Download Disease Essay

Whether the government has legal authority to quarantine an entire town for
the purpose of preventing the spread of a deadly contagious disease to the
entire nation?
Laiza Gomes 8.1
17/11/15
Humanties
In this essay I will be explaining “Whether the government has legal authority to
eradicate an entire town for the purpose of preventing the spread of a deadly
contagious disease to the entire nation.” This question has a two-sided answer,
because people that work CDC and other organizations think that it’s something that
can stop a worldwide spread but people that live in these places being quarantined or
isolated think otherwise.
The government only allows quarantine or isolation operations when it’s serious and
can potentially get over the borders and spread worldwide like the Ebola incident for
example. Theses operations have a completely different working system, as Isolation
separation of people known or have signs of the disease and Quarantine when you are
restricted from movement and they are provided with meals, sleeping
accommodations, and other necessities. They would stay there until the risk of
developing the disease or spreading the disease is over. It’s known that there is
twenty U.S. Quarantine Stations, located at ports of entry and land border crossings,
use these public health practices as part of a comprehensive Quarantine System that
serves to limit the introduction of infectious diseases into the United States and to
prevent their spread and not cause a huge worldwide spread.
Now the people being isolated or quarantined think that it’s something almost brutal
as there taken from their home or are stuck inside a town with an infectious disease.
They aren’t given much of a choice when theses operations are done and stop them
from leaving the borders, some describe isolation as being refugees others find it a
way of protecting themselves and families from this thing attacking people’s organs.
According to a survey conducted for the Trust for America's Health in 2007, "nearly 9
out of 10 Americans say they would abide by a voluntary quarantine and stay home in
the case of an outbreak of a pandemic flu so really it depends on who you talk to
really. But at the end of the day people realize they are being protected and a chance
of living without this disease and they are granted with meals, sleeping
accommodations, and other necessities.
In conclusion it’s a smart operation but it needs to be explained to the public in more
detail so they are aware of what is happening. Use of quarantine or isolation powers
may create sensitive issues related to civil liberties, which could cause rebelling
against the government in over two states. Quarantine and isolation are usually
undertaken voluntarily but in rare circumstances can be required by public health
authorities, so really it depends how bad the situation is of this deadly disease going
around and how the outbreak could attack. This is a working progress operation in
my opinion. My final decision is that it should be legally aloud because it’s an
operation stopping infectious disease from going worldwide I understand it may
invade people’s, lives but what’s more important a state being infected or the whole
world.
Bibliography:
 com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

MD, Web. "Quarantine and Isolation for Infectious Diseases." WebMD. WebMD, 8 May 2015. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)

(MD, Web. "Quarantine and Isolation for Infectious Diseases." WebMD. WebMD, 8 May 2015. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
Date: ______________________________________
Name: ___________________________________
Topic: _____________________________________
Class: ___________________________________
Key Words
Quarantine
Isolation
Authorities
Disease
infectious
protect
borders
exposed
separation
spread
contagious
outbreak
prevent
stations
Notes/Pictures/ Diagrams
● Quarantine and Isolation are legal authorities that rarely happen. They only happen
when they need to contain a contagious disease.(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations."
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
● Isolation: Separation of people known or have signs of the disease.
● Quarantine: When you are restricted from movement and they are provided with meals,
sleeping accommodations, and other necessities. They would stay there until the risk of
developing the disease or spreading the disease is over.
●
● Use of quarantine or isolation powers may create sensitive issues related to civil
liberties.(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
● According to a survey conducted for the Trust for America's Health in 2007, "nearly 9
out of 10 Americans say they would abide by a voluntary quarantine and stay home in
the case of an outbreak of a pandemic flu.(.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 15 Jan. 2014.
Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
● Twenty U.S. Quarantine Stations, located at ports of entry and land border crossings, use
these public health practices as part of a comprehensive Quarantine System that serves
to limit the introduction of infectious diseases into the United States and to prevent their
spread. (.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
● If they are asked to sta
● Quarantine officers are responsible for activities as various as responding to reports of
illnesses, to screening cargo and inspecting animals and animal products, to monitoring
the health of and collecting any medical information of new immigrants, refugees,
asylees, and parolees. (.com, NCSL. "Quarantine Stations." Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 15 Jan. 2014. Web. 13 Nov.
2015.)
● If they are asked to stay in a place away from home they are provided with meals,
sleeping accommodations, and other necessities. They would stay there until the risk of
developing the disease or spreading the disease is over.(MD, Web. "Quarantine and
Isolation for Infectious Diseases." WebMD. WebMD, 8 May 2015. Web. 13 Nov.
2015.)
●
● Quarantine and isolation are usually undertaken voluntarily but in rare circumstances
can be required by public health authorities. (MD, Web. "Quarantine and Isolation
for Infectious Diseases." WebMD. WebMD, 8 May 2015. Web. 13 Nov. 2015.)
http://www.ncsl.org/research/health/state-quarantine-and-isolation-statutes.aspx
Summary:The government only allows operations like this when it’s serious and can potentially get over the borders and spread
worldwide like the Ebola incident for example. This operations have a completely different working system, as Isolation separation of
people known or have signs of the disease and Quarantine when you are restricted from movement and they are provided with meals,
sleeping accommodations, and other necessities. They would stay there until the risk of developing the disease or spreading the
disease is over. It’s known that there is twenty U.S. Quarantine Stations, located at ports of entry and land border crossings, use these
public health practices as part of a comprehensive Quarantine System that serves to limit the introduction of infectious diseases into the
United States and to prevent their spread. and not cause a huge worldwide spread.
Title:
Origin
Purpose
Value
Limitation
National Conference of
State Legislatures
NCSL is a government
organization source.
This source is intended
for adults and some
teens but specific ages.
It was written to
inform people about
state Quarantine and
isolation statues.
The value of this source
is that it’s connected to
the government which
usually makes
information more
accurate.
It’s only one open
making it a Bias and it’s
just a government
point of view and not
the public's.
National Conference of
State Legislatures
Center for Disease
Control and Prevention
It’s a government
organization source.
This source is intended
for teens and adults. It
is was written to tell
people the difference
between Quarantine
and isolation also if it’s
allowed to happen.
The value of this source
is that it’s not only
telling it’s allowed but
also the differences in
the operations.
The limitation is it’s
only facts not
subjective when
explaining the
differences.
WebMD
Is a medical website
that talks about
different diseases and
conditions.
This source is intended
for preteens and up, it
was written to inform
and give people
knowledge of diseases
and conditions also to
persuade people.
The value of this source
it’s a medical website
so it’s quite accurate
it’s reliable
The limitation is it’s
only giving you a
medical/scientific
perspective so it’s quite
bias.
Source 1- Why- I chose this source because it’s a government website and how to inform people of the process and how it
actually works but one thing that I wish was improved was that they had public opinion.
Source 2- Why- I chose this source because it’s also a government organization, also because it was written to the define the
differences between the two operations.
Source 3- Why- I chose this source because it is a medical website and how it’s not only for preteens but almost all ages, but there
limitations as it’s only facts.