Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
First-wave feminism wikipedia , lookup
Slut-shaming wikipedia , lookup
Feminist movement wikipedia , lookup
Women in ancient Egypt wikipedia , lookup
Raunch aesthetics wikipedia , lookup
New feminism wikipedia , lookup
Anarcha-feminism wikipedia , lookup
Feminism in the United States wikipedia , lookup
Halah Buhaisi and Komal Patel Rel A42 B Dr. Teipen November 18, 2004 Con: Islamic dress is not oppressive while Western dress is oppressive. THE HISTORY OF HIJAB IN ISLAM Though the Qur’an does not specifically mandate the wearing of the veil, the Qur’anic verse from which most Muslims derive the commandment to wear the veil can be found in Sura 33. 53. O you who believe! do not enter the houses of the Prophet unless permission is given…. And when you ask of [the Prophet’s wives] any goods, ask of them from behind a curtain [hijāb]; this is purer for your hearts and (for) their hearts; and it does not behove you that you should give trouble to the Messenger of Allah, nor that you should marry his wives after him ever; surely this is grievous in the sight of Allah. This verse was revealed during the Prophet’s marriage to Zaynab. Muhammad sought to be alone with his wife, but guests would not leave the home, so the revealed verse was intended to create privacy for the Prophet’s wives. Thus, this verse is not addressed to Muslim women as a whole but merely towards Prophet Muhammad’s wives. Furthermore, the term hijab does not regard women’s apparel; it simply means a “curtain.” REASONS FOR CHOOSING TO WEAR ISLAMIC FEMALE DRESS According to Islamic scholar Katherine Bullock, there are four reasons why women adopt Islamic standards of dress (Bullock 22-53). 1. Political Protest a. In 1935, Reza Shah in Iran banned the veil in order to westernize the nation. The law which was in effect until 1941 was very unpopular with non-elites who did not have exposure to Western ideals, and women wore the veil as a symbol of protest against the law. b. A similar situation occurred in Turkey Kemal Ataturuk discouraged the wearing of the veil, but did not ban it. This measure was not popular across class lines, so here again women of lower social class wore the veil as an act of defiance (Ahmed 164). c. In modern-day France, the veil, among other displays of religious symbols, has been banned in public schools. Several young Muslim women have been suspended because of their adamant refusal to throw off the veil (Davis 221-35). 2. Religious Obligation a. As already discussed, most Muslim scholars believe the verse mentioning hijab is not addressed to Muslim women in general. Nonetheless, many women extend the idea of males living according to the exemplary lifestyle of the Prophet to females living according to the example of the Prophet’s wives. 3. Continued Access to the Public Sphere a. When Reza Shah banned the veil in Iran, many young girls were not allowed to go to school unveiled (Brooks 24). 2 4. Expression of Personal Identity a. Many Muslim women the veil as “an assertion of their identity which reflects the syntheses of modernity and tradition” (Shaikh 152). WESTERN STANDARDS OF DRESS OPPRESS! According to Muslim author and feminist Fatima Mernissi, it is Western standards of dress, not Muslim standards of dress, that oppress women. In “Size 6: The Western Women’s Harem,” the final chapter of the novel Scheherazade Goes West, Mernissi recounts an incident that occurs in an American department store in New York. Mernissi is in search of a skirt, and when she cannot find one in her, she asks the sales associate for assistance, the sales replies, “ ‘You are too big.’ ‘I am too big compared to what?’ … ‘Compared to a size 6,’ came the saleslady’s reply” (209). Mernissi is shocked with Western women’s infatuation with their looks especially their pre-occupation with size. She argues that in their efforts to conform to male-defined standards of what entails a beautiful woman, women are harming their bodies physically and emotionally. Mernissi points out that both she and the saleslady are in their late 50s, yet the saleslady has the physique of a pre-pubescent girl. Thus, Mernissi concludes that “Unlike the Muslim man, who uses space to establish the male domination by excluding women from the popular arena, the Western man manipulates time and light” (213). By overemphasizing the flesh—boobs and curves—women present themselves as intellectually inferior to men because female dress is not comparable with male suits. Much of female business attire exposes cleavage and legs, whereas male business dress is intended for business—males are not showing their biceps or pecs. Such obsession with appeasing the male-defined 3 standards of beauty can unconsciously lead women to take more drastic measures, as exemplified in the custom of Chinese women binding their feet because Chinese males like small, baby feet (Mernissi 215). Thus, women are not only intellectually inferior; this example illustrates how Chinese women have also become physically inferior. CONCLUSION To explain why many of the elites of the Muslim world decided that women should not wear hijab, Mostafa Hashem Sherif says, “In their frenetic rush to mimic the European and North American cultural and economical model,” these groups began to see the veil as a “symbol of retardation and of women’s backwardness and subjugation” (Sherif 151). However, if examined “European and North American cultural” standards of dress are oppressive. 4 WORKS CITED Ahmed, Leila. Women and Gender in Islam. Yale University Press: New Haven, 1992. Brooks, Geraldine. Nine Parts of Desire: The Hidden World of Islamic Women.” New York: Bantam Doubleday Publishing Group, Inc., 1995. Bullock, Katherine. “Challenging Media Representations of the Veil: Contemporary Muslim Women’s Re-veiling Movement.” The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences 3 no. 3. 2000: 22-53. Davis, Derek H. “Reacting to France’s Ban: Headscarves and other Religious Attire in American Public Schools.” Journal of Church and State 46 no. 2. Spr 2004: 22135. Mernissi, Fatema. Scheherazade Goes West.Washington Square Press: New York: 2001. Shaikh, Sa’diyya. “Transforming Feminisms: Islam, Women, and Gender Justice.” Progressive Muslims. Ed. Omid Safi. Oxford: One World, 2003: 152. Sherif, Mostafa Hashem. “What is Hijab?” The Muslim World LXXVII no. 3-4. July-Oct. 1987: 151-153. 5