* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Download Unit 6 - BCPSS
Survey
Document related concepts
Transcript
American Government Baltimore City Public School System 2007 Unit 6 Public Policy How To Use This Guide This is the instructional guide for Unit Six Public Policy. The guides have not been designed to be the “end all and be all” of social studies. They have been designed as a way to meet the state standards in a meaningful manner and allow time for re-teaching and/or extension. As with all new curriculum, time for extension may only become available after the teacher has run through the curriculum once or twice. The guide is to be read in its entirety before teaching any of the lessons in order to get the “big picture.” This helps guide planning, preparation, and implementation. It allows the teacher to plan for re-teaching and extension activities in a meaningful way. Begin by reading the Essential Concepts and Possible Essential Questions from the Maryland Voluntary State Curriculum. Those two items explain why it is necessary to study this unit. The sessions will build to express the ideas in the Enduring Understanding. Next review the WHAT. These are the MSDE indicators and session objectives. This is what MSDE wants kids to be able to know and do. These are placed in the sessions where they are taught. The rest of the guide and what you do in the classroom is the HOW. WHY? Essential Concepts • Economic decisions made by governments, businesses, groups, and individuals directly affect our current and future daily life and standard of living. • In an interdependent world, U.S. foreign policy and international organizations play an increasingly important role in addressing political, economic, and social problems. • Public policy begins with the people whose interests, problems, and concerns are addressed as government provides for the common good (general welfare) and establishes justice. Possible Essential Questions • What are the economic, political and social factors influence domestic and foreign policy decision making? • How do the media, political parties, special-interest groups, lobbyists, Political Action Committees (PACs) and public opinion influence the development of domestic public policy? • How do global concerns, trade, terrorism, world health, and poverty affect our relationships with other countries? • What should be the role of the United States as a member of various international organizations and alliances? • What is the role of regions, population and other demographic factors on voting patterns, funding and development of government policy? • How does the state government develop policy for domestic issues in Maryland? • What are the economic costs and benefits are associated with foreign and domestic policy decision-making? • • How does the government address market failures? How effectively does fiscal and monetary policy improve our economy and provide for our citizens? Source: MSDE Government Online Course Unit 6: Public Policy Title Demographics and Public Policy Making Public Policy Objectives Domestic Policy Define demographics Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States Determine the influence demographic factors, such as race, age, education, ethnicity and gender have on voting patterns (3.1.1 c) Analyze patterns, trends, and projections of population in regions and how these may affect the environment, society and government policy (3.1.1 d) Analyze the influence of demographic factors on the formation and implementation of government policy and funding decisions, such as education, health care and social security (3.1.1 e) Define public health and health care issues and evaluate existing government policy, such as smoking in public places, Medicare and Medicaid (1.1.3 f) Examine the impact of government decisions on individuals and groups, such as approval policies of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), environmental standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), regulations by the Maryland Department of the Environment (1.2.3 f) Evaluate the role of state and national governments concerning issues related to public safety and maintaining order, such as crime prevention, changes in driver’s license requirements, seat belt laws, and immunization shots (1.2.3 g) Evaluate how the principles of economic costs, benefits, and opportunity cost are used to address public policy issues, such as environmental and healthcare concerns (4.1.2 e) Assessment Limits Demographic factors Entitlements – Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental National government agencies, State actions affecting rights, order and safety Opportunity cost, economic equity, economic security Regulatory agencies that respond to social issues and/or market failures: - Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) - Food and Drug Administration Describe the purpose, roles and responsibilities of regulatory agencies: Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Federal Communications Commission (FCC) (4.1.3 b) Maryland and Public Policy Monetary Policy 1. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 2. Explain how geographic characteristics and shared interests stimulate regional cooperation between governments (3.1.3 a) 3. Analyze how the population shifts in and between regions affects the formation and implementation of government policy, such as the relocation or loss of industry and urban flight (3.1.3 b) 4. Analyze the importance of regional characteristics and interests including economic development, natural resources, climate and environmental issues in formulating local, state, and national government policy (3.1.3 c) Describe how the Federal Reserve System uses the three tools of monetary policy, including open market operations, changes in the discount (interest) rate and changes in the reserve requirements to influence the economy(4.1.4 f) Describe the effectiveness of monetary policy in achieving economic growth, full employment and price stability (4.1.4 g) Explain how inflation reduces buying power and may contribute to a slow down in the economy (4.1.4 j) (FDA) - Federal Trade Commission (FTC) - Federal Communications Commission (FCC) - Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Population growth and regional issues Business cycle, monetary policy (Federal Reserve actions) and fiscal policy (Legislative and Executive actions) and their effect on economic performance, full employment, and price stability. Tools of monetary policy (Federal Reserve SystemFED) including the reserve requirement, interest rates, and open-market operations (buying and selling of government Land Use Public Policy Case Study: Smart Growth 5. Evaluate the effect that international, national, and regional interests have on shaping environmental policy, such as logging forested areas, oil drilling, pollution, nuclear power, or alternative energy sources (1.1.3 e) 6. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 7. Evaluate the way national, state, and local governments develop policy to address land use and environmental issues, such as urban sprawl, Smart Growth and commercial use of public (3.1.2 e) Evaluate the effect that international, national, and regional interests have on shaping environmental policy, such as logging forested areas, oil drilling, pollution, nuclear power, or alternative energy sources (1.1.3 e) Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States Evaluate the way national, state, and local governments develop policy to address land use and environmental issues, such as urban sprawl, Smart Growth and commercial use of public (3.1.2 e) securities). Tools of fiscal policy including increasing /decreasing taxes and tariffs and/or spending. Measures of economic performance including Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Consumer Price Index (CPI), and unemployment rate. Entitlements: Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental Land use, smart growth, and urban sprawl Entitlements: Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental Land use, smart growth, and urban sprawl Measuring the Economy Explain how the Consumer Price Index (CPI), the unemployment rate and the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) measure economic performance (4.1.4 h) Explain how economic instability, including periods of growth and recession is a part of the free enterprise system (4.1.4 i) Explain how inflation reduces buying power and may contribute to a slow down in the economy (4.1.4 j) Business cycle, monetary policy (Federal Reserve actions) and fiscal policy (Legislative and Executive actions) and their effect on economic performance, full employment, and price stability. Tools of monetary policy (Federal Reserve SystemFED) including the reserve requirement, interest rates, and open-market operations (buying and selling of government securities). Tools of fiscal policy including increasing /decreasing taxes and tariffs and/or spending. Measures of economic performance including Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Consumer Price Index (CPI), and unemployment rate. Pre-Assessment Pre-assessment Overview Baltimore City public school students were introduced to key terms and concepts of public policy in elementary and middle school, and in United States History. The pre-assessment is designed to provide insight into the strengths and weaknesses in the public policy understandings of your students. This pre-assessment includes 35 selected response questions to determine student understanding of government concepts and vocabulary necessary for the Government High School Assessment. Use the information from the preassessment to help determine which students need acceleration or support on topics of HSA and this unit. Indicators/Objectives 1. Evaluate the principles of federalism, representative democracy, popular sovereignty, consent of the governed, separation of powers, checks and balances, rule of law, limited government, majority rule and how they protect individual rights and impact the functioning of government (1.1.2 a) 2. Identify the rights in the Bill of Rights and how they protect individuals and limit the power of government (1.1.1 i) 3. Describe the role of the United States Congress and the Maryland General Assembly in developing fiscal policy and the approval of budgets 4. Describe the structure, powers and authority of the executive branch on the federal, state, and local levels 5. Describe the powers, structure and organization of the Federal and Maryland court systems Assessment Limits Evaluate how principles assist or impede functions of government. Concepts: federalism, separation of powers, checks and balances, judicial review, representative democracy, limited government, rule of law, individual rights and responsibilities, consent of the governed, majority rule, popular sovereignty, equal protection, and eminent domain Federal and Maryland State government: Powers structure and organization of the Executive Branch Federal (Congress- House of Representatives & Senate), State (General Assembly – House of Delegates & State Senate), and Local Legislative Branches: Structure, Powers, Selection of Leaders and the Electoral Process Cases included: Marbury v. Madison, McCulloch v. Maryland, Plessy v. Ferguson, Brown v. Board of Education, Miranda v. Arizona, Gideon v. Wainwright, Tinker v. Des Moines Board of Education, and New Jersey v. T.L.O. National government agencies, State actions affecting rights, order and safety Political parties, interest groups, lobbyists, candidates, citizens, and the impact of the media on elections, elected officials and public opinion United Nations, NATO, NAFTA, IMF, World Bank, and the International Red Cross human rights, economic sanctions, and foreign aid Forms of Government Population growth and regional issue Political causes and effects of reapportionment, redistricting and voting patterns. Tools of fiscal policy Regulatory: agencies that respond to social issues and/or market failures: Opportunity cost, economic equity, economic security Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge. Pose the following question: • What is government? • What are the purposes of government? • What are some of the most important principles of government? Review a few responses. Use student responses to explain that government affects us daily. Remember – these questions and the discussion are to get students thinking about government. 2. Assessing – Principles of Government. Distribute and review Public Policy Pre-assessment. Explain that the pretest will not affect student grades, but will be used to plan instruction. Provide time for students to independently complete the preassessment. 3. Follow-Up. Use the information from the pretest to support or accelerate instruction. Keep in mind that all students are expected to learn the same concepts and content to meet state and local expectations of learning. Use this data to guide instruction. Name Date Public Policy Pretest Directions: This pretest will provide your teacher with information about what you know about participation in government. This test will not affect your grade, but will be used to help you learn what is necessary to pass later tests. 1. Which of these principles of government is demonstrated when the governor of Maryland vetoes a bill? A. federalism B. popular sovereignty C. checks and balances D. representative democracy 2. The United States Constitution is called a “living document” because it A. can be changed when needed B. outlines the government's structure C. refers to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness D. supports every citizen's right to make a good living Read the excerpt below. The President in every possible instance shall consult with Congress before introducing United States Armed Forces into hostilities [military conflicts]...and after every such introduction shall consult regularly with the Congress until United States Armed Forces are no longer engaged in hostilities.... The War Powers Act of 1973 3. Based on the excerpt, the War Powers Act was most likely issued in response to A. protest against drafting women B. lack of preparedness in the armed forces C. expansion by the President of his role as Commander in Chief D. attempts by the Supreme Court to control the Department of Defense 4. Which of these is a responsibility of the Maryland General Assembly? A. approving the annual state budget B. supervising the Maryland State Police C. reviewing criminal appeals D. vetoing unpopular laws 5. Study the political cartoon below. . The cartoon suggests that some citizens A. B. C. D. believe that the justice system is unworkable are unwilling to break the law believe that the right to a trial by jury is unnecessary are unwilling to accept their responsibilities 6. Which of these examples best reflects the principle of representative democracy? A. Citizens of a town vote on all government issues. B. The leader of a country makes all government decisions. C. A judge finds a defendant guilty of a crime. D. An elected official proposes a bill in the state legislature. 7. Which of these is part of the legislative branch of the United States government? A. the Cabinet B. the President C. the Supreme Court D. the House of Representatives 8. Which of these officials is responsible for making laws? A. a federal judge B. the governor of a state C. a United States senator D. the Secretary of Defense 9. Which of these is a purpose of Social Security? A. to provide income for retirees B. to regulate the health care industry C. to give relocation assistance to immigrants D. to encourage taxpayer contributions to charities 10. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) offers home loans at low interest rates to low-income borrowers who live in rural communities. What is most likely the purpose of this government program? A. to increase ownership of property B. to regulate the lending industry C. to encourage people to move D. to raise tax revenues 11. The Clean Air Act of 1970 set broad national goals for the reduction of air pollution. Which of these was a direct result of this act? A. Prices of automobiles declined. B. Fewer automobiles traveled on highways. C. Automobile makers redesigned automobile engines. D. Automobile smog problems were eliminated. 12. When a famous actress was accused of wrong-doing, the newspapers covered the event extensively. The actress was convicted of the crime, but appealed the verdict on the grounds that the pre-trial publicity prejudiced the jury. Which of these rights is in conflict with the freedom of the press? A. the right to a speedy trial B. the right to present witnesses C. the right to legal counsel D. the right to a fair trial 13. The United States government is allowed to restrict publication of information that A. criticizes presidential decisions B. supports one political party C. endangers national security D. promotes legal reforms 14. Which of these Supreme Court decisions established the doctrine of "separate but equal"? A. Plessy v. Ferguson B. Marbury v. Madison C. Tinker v. Des Moines School District D. Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka 15. Which of these cases helped establish the right of the Supreme Court to review the constitutionality of federal law? A. Marbury v. Madison B. McCulloch v. Maryland C. Plessy v. Ferguson D. Brown v. Board of Education 16. Which of these Supreme Court cases established supremacy of the federal government over the states? A. Plessy v. Ferguson B. New Jersey v. T.L.O C. Marbury v. Madison D. McCulloch v. Maryland 17. Which of the following best illustrates the reason Congress passes civil rights legislation? A. to promote equity B. to establish better legal aid C. to solve housing shortages D. to increase school funding 18. Which of these best describes a goal of affirmative action legislation? A. to encourage young people to go into politics B. to promote educational opportunities for minorities C. to require employers to provide health benefits to all workers D. to establish job training courses for the economically disadvantaged 19. Which of these government actions is most associated with due process of law? A. creating affirmative action programs B. informing the accused of their rights C. maintaining order during times of crisis D. establishing guidelines for workplace safety 20. The Fourteenth Amendment limits the state government's ability to A. raise the federal income tax B. use military forces in peacetime C. regulate interstate trade and commerce D. place restrictions on qualified voters 21. Which of these is a characteristic of an authoritarian system of government? A. popular sovereignty B. equal protection under the law C. restrictions of personal freedoms D. majority rules with minority rights 22. Which of these is important to a successful democracy? A. discouraging criticism of elected officials B. ensuring that only the most capable citizens receive an education C. producing policies that address a variety of citizens' concerns D. refusing to allow presidents to meet with leaders of hostile countries 23. In the United States, the central government and the state governments share power. Which of these terms best describes this type of government? A. representative democracy B. federal system C. confederate system D. direct democracy 24. Which of these is a purpose of the International Red Cross? A. to assist people who are victims of war B. to make trade agreements with businesses C. to provide military aid to countries being invaded D. to loan money to countries with economic problems 25. Which of these statements about the United Nations (UN) is true? A. Its membership rules exclude poor nations. B. Its policies discourage international cooperation. C. Its councils elect leaders for many nations. D. Its goals include international stability. 26. Which of these is the most likely impact on counties experiencing population growth? A. a decrease in revenue from local sales tax B. a decrease in housing costs C. an increase in the need for public services D. an increase in school closings 27. Which of these sources would be most reliable for determining interstate migration patterns? A. public school records B. voter registration cards C. property tax assessments D. government census counts 28. Which region of Maryland would benefit most from research on Chesapeake Bay's infectious water diseases? A. Eastern Shore B. Central Maryland C. Western Maryland D. Baltimore–Washington area 29. Due to large financial losses in the American automobile industry, the United States once set limits on the number of cars it imported. This response is most likely an example of government policy being shaped by A. national interests B. international interests C. state interests D. regional interests 30. Which of these best describes a mixed economy? A. The government decides who will produce goods and services. B. Natural resources are owned and controlled by the government. C. The government's only role in the economy is to ensure competition. D. Businesses are regulated by the government to protect the public's interest. 31. Which of these would most likely take place in a command economy? A. Industrial leaders agree to control prices. B. Stock traders create wealth through buying and selling. C. Government leaders decide how goods will be produced. D. Consumers decide the sales policies of business owners. 32. Sugar substitutes are used in many diet soft drinks. They were tested for many years before being approved for use. Which of these regulatory agencies is responsible for giving this approval? A. the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) B. the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) C. the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) D. the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) 33. Which of these is most closely associated with an economic recession? A. an increase in stock prices B. a decrease in demand for labor C. a decrease in the minimum wage D. an increase in consumer spending 34. Which of these best reflects how the federal government manages the economy through fiscal policy? A. taxing and spending B. buying and selling securities C. controlling the money supply D. controlling interest rates 35. What is the opportunity cost for state governments that spend state money during natural disasters? A. Main highways between states may be blocked. B. Prices for snow removal equipment may increase. C. Other services offered by the states may have to be cut. D. State governments may receive additional highway funds. Source: Public Release Items from Government HSA Session 1: Demographics and Public Policy Overview Public policy involves all elements of the course: levels and branches of government, principles, citizen participation, data interpretation, and influencing policies. In this session, students analyze demographic factors that influence government decisions. In the second session, students examine making public policy. Objectives: 1. Define demographics 2. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 3. Determine the influence demographic factors, such as race, age, education, ethnicity and gender have on voting patterns (3.1.1 c) 4. Analyze patterns, trends, and projections of population in regions and how these may affect the environment, society and government policy (3.1.1 d) 5. Analyze the influence of demographic factors on the formation and implementation of government policy and funding decisions, such as education, health care and social security (3.1.1 e) Assessment Limits • Demographic factors Key Questions 1. Why does the government make the policies that it does? 2. How do the characteristics (demographics) of the people influence government decision-making? 3. What are the economic, political and social factors that influence domestic policy decision-making? 4. How does the state government develop policy for domestic issues in Maryland? Key Terms Demographics Census Public policy Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Census. Pose the following questions: • What is a census? • What types of data/information is available from the census? • How might government officials use the data from the census? Review a few student responses. 2. Developing Understanding – Before and During Reading – Demographics. Explain that the Constitution requires a census, a count of the population, every ten years. The census provides demographic data. Define demographics: Demographics - Characteristics of the population including: age, sex, race, family size, level of education, occupation, income and location of residence Direct students to record the definition in their notebooks. Explain that executives and legislators and all levels of government use this information to create public policy. Define public policy: Public Policy - government responses to public issues; all of the goals a government sets. Distribute “Demographics and Public Policy” reading and set the purpose to read: • explain how demographics affect public policy • describe examples of public policy • explain how demographic data is used • explain how the government provides for services Note: Instructional Decision. Questions are embedded throughout the Demographics and Public Policy reading. Students may respond on this reading or in their notebooks. It is advisable to direct students through this reading this part-by-part, stopping and reviewing the questions and re-teaching as necessary. 3. Checking for Understanding – After Reading – Demographics. Conduct a brief class discussion. Ask: • How do the characteristics (demographics) of the people influence government decision-making? Distribute the Demographics Case Study and direct students to study the graphs and respond to the questions. Use data from the case study to inform instruction. Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), does not match this lesson nor does it meet the needs of HSA. Demographics and Public Policy Part 1: Public Policy Public policy is the study of specific problems in a society and how the government responds to these problems. Public policy begins with the people whose interests, problems, and concerns are addressed by government. Public policy may include: • Tax policy • Social Security and Medicare for the elderly • Education services such as interpreters for the deaf or teachers for students who may not speak English • Safety requirements for homes and new cars such as airbags • Environmental laws that require special trash pick ups for chemicals such as paint and oil Think about. . . • What public policies affect your life? • How does the government decide which policies to make? Part 2: Demographics Demographics are the physical characteristics of a population of people. These characteristics may include gender, age, race, education, occupation, marital status, or the number of children in a family. Every ten years, the Census Bureau takes a census. This census asks questions about the characteristics of the people. Typically, the U.S. Census Bureau provides the demographic data that tells us what the population of the country, of the state, of the county, or of the community in which we live is like. The Census Bureau collects and organizes this information and national, state, and local governments use it to make decisions. Source: MSDE Government Online Course Part 3: Examining Demographic Data The Census collects demographic data which includes information about gender, age, race, education, occupation, marital status, or the number of children in a family. This part of the lesson focuses on one area of demographic data, AGE. Look at the graph. Have you ever since a graph like this? One of the methods used for examining age demographics is a population pyramid. A population pyramid tells a lot about the population. It may show • The distribution of population by age • The distribution of the population that is male or female • The distribution of the ages in the population Source: MSDE Government Online Course Part 4: Population in Maryland Study the Age Distribution Population pyramid for Maryland and use the information to answer the following questions. Maryland Source: http://www.censusscope.org/us/s24/print_chart_age.html 1. What age group had the greatest population in Maryland in 2000? 0-4 years of age 35-39 years of age 40-44 years of age 85+ years of age 2. What age represents the smallest part of the population of Maryland in 2000? 15-19 years of age 65-69 years of age 80-84 years of age 85+ years of age 3. Among the 85+ age group, which gender has the most people? Male Female 4. Study the age distribution above 60 years old in Maryland. What can we say about life expectancy in relation to gender? 5. Examine the information about people between the ages 20 and 55. What prediction can you make about the population in 25 years? Source: MSDE Government Online Course Part 5: Comparing Demographic Data in Maryland The Census Bureau breaks down demographic data on a national, state, and a local level. This way the government can compare what is happening in local communities to the national and statewide trends. With this information, the government can make policies that meet the needs of the people in a particular area or region. Demographics in Kent County and Baltimore City In this activity we will compare the age distribution in two areas of Maryland. Kent County Source: http://www.censusscope.org/us/s24/print_chart_age.html Examine this population pyramid for Kent County, Maryland, and respond to the questions that follow. 1. Which of the following best summarizes the demographics for Kent County? a. Young families with children b. Older adults approaching retirement age c. Elderly individuals collecting Social Security 2. Which of the following best explains why the 25-29 year old age group is so small? a. The men and women have been drafted by the military b. Widespread disease struck the county when this group was young c. Jobs for these individuals may be scarce and hard to find Source: MSDE Government Online Course Now examine the population pyramid for Baltimore City. Then respond to the questions that follow. Baltimore City Source: http://www.censusscope.org/us/s24/print_chart_age.html 1. Which of the following best summarizes the demographics for Baltimore City? a. Families with children b. Older adults approaching retirement age c. Elderly individuals collecting Social Security 2. Which of the following best explains why the pyramid is like a “square” for the individuals under 45? a. There is little to any employment opportunities in the city. b. Many of Baltimore City's residents are at an age when having children is possible and popular c. The public transportation system does not provide easy access for commuters and students 3. In your notebook, write a statement about how Kent County and Baltimore City's population pyramid are different. Source: MSDE Government Online Course Part 6: Government decision-making and demographic information How does demographic data inform the government? Data from census information or from sources like the population pyramid, inferences or conclusions are drawn about the people of Maryland. This information is used by the government, candidates for office and citizens to inform decision making. The government analyzes the characteristics of the population using data from graphs like the population pyramid in the last activity and uses the information to make decisions. Think about . . . •Which of these local population statistics would be most useful in deciding where to construct a public high school? political party identity family composition occupation religion For example, if a great number of the population is school-age, the government may consider building more schools. Also, if there is only a small number of people in the “economically active population,” that may affect the amount of taxes raised to support government services. Demographic groups may also organize to influence the government about issues of importance to them. For example, the elderly may join together in groups such as AARP (American Association of Retired Persons) to write letters to elected representatives about medical or housing for that group. Or they may contact representatives about Social Security benefits. Additionally, candidates for political office study demographic data to help them develop their platforms for election. By knowing the demographic information about an area, a candidate can identify issues that voters may want addressed. Here are some examples of these services: • Park and recreation facilities • Senior citizen facilities • Educational services such as schools and libraries • Maintaining and building roads • Social Service programs (for example: health clinics, food programs) • Access to personal growth programs such as yoga, gourmet cooking lessons, hiking, golf • Public transportation for commuting to work The government considers how to provide for these services. To meet the needs of the community, the government can: • increase or decrease taxes • decide where to spend money • award tax credits for saving for a college education, daycare or retirement Think about . . . • What are some of the services that the government may provide in your county or city? • How can the government provide these services? Source: MSDE Government Online Course Demographics Case Study You will use the information displayed on the Population Pyramid Graphs for Kent County and Baltimore City to complete the case study. Kent County Baltimore City 1. Which of the following communities would be most interested in issues related to Social Security? 2. Which of the following communities would be most interested in issues related to providing daycare facilities and early childhood initiatives? 3. Which of the following communities might invest in research to assess what the needs of the 25-40 year old age group are? 4. Which of the following communities would research how to attract and to retain individuals entering early retirement? 5. What type of public policy decisions would most meet the needs of Kent County’s citizens? 6. What type of public policy decisions would most meet the needs of Baltimore City’s citizens? 7. You have been hired by a candidate running for a seat in the House of Delegates from Baltimore City. What issues would you advise a candidate running for office to address? Source: MSDE Government Online Course Lesson 2: Making Public Policy Overview During this lesson, students study why the government makes the public policy. Then students “research” some public policy issues and discuss how citizens and groups can influence government decisions. In the final session, the issue of monetary policy is examined. Objectives: 1. Define public health and health care issues and evaluate existing government policy, such as smoking in public places, Medicare and Medicaid (1.1.3 f) 2. Examine the impact of government decisions on individuals and groups, such as approval policies of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), environmental standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), regulations by the Maryland Department of the Environment (1.2.3 f) 3. Evaluate the role of state and national governments concerning issues related to public safety and maintaining order, such as crime prevention, changes in driver’s license requirements, seat belt laws, and immunization shots (1.2.3 g 4. Evaluate how the principles of economic costs, benefits, and opportunity cost are used to address public policy issues, such as environmental and healthcare concerns (4.1.2 e) 5. Describe the purpose, roles and responsibilities of regulatory agencies: Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Federal Communications Commission (FCC) (4.1.3 b) 6. Analyze the effect of trade and trade policy including: free trade agreements, embargoes, tariffs and economic sanctions on relationships with other countries (2.1.1 j) Assessment Limits Entitlements – Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental National government agencies, State actions affecting rights, order and safety Opportunity cost, economic equity, economic security Regulatory agencies that respond to social issues and/or market failures: Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) • Policies of United States government that promote or fail to promote relationships with other countries include: national defense (military), arms control, and security of other nations, trade, human rights, economic sanctions, and foreign aid Key Questions 1. Why does the government make the policies that it does? 2. What impact do these policies have on the citizens, groups, and businesses? 3. How is the government influenced by citizens when making these policies? Key Terms Public policy Regulation Federal Communications Commissions (FCC) Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Public Policy. Place the no-smoking sign transparency on the overhead. Direct students to discuss the questions on the transparency. Ask: • Who made a no-smoking policy? • How can you influence public policy and those making these policies? 2. Developing Understanding – Before and During Reading – Public Policy. Explain that governments at all levels created smoking policies based on the needs of the people. Smoking affects the health of people and thus affects their jobs, the economy, etc. Governments create public policy in all areas of our lives. Divide students into small groups/pairs. Direct students to the appropriate section of the textbook (Remy, Chapter 21, Social and Domestic Policy) to read about selected public policies. Direct students to create the following chart to record information: Public Policy Issue/problem Which level, branch, or agency of government is involved in this issue? Trade Regulating business (monopolies) Consumer protection Protecting Environment – air and water Social Security Health Insurance (Medicaid/Medicare) Public Health Set the purpose to read: • explain major public policy issues • identify which level, branch, or agency of government is involved in the issue? 3. Checking for Understanding – After Reading – Public Policy. Combine groups to share/compare information. Direct students to add/correct charts. Conduct a brief discussion of these areas of public policy. Ask: • What impact do public policies have on citizens, groups, and businesses? • How do citizens, media, interest groups influence the development of public policies like smoking or clean air and water or cleaning the Chesapeake Bay? Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), Chapter 21. Regulatory agencies/programs/agreements included in this chapter are: NAFTA, FTC, EPA, Social Security, Medicare/Medicaid, FDA. 2. MSDE Government Online Course. There are lessons on many public policies including censorship, entitlements, health care, crime prevention, and equity. If time permits, link to these lessons and allow students to explore them. Study the sign and discuss the questions that follow. • What is the purpose of this sign? • Where do you see these types of signs? • Why would the government and other groups post these signs? Session 3: Maryland Regions and Public Policy Overview During this session, students read about Maryland to learn about its regions, geographic characteristics, economy, and possible issues. This leads to a review of fiscal and monetary policy in the next lesson. Objectives: 1. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 2. Explain how geographic characteristics and shared interests stimulate regional cooperation between governments (3.1.3 a) 3. Analyze how the population shifts in and between regions affects the formation and implementation of government policy, such as the relocation or loss of industry and urban flight (3.1.3 b) 4. Analyze the importance of regional characteristics and interests including economic development, natural resources, climate and environmental issues in formulating local, state, and national government policy (3.1.3 c) 5. Assessment Limits Population growth and regional issues Key Questions 1. What economic issues affect the regions of Maryland? 2. How do these economic issues affect the people in that region? 3. What actions does the government take to address these issues? Key Terms Land use Natural resources Demographics Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Maryland Geography. Pose the following questions: • What are the geographic regions of Maryland? • If you read a newspaper from each region, what are the major stories, issues, or problems? If possible, work as a group to record this information to see what students know about their state. Return to this information at the end of the lesson to see how their knowledge has increased. Remind students that issues in these areas are often pressing enough for state and local governments to create public policies. 2. Developing Understanding – Before and During Reading – Regional Issues. Place the transparency Regions of Maryland on the overhead (or make a copy for students). Review the regions, reminding students that these regions are based on common interests. In this case, it is both geographic and economic. Note: This is an opportunity to jigsaw students by dividing them into 5 groups and assigning a region to each group. Assign roles to each group making sure that at least one person will be a spokesperson. Note that the length of the reading varies by region. Distribute Regions of Maryland packet and the student resource/graphic organizer. Set the purpose to read: • identify and describe the regions of Maryland • describe the types of jobs in each region and how they may affect the region • describe the major issues of each region 3. Checking for Understanding – After Reading – Regions of Maryland. Direct the spokesperson for each group to move to a new group and share information about the region. Continue this rotation until charts are completed. Or have groups report out and record information on the overhead or a chart. Conclude with a whole class discussion: • What types of jobs are available in Maryland? • How does the type of job in an area affect the economy? • What do you think are some issues in Maryland that the government is addressing or will address? Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), This resource does not address regional issues of state governments. 2. Web resources. For information about each county link to the Maryland Department of Tourism at http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/destinationscitiesandtowns/dest inations.html For information about the economy of each Maryland county type in the name of the county at the Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development website at http://www.choosemaryland.org/ Regions of Maryland http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/destinationscitiesandtowns/destinations.html Regions of Maryland Region Western Maryland Capital Region Description Types of Jobs Affect of Jobs on the Region Possible Issues of the Region Central Maryland Region Southern Region Eastern Shore Region Regions of Maryland Maryland may be divided into regions in many ways. If you are visiting the Maryland Office of Tourism online, you will find this map and descriptions of each of the regions. (http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/destinationscitiesandtowns/destin ations.html). Study the following map and think about the characteristics of each region. What do you think are the major concerns for the region? http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/destinationscitiesandtowns/destinations.html Now you will now read about each region of Maryland. As you read, consider the advantages and disadvantages of living in this location. Are there enough jobs? What kind of jobs are there? What kinds of activities would interest you in this region? Think about issues that are important to the residents of this region. Western Maryland Description According to the Maryland Office of Tourism: “Visitors can climb Maryland's highest mountain, swim in numerous lakes, hike the Appalachian Trail, brave whitewater rapids or enjoy all kinds of winter sports from skiing to ice fishing. The three counties of Western Maryland, where fall foliage arrives first and winter usually stays the longest, were Maryland's last frontier. One of the most important events in Western Maryland in the early 1800s was the opening of the National Road, the first highway built with federal funds. Later, the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad and the Chesapeake & Ohio Canal carried passengers to and from the western states. This part of the state is in the Appalachian Mountain region, where apples, peaches, maple syrup, honey and lumber are abundant.” The counties included in Western Maryland are: #1 - Garrett County #2 - Allegany County #3 - Washington County Source:http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/destinationscitiesandtowns/western_map_key.gif Economic Information Source: Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development Garrett County’s Garrett County is Maryland’s westernmost county. With over 76,000 acres of parks, lakes and publicly accessible forest land, Garrett County is considered Maryland’s “Mountaintop Playground.” Recreational industries provide jobs for a large number of people but this is seasonal employment that impacts the economy. Garrett County’s 930 businesses employ 9,800 workers. Businesses range in size from the very small firms located in the Garrett Information Enterprise Center, a technology business incubator, to the estimated 14 companies that employ over 100 workers. Major private employers include GMS Mine Repair & Maintenance/Pioneer Conveyor, Phenix Technologies and Wal-Mart. Garrett County participates in programs that offer significant tax credits for capital investments that create jobs. Allegany County Allegany County is crossed by Interstate 68 and the main lines of CSX Transportation providing excellent access to major markets in the East and Midwest. Allegany’s 1,670 diverse businesses employ 24,100 workers with 38 of these firms employing over 100. Among the largest employers in the area are Western Maryland Health Care Systems (2400 employees), FirstPage (paper manufacturing 1100 employees), Frostburg State University(904 employees), and CSX (925 employees). Skilled workers come from the management and the professional sector, service industries, manufacturing and production, and sales. The county has developed a series of business parks tailored to a diverse economy including information technology, biotechnology and advanced manufacturing. Allegany County participates in state programs that offer significant tax credits for new capital investments and job creation. Washington County Washington County is a major industrial and transportation hub in the Mid-Atlantic region. Interstates 81, 70 and 68, coupled with excellent rail service, provide easy market access and distribution. Washington County’s 3,340 businesses employ 57,700 workers; an estimated 93 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Key employers include Citicorp Credit Services, FedEx Ground, Fleetwood Travel Trailers of Maryland, Staples Distribution, and Volvo Powertrain North America. After reading, respond to the following questions and record the information on your student resource. Describe this region. Describe what types of jobs are available in this region. Explain how these types of jobs affect the region. Identify some issues that governments – state and/or local - might address in this county. Capital Region Description According to the Maryland Office of Tourism: “The Capital Region's history spans three centuries of Maryland and American life, from the earliest colonists to the pioneers in space flight. Here you'll find peaceful farmland as well as bustling cities and suburbs. In 1791, Maryland donated land from Montgomery and Prince George's counties to be used for the nation's new capital city, Washington, D.C. Once an important farming area, the Capital Region is known today for its many high-tech industries and research centers in the fields of telecommunications, electronics, computers, health and medicine.” The counties included in Western Maryland are: #1 - Frederick County #2 - Montgomery County #3 - Prince George's County http://www.visitmaryland.org/resources/capital_map_key.gif Economic Information Source: Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development Frederick County Frederick County’s 5,670 businesses employ 77,500 workers; an estimated 133 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Frederick County boasts employers including Bechtel National, BP Solar, Cambrex Bio Science, CitiMortgage, Fort Detrick, MedImmune, and State Farm Insurance. The county has experienced a significant increase in high-tech companies, allowing more residents to work near where they live. Montgomery County Montgomery County is a thriving business center, Maryland’s most populous jurisdiction, and a major job generator for the state. The county is the heart of Maryland’s biotech community, which ranks third largest in the nation. Montgomery County’s 32,200 businesses employ over 380,000 workers in areas including information technology, telecommunications, biotechnology, software development, aerospace engineering, and various professional services. Over 200 biotech companies are located here. Companies include Discovery Communications, GEICO, Hughes Network Systems, IBM, Lockheed Martin, and Marriott International. The county is also home to 19 federal agencies, including the National Institutes of Health, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, and the Food and Drug Administration. In addition, the county is home to world-famous educational and research organizations such as The Johns Hopkins University’s Montgomery County Campus, the Center for Advanced Research in Biotechnology, The Institute for Genomic Research and the Universities at Shady Grove. Prince George’s County Prince George's County wraps around the eastern boundary of Washington, D.C. and offers urban, suburban and rural settings for employers and residents. 15,300 businesses employ over 231,000 workers; an estimated 486 of these businesses have 100 or more employees. Major employers include the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Computer Sciences Corporation, the University of Maryland, College Park, the Beltsville Agricultural Research Center, and Verizon. Prince George's County has nearly a dozen high-technology oriented federal labs and agencies. Almost 900 technology companies employ 33,600 highly-trained workers—the second highest number of high-tech companies, as well as defense and aerospace companies, of any jurisdiction in the state. After reading, respond to the following questions and record the information on your student resource. Describe this region. Describe what types of jobs are available in this region. Explain how these types of jobs affect the region. Identify some issues that governments – state and/or local - might address in this county. Central Maryland Description According to the Maryland Office of Tourism: “The attractions vary from the state's historic capital, Annapolis, to its largest city, Baltimore, from waterfront villages and mill towns to the gently rolling hills of horse country and the waters of the Chesapeake Bay. This area is part of two geographic regions, the Atlantic Coastal Plain and the Piedmont Plateau, so the variety of industries in this area ranges from mining marble, granite and other stones to harvesting fish and seafood. This is where some of the most important events in state and national history took place and where people are still making history. In Central Maryland, you'll find government at work and Marylanders making important contributions in the areas of art, culture, education, medicine and business.” The counties in the Central Maryland region include: #1. Anne Arundel County #2. Baltimore City #3. Baltimore County #4. Carroll County #5. Harford County #6. Howard County Central Maryland http://www.visitmaryland.org/planningamarylandvisit/central_map_key.gif Economic Information Source: Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development Anne Arundel County Anne Arundel County is located in the heart of the nation’s fourth largest marketplace, the Baltimore-Washington D.C. corridor. The county is home to the state capital, Annapolis, and to the U.S. Naval Academy, both of which are major destinations for visitors. The county’s economy is supported by a diverse set of economic drivers such as the Baltimore/Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport, world-class private sector employers such as ARINC and Northrop Grumman, and telecommunications, retail, and distribution services. Its rapidly expanding informatics and defense industry is fueled by the National Security Agency, Fort George G. Meade, and key defense contractors. Anne Arundel County is ranked fourth in Maryland for defense contracts and has seven of the top 10 defense contractors in the nation. Anne Arundel’s 13,900 businesses employ 188,300 workers; an estimated 323 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Baltimore City Baltimore City ranks 18th in population of U.S. cities. Tourist attractions abound throughout the city, extending well beyond Baltimore’s famous Inner Harbor waterfront. Baltimore is home to world-renowned The Johns Hopkins Hospital and School of Medicine, the largest recipient of federal research dollars in the country. The University of Maryland Medical System is located in new, state-of-the-art facilities in Baltimore’s redeveloping West Side. Both universities, in cooperation with the city, are developing biotech parks. These new research parks, combined with the Johns Hopkins Bayview Research Campus, and the University of Maryland Biotechnology Institute, make Baltimore a life sciences capital. The Port of Baltimore is a significant economic engine for the region, generating $1.4 billion in annual revenue and employing nearly 126,700 residents. Baltimore’s 13,700 businesses create a diverse economy and employ 275,100 workers. An estimated 449 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Major employers include the Johns Hopkins Institutions, the University of Maryland Medical System, Constellation Energy Group, Bank of America, Verizon, Legg Mason and T. Rowe Price. Baltimore participates in programs that offer economic benefits to eligible businesses. Baltimore County Baltimore County enjoys a diverse and strong economy and an attractive standard of living. Home to 21,000 businesses, Baltimore County's business community is balanced across industry sectors with international headquarters for McCormick & Company and Black & Decker and major operations for GM Powertrain, T. Rowe Price, Lockheed Martin, BD Diagnostics, AAI Corporation, Procter & Gamble, Shire Pharmaceuticals, Mittal Steel, and Bank of America. Other business environments vary from a research and technology park to industrial properties with rail, interstate and deepwater port access to a thriving technology community near interstates and light rail to downtown and BWI Airport Carroll County Carroll County’s central location in the state attracts a diversity of business interests including firms in manufacturing, transportation, and health and business service sectors. Carroll County’s 4,660 businesses employ 46,300 workers; an estimated 64 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Major manufacturing and distribution firms in the county include General Dynamics Robotic Systems, Lehigh Portland Cement, , Northrop Grumman, Random House, and Solo Cup. Agriculture remains a viable industry with an emphasis on nurturing bioscience and other nontraditional enterprises. As a part of the Baltimore metropolitan area, Carroll County enjoys strategic assets such as proximity to major transportation hubs including the Port of Baltimore and Baltimore/Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport. Harford County Harford County offers immediate proximity to premier research institutions such as the U.S. Army’s Aberdeen Proving Ground, Johns Hopkins, and the University of Maryland. Coupled with a highly skilled regional workforce of more than 1.6 million, Harford County provides the ultimate setting for a vast array of companies and industry sectors. Harford County’s 5,430 businesses employ 64,200 workers; an estimated 97 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. The U.S. Army’s Aberdeen Proving Ground (APG) is the major county employer and a technology resource for the region. As a result of the recent military Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) process, APG is projected to have a net gain of 6,200 positions, both military and civilian, to its workforce. Major private sector employers in the county include Clorox Products Manufacturing, FritoLay, Northrop Grumman, and Rite Aid, Saks. Howard County Howard County is situated in the heart of the dynamic corridor between Washington, D.C. and Baltimore, which combined comprise the fourth largest consolidated market in the United States. Howard County’s ideal geographic location has resulted in the substantial growth of a wide variety of industries, including high-tech and life science businesses. Both Baltimore/Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport and the Port of Baltimore are easily accessible. A diverse business base thrives in the county, taking advantage of a friendly business climate, a highly educated workforce and superb quality of life. Howard County’s corporate citizens range from information technology, telecommunications and biotechnology companies to multinational corporations, research and development firms and wholesale distributors. Howard County’s 8,170 businesses employ 122,400 workers; over 260 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Major private sector employers include Arbitron, Dreyer’s Grand Ice Cream, The Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory, MICROS Systems, Northrop Grumman, and Verizon Wireless. After reading, respond to the following questions and record the information on your student resource. Describe this region. Describe what types of jobs are available in this region. Explain how these types of jobs affect the region. Identify some issues that governments – state and/or local - might address in this county. Southern Maryland Region Description From the Maryland Department of Tourism: “In St. Mary's, Calvert and Charles counties, there are landmarks that help visitors learn about earlier - even prehistoric - times. Many of the people who live there still farm tobacco, corn, wheat and soybeans, and harvest fish and shellfish from the waters of the Chesapeake Bay and the Potomac and Patuxent rivers. There also are many historic sites and environmental treasures such as woods, fields, ponds, swamps and beaches that are preserved for all to enjoy.” The counties in the Southern Maryland Region are: #1. Calvert County #2. Charles County #3. St. Mary's County Source: http://www.visitmaryland.org/resources/southern_map_key.gif Economic Information Source: Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development Calvert County Part of the Washington, D.C. metropolitan area, Calvert County offers a variety of amenities. Calvert County is the state’s smallest county consisting of about 213 square miles. Calvert is accessible to major airports and highways, the Port of Baltimore, an abundant workforce, and cultural and recreational activities. In addition, preservationoriented planning projects safeguard the area’s character. Calvert County’s 1,830 businesses employ 17,000 workers with an estimated 16 businesses having 100 or more workers. Major employers are Constellation Energy, Calvert Memorial Hospital, ARC of Southern Maryland, DynCorp International, and Recorded Books. Charles County Charles County has two distinctive business corridors, each with easy access to the entire Washington, D.C. metro area. An ambitious policy of maintaining 50 percent open space as the county grows and develops ensures a high quality of life for generations to come. Charles County's 2,830 businesses employ 32,500 workers. Including those entrepreneurs, proprietors, and government employment, over 50,000 people work in Charles County. Major employers reflect the growing number of technology related disciplines: Applied Ordnance Technology, Automated Graphics Systems, Besche Oil, Chaney Enterprises, Civista Medical Center, the College of Southern Maryland, The Facchina Group of Companies, and the Naval Support Facility Indian Head Division. St. Mary’s County St. Mary’s County is situated on a peninsula in Southern Maryland with over 500 miles of shoreline on the Patuxent River, Potomac River and Chesapeake Bay. The Patuxent River Naval Air Station, employing 20,200 military, civilians and defense contractors, is home to the U.S. Naval Air Systems Command (NAVAIR), including the Naval Air Warfare Center Aircraft Division (NAWCAD). With over 230 high-tech defense contractors, the county has emerged as a world-class center for maritime aviation research, development, testing and evaluation. The area combines access to technology with a rich heritage and many outdoor opportunities. St. Mary’s County’s 1,870 businesses employ 26,500 workers; an estimated 41 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Businesses include Boeing, Lockheed Martin, Northrop Grumman, Titan Systems, Wyle Laboratories and many others. Non-defense employers include the Lundeberg School of Seamanship, St. Mary’s Hospital, and St. Mary’s College of Maryland. The Lexington Park area participates in programs that provide incentives for expanding businesses. After reading, respond to the following questions and record the information on your student resource. Describe this region. Describe what types of jobs are available in this region. Explain how these types of jobs affect the region. Identify some issues that governments – state and/or local - might address in this county. Eastern Shore Region Description From the Maryland Department of Tourism: “It [Eastern Shore Region] is mostly flat farmland where wheat, corn, tomatoes and other crops grow, and where poultry and cattle are raised. Discover this region's many historic and natural landmarks by bicycling or driving on the quiet country roads, or explore the rivers, creeks, inlets and bays by boat. The fresh fish, crabs and oysters found here give both residents and visitors something to look forward to throughout the year.” Counties in the Eastern Shore Region include #1. Kent County #2. Queen Anne's County #3. Talbot County #4. Caroline County #5. Dorchester County #6. Wicomico County #7. Somerset County #8. Worcester County - Ocean City #9. Cecil County Source: http://www.visitmaryland.org/resources/eastern_shore_map_key.gif Economic Information Source: Maryland Department of Business and Economic Development Kent County Kent County, founded in 1642, is located on the Eastern Shore of the Chesapeake Bay, directly across from Baltimore, and provides both naturalists and sportsmen exceptional recreational opportunities, with its more than 20 marinas, beaches and wildlife areas. Maryland's only National Scenic Byway, Route 213, bisects Kent County with U.S. Route 301 providing a major north-south artery for commercial transportation. The county's over 100,000 acres of prime farmland provide the second highest crop output in Maryland, with commercial nursery operations representing the most valuable product. Kent County's 720 businesses employ over 7,000 workers, with many employing over 100 individuals. Such diverse businesses as Washington College, Chester River Health System, Dixon Valve & Coupling, Chestertown Foods, and Angelica Nurseries call Kent County home. Queen Anne’s County Queen Anne’s County, located on the Eastern Shore of the Chesapeake Bay, offers a scenic rural environment strategically located within the Washington-Baltimore metropolitan area. Highways connect with major interstate arteries so that approximately one-third of the U.S. population can be reached via overnight trucking. Air freight and passenger service is available primarily through nearby Baltimore/Washington International Thurgood Marshall Airport. Queen Anne’s 1,430 businesses employ 10,500 workers. Major employment sectors include manufacturing, distribution, publishing, food processing and hospitality services. The recreational boating industry in the county generates a $73 million annual economic impact, and travelers to Queen Anne’s contribute in excess of $36 million annually to the local economy. Talbot County Talbot County is a largely rural county with 64 percent of the land in agricultural production. Talbot County targets businesses related to environmental and informational technologies as growth industries. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Laboratory in Oxford is dedicated to the monitoring of national fisheries and the ecosystem of the Chesapeake Bay. Within a 25-mile radius of downtown Easton, there is an available workforce of approximately 80,000. Manufacturing supports eight percent of the job base and includes major employers Allen Family Foods, Cadmus Communications, Konsyl Pharmaceuticals, L-3 Communications, Orion Safety Products, Salisbury Pewter, and Seawatch International. Caroline County Caroline County is rural in character. Farming is a major economic pursuit, consisting primarily of poultry, grain and vegetable crops. Caroline’s 680 businesses employ 7,300 workers; an estimated 11 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Manufacturing accounts for about 17 percent of total employment. Major employers include Maryland Plastics, Pillsbury, Ritz Camera, Solo Cup, and Tri Gas & Oil. Dorchester County Dorchester County, the largest land/water mass county in Maryland, consists of nearly 600 square miles of land and 70 square miles of water, with 1,488 miles of shoreline. The county participates in programs to encourage development of businesses. Dorchester County’s 750 businesses employ 9,900 workers; an estimated 16 of these businesses have 100 or more employees. Manufacturing accounts for 23 percent of total employment. The balance of the county’s work force is employed primarily in services, tourism and the agriculture sectors. Key employers include: Allen Family Foods, Icelandic USA, Airpax, Hyatt Regency Chesapeake Bay Golf Resort, and The Mushroom Company. Wicomico County, Wicomico County is the commercial/industrial center of the Lower Eastern Shore, drawing shoppers and business from Delaware, Virginia, and nearby Maryland counties. Salisbury is the region’s transportation and industrial center. Educational needs are served by Salisbury University, Wor-Wic Community College, and the University of Maryland Eastern Shore. Wicomico’s 2,710 businesses employ 38,800 workers; an estimated 60 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Major employers are Delmarva Power, Harvard Custom Manufacturing, Jubilant Pharmaceuticals, K&L Microwave, Peninsula Regional Medical Center, Perdue Farms, and Silverton Marine. Somerset County Somerset County is a water-oriented rural county that attracts fisherman, hunters, tourists and water sports enthusiasts. Somerset's 430 businesses employ 4,100 workers, with Crisfield and Princess Anne as the two major business and industrial centers. Major employers are Lankford-Sysco Food Services, McCready Memorial Hospital, Mountaire Farms, Mercantile Peninsula Bank, Perdue Farms, Eastern Correctional Institute and the University of Maryland Eastern Shore. Somerset is a major seafood processor and poultry producer and provides a rich agricultural harvest including soybeans, corn, tomatoes and wheat. Worcester County Worcester County is a major recreational area, famous for its Ocean City beach resort, and also offers canoeing, cruises, and bass fishing on the Pocomoke River; hiking, camping, and nature observing at two state parks; and sunbathing, surfing, and beachcombing at Assateague Island National Seashore. Worcester County’s 2,200 businesses employ 20,800 workers; an estimated 18 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Tourism is the largest industry in Worcester County. Major private sector employers include Atlantic General Hospital, Bel-Art Products, and Royal Plus Electric. Cecil County Cecil County's strategic location on the I-95 corridor offers businesses overnight access to markets in New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Virginia and Washington, D.C. Main lines for CSX and Norfolk Southern railroads and Amtrak commuter lines provide additional transportation linkages. Cecil County's 1,880 businesses employ 22,100 workers; an estimated 32 of these businesses have 100 or more workers. Key employers include a host of world-class companies such as Air Products, DuPont, General Electric, IKEA and Terumo Medical. After reading, respond to the following questions and record the information on your student resource. Describe this region. Describe what types of jobs are available in this region. Explain how these types of jobs affect the region. Identify some issues that governments – state and/or local - might address in this county. Session 4: Monetary Policy Overview During this session, students review fiscal policy and then use the text/reading to learn how the Federal Reserve influences the economy through monetary policy. Objectives: 1. Describe how the Federal Reserve System uses the three tools of monetary policy, including open market operations, changes in the discount (interest) rate and changes in the reserve requirements to influence the economy (4.1.4 f) 2. Describe the effectiveness of monetary policy in achieving economic growth, full employment and price stability (4.1.4 g) 3. Explain how inflation reduces buying power and may contribute to a slow down in the economy (4.1.4 j) 4. Explain how the Consumer Price Index (CPI), the unemployment rate and the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) measure economic performance (4.1.4 h) 5. Explain how economic instability, including periods of growth and recession is a part of the free enterprise system (4.1.4 i) 6. Explain how inflation reduces buying power and may contribute to a slow down in the economy (4.1.4 j) Assessment Limits Business cycle, monetary policy (Federal Reserve actions) and fiscal policy (Legislative and Executive actions) and their effect on economic performance, full employment, and price stability. Tools of monetary policy (Federal Reserve System-FED) including the reserve requirement, interest rates, and open-market operations (buying and selling of government securities). Tools of fiscal policy including increasing/decreasing taxes and tariffs and/or spending. Measures of economic performance including Gross Domestic Product (GDP), Consumer Price Index (CPI), and unemployment rate. Key Questions 1. What is the Federal Reserve? 2. How does the Federal Reserve use the tools of monetary policy to influence the economy? 3. How does inflation affect consumers and the economy? 4. How is the performance of the economy measured? 5. How do inflation and recession affect the economy? Key Terms Federal Reserve Monetary Policy Inflation Interest CPI (Consumer Price Index) • • • • Unemployment rate Business Cycle GDP (Gross Domestic Product) Recession Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Fiscal Policy. Divide students into small groups/pairs. Ask: • How does the government make decisions about public policy? • How does it support the cost of these policies? Review a few responses guiding the discussion to taxing and spending, influencing the economy. 2. Developing Understanding – During Reading – Fiscal Policy. Remind students that the legislative and executive branches work together to create fiscal policy, taxing and spending, in order to keep a strong economy. Direct students to the appropriate text (Remy, Chapter 20, Section 3). Set the purpose to read: • explain how the government uses taxing and spending to keep the economy strong • describe the economic indicators that the government used to determine the strength of the economy Note: If students do not have enough information in the text, use the reading provided in an earlier session. That reading is included in this session. The student resource worksheet is also included. 3. Checking for Understanding – After Reading – Fiscal Policy. Place the following questions on the overhead and ask students to record answers in their notebooks. • Who proposes budgets for the national government? Who proposes them for the state? • What are the indicators that governments study to determine the strength of the economy? • Explain how taxing and spending can affect the economy? Review student responses. 4. Developing Understanding – Before and Reading – Monetary Policy. Explain that the national government uses monetary policy, another tool, to keep the economy strong. Direct students to the appropriate text. Set the purpose to read: • explain how the government uses monetary policy to keep the economy strong • describe the tools the Federal Reserve uses to keep the economy strong Note: A reading about Monetary Policy from the online government course is included. It includes some graphs that may be helpful for students to understand monetary policy. Questions are embedded in the reading. 5. Checking for Understanding – After Reading – Monetary Policy. Divide students into pairs to respond to the following: • What is the Federal Reserve? Why is it important? • What does the Federal Reserve do? • What tools does the Fed use to help the economy grow or slow? • What actions might the Fed take if the economy grows too rapidly? • What actions might the Fed take if the economy grows too slowly? Conduct a brief discussion, reviewing student responses. Distribute Economic Policy Quiz. Use data to inform instruction. Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), Chapter 20, Section 3 provides limited information about monetary policy. Teachers will have to include additional resources to prepare students for the Government HSA. 2. Web resources. What happens when money and credit rise? Link to http://federalreserveeducation.org/fed101/policy/money.htm Developing Fiscal Policy Fiscal Policy Part 1 Do you know what a budget is? A budget is an itemized summary of income and expenditures for a given period of time. If you have a job, you might have to budget your paycheck. For example, let's say that you receive $450 each month. From your paycheck, your parents require you to pay: • Gas for your car (gas prices are very high) - $60/month • Car Insurance - $300/month • Cell phone - $50/month That leaves you with $40 each month to spend on movies, clothes, savings and other incidentals. So, what is a budget? Like you, the federal and state governments must also budget their money. They get their money from taxes that we pay. Look at the pie chart below. From which type of tax do state governments get most of their money? Then, the government can spend the funds on programs and services for the citizens. Look at the chart below. Think about . . . Which programs receive most of the State's money? Fiscal Policy Part 2 Government spending affects you. You may not realize it, but the government spends a great deal of money on you. Roads, public schools, parks, libraries, defense, police and fire departments are all paid for by the government. In this lesson, we will learn about how the legislature (U.S. Congress and Maryland General Assembly) makes decisions about what to spend money on and whether to raise or lower taxes. What are taxes and why do we have to pay them? Taxes are required payments of money to various levels of government. • Taxes provide revenue (money) for public goods and services that benefit the community and the nation as a whole. • Although taxpayers often complain about paying taxes, the benefits of taxation are positive. • The amount of revenue raised by taxes determines the amount of services the government can afford to provide Fiscal policy is the government's use of taxing and spending. It helps keep the economy stable and meet socio-economic goals. If the economy is growing too fast, the government may choose to increase taxes to slow it down. This means that consumers will have less money to spend. If the economy is not growing, the government may choose to increase spending. This means that the government spends money on projects such as building roads, improving defense, or protecting the environment. More money is put into the economy to create jobs and help the economy grow. Together, the legislative and executive branches work to ensure the health of our economy. The government wants: • Full employment - Everyone has a job • Price Stability - Prices that do not fluctuate up or down drastically • Economic Growth - Production increases This plan of taxing and spending is developed through the budgetary process. This process starts with the executive in the form of a plan, and then passes to the legislature in the form of a bill. So, the budget is really legislation that must be passed by Congress at the national level and the General Assembly at the state level. When developing and approving a budget, the Legislative and Executive Branches compromise on which goals should take priority for the nation or state and fund them accordingly. The budget should maximize the benefits of taxing and spending and also keep the economy growing. On the national level, the budget is proposed by the President and approved by Congress. The process is similar on the state level, with the Governor developing and the General Assembly approving the state budget. Local governments follow a similar process with the executive or mayor proposing a budget and the legislative branch such as the county or city council approving the budget. In order to adjust taxes and spending, a law must be passed. Executives and legislatures decide whether to tax and spend by watching three economic indicators that influence the business cycle and measure the health of the economy. Before the executive proposes and the legislature approves the budget, they study the health of the economy. Remember, the goal is to keep the economy stable. Think about . . . What is a budget? What are taxes and why do we have to pay them? What is fiscal policy? What is its purpose? What is the process for making fiscal policy? What branches are involved? What is their role? The Business Cycle The economy is constantly changing, It follows an up and down pattern called the business cycle. The business cycle is like a roller coaster. The economy will improve and go up for a while, reach a peak, then go down for a while. Eventually, it will reach a low point and then go up again. Sometimes, our economy is prosperous (peak) with a lot of jobs and money to go around. Other times it is in a depression when it is hard to find a job and money is tight (trough). The economy is in the "expansion" phase when consumers (people who buy things) spend their money to buy products (demand), then production increases (supply). This willingness to spend money causes the economy to expand, because more money is in circulation. If the economy is growing too fast, the government may choose to increase taxes to slow it down. This means that consumers will have less money to spend. If the economy is not growing, the government may choose to increase spending. This means that the government spends money on projects such as building roads, improving defense, or protecting the environment. More money is put into the economy to create jobs and help the economy grow. If people are not demanding products and are not spending money, the economy contracts (gets smaller) because there is less money in circulation. This is the "recession" phase of the business cycle. If the health of the economy gets worse, the recession may become a depression. Think about . . . 1. If the economy is contracting (slowing), what action might the government take? 2. If the economy is expanding (growing), what action might the government take? Three Economic Indicators: GDP, CPI and the Unemployment Rate Executives and legislatures decide whether to tax and spend by watching three economic indicators that influence the business cycle and measure the health of the economy. Before the executive proposes and the legislature approves the budget, they study the health of the economy. Remember, the goal is to keep the economy stable. 1. Gross Domestic Product The first is Gross Domestic Product (GDP). Gross Domestic Product (GDP) measures the value of all goods and services produced in the country. The government uses information from GDP to measure the productivity of the economy. The business cycle shows how the economy changes and fluctuates. It expands and contracts. When we look at the business cycle, we usually look at the GDP which shows us the values of goods and services produced in the country. For example, in the business cycle, during the prosperous or in the expansion phase, the economy grows. At this time, the unemployment rate is low and GDP is high. Study the business cycle image below and answer the questions on your student resource sheet. Think about . . . 1. What is gross domestic product (GDP)? Using the image above, place the following examples at the correct spot on the business cycle. 1. Businesses are failing and employers have had to lay off workers. 2. Unemployment is low. People are working and purchasing lots of goods and services. Businesses are thriving. 3. After a period of economic slowdown, GDP is beginning to rise. 4. At what point in the business cycle would GDP fall? Recovery Recession 5. At what point in the business cycle would GDP rise? Recovery Recession 6. At what point in the business cycle would GDP be highest? Trough Prosperity 7. When GDP is low, what happens to unemployment? Increases Decreases 2. Unemployment Rate The government also watches the unemployment rate. The unemployment rate indicates the percentage of people who want a job, but cannot find one. Another measure that the legislative and executive branches look at is the unemployment rate. In the United States, you have the freedom to choose where you want to work. Employers also have the freedom to decide when to hire or dismiss employees, based on their business needs. If many people are unemployed, or out of work, there is high unemployment. When this happens, the Congress may want to give money to build and repair interstate highways. This increase in spending helps to create jobs for manufacturers of highway equipment. If more people are employed, the unemployment rate goes down. This action will make more money available for people to spend. The government keeps track of the number of people employed and unemployed to make adjustments in policy and keep the economy growing. Study the chart below and answer the questions on your student resource sheet. The unemployment rate fluctuates over time. 3. Consumer Price Index The third measure the government monitors the level of prices in the Consumer Price Index (CPI). The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is the average price level of a fixed basket of goods and services purchased by consumers. Through the Consumer Price Index, the government monitors the rate of inflation. A degree of inflation happens every year. Prices generally increase by about 3%. Inflation is an increase in the general level of prices and CPI measures the change in prices. Through the CPI, the government monitors the price of • Housing • Medical Care • Food • Entertainment • Transportation • Clothing However, if prices are too inflated, then people can’t afford the products. The graph below shows the Annual Inflation Rates. Notice that during some years the prices rose (bars above the 0% percent line) and during some the prices fell (bars below the 0% line). Source: http://inflationdata.com/Inflation/Inflation_Rate/DecadeInflation.asp Study the bar graph above and answer this question: • In which years was inflation the HIGHEST? The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is used to calculate how prices have changed over the years Let's say you have $10 in your pocket to purchase some goods and services today. According to the CPI, you would have only needed $2.76 in the year 1975 to buy the same amount of goods and services. In 1950, an average baseball ticket cost $ 1.60. To convert that price into today's dollars, use the CPI inflation calculator that is found on the Internet (inflation calculator) Look at another example to see how prices have changed over time. If in 1950 I bought goods or services for 1.60 then in 2006 the same goods or services would cost $13.44 Think about how much it costs to buy a baseball ticket today. Is an average baseball ticket more or less than 13 dollars? Has the cost of baseball tickets increased in price faster or slower than most goods and services? Using the inflations calculator, the price increase was--- Faster. The cost of a baseball ticket now ranges from $15 and $40. The Gross Domestic Product, the unemployment rate and the Consumer Price Index tell us about the health of the economy. Executives and legislatures decide whether to tax and spend by watching these economic indicators that influence the business cycle and measure the health of the economy. Before the executive proposes and the legislature approves the budget, they study the health of the economy. The government uses information from these indicators to make decisions about fiscal policy, taxing and spending. Think about . . . What is gross domestic product? How do the legislative and executive branches use the economic indicators? Source: MSDE Government Online Course – Legislative Branches – Fiscal Policy Name Fiscal Policy Student Resource Directions: After reading about fiscal policy, respond to these questions. 1. What is a budget? Why might it be important to have a budget? 2. What are taxes and why do we have to pay them? 3. What is fiscal policy? What is its purpose? 4. What is the process for making fiscal policy? What branches are involved? What is their role? 5. What do you think you could do to influence fiscal policy if you disagree with possible proposed taxes or spending? Study the graphs. 6. From which type of tax do state governments get most of their money? 7. On what types of programs do government spend funds? Source: MSDE Government Online Course – Legislative Branches – Fiscal Policy Name: The Business Cycle Directions: After reading about the business cycle, respond to these questions. 1. What is the business cycle? 2. If the economy is contracting (slowing), what action might the government take? 3. If the economy is expanding (growing), what action might the government take? Three Economic Indicators Gross Domestic Product Directions: After reading about gross domestic product, respond to these questions. 1. What is gross domestic product (GDP)? Study the business cycle image below. Using the image above, indicate where the following examples are located. 2. Businesses are failing and employers have had to lay off workers. A, B, or C 3. Unemployment is low. People are working and purchasing lots of goods and services. Businesses are thriving. A, B, or C 4. After a period of economic slowdown, GDP is beginning to rise. A, B, or C 5. At what point in the business cycle would GDP fall? Recovery Recession 6. At what point in the business cycle would GDP rise? Recovery Recession 7. At what point in the business cycle would GDP be highest? Trough Prosperity 8. When GDP is low, what happens to unemployment? Increases Decreases Source: MSDE Government Online Course – Legislative Branches – Fiscal Policy Monetary Policy Opening Activity: Federal Reserve Study the picture of the dollar bill below. Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:US_%241_obverse.jpg U.S. money is distributed for circulation by 12 Federal Reserve Banks. These institutions act as "banks for the banks." Which Federal Reserve Bank seal is on the front of the dollar in your wallet? Did you notice that the money is labeled with the mark of the Federal Reserve? In this lesson, we will investigate these questions: • What is the Federal Reserve? • Why is the Federal Reserve important? • How do the actions of the Federal Reserve affect individuals? What is the Federal Reserve? The Federal Reserve is the central bank of the United States. It is an independent agency of the federal government commonly known as the "Fed." The Federal Reserve regulates how much money there is in the economy. Most banks are members of the Federal Reserve system. Why is the Federal Reserve important? The Fed uses monetary policy to affect how much money is available to banks. This in turn, affects the amount of money available to people everyday. The Fed changes the money supply and adjusts interest rates to keep prices stable, employment high and the economy growing. Activity 1: What does the Federal Reserve do? The Federal Reserve makes and carries out the monetary policy of the government. Through its regulations, the Fed influences economic conditions to promote high employment, economic growth and stable prices. While the Federal Reserve tries to regulate the economy through the management of the money supply, the Fed cannot guarantee that the economy will grow at a healthy pace or that jobs will be available for everyone who wants one. To promote economic growth, the Fed attempts to control inflation so it does not affect business or individual spending. Part 1: Rapid Growth and the effects on the economy Inflation occurs when the growth of money (deposits in banks and cash in circulation) and credit exceed the supply of goods and services. To you, this means that you have to spend more dollars for goods and the dollars are worth less. To keep the economy strong, the growth of money and credit should NOT grow too rapidly or too slowly. To keep the economy strong, the growth of money and credit should be steady. The Federal Reserve watches the growth of money and credit and sets monetary policy to remedy changes (rapid growth or slow growth) in the economy. What happens when money and credit rise? What happens to interest rates when there is MORE money in the economy? When more money is flowing in the economy, interest rates go down because banks have more money to lend. What do consumers do when banks have more money to lend? Consumers borrow more money. When consumers have more money to spend, what can happen in the economy? When consumers are able to spend more money and demand more products. To keep up with demand, prices may rise too quickly. Part 2: Slow Growth and the effects on the economy . The Fed is also worried about the economy when growth is slow. What happens to interest rates when there is LESS money in the economy? Interest rates go up because banks have less money to lend. What do consumers do when banks have less money to lend? Consumers borrow less money because interest rates are high. When consumers have less money to spend, what can happen in the economy? When consumers do not have as much to spend, prices may fall and businesses may reduce production of goods. Workers may lose their jobs Activity 2: Federal Reserve Actions The amount of money in an economy is important because it affects the level of spending, employment, prices and economic growth. Too much spending can lead to inflation while too little spending can cause unemployment and decreases in the production of goods. The job of the Fed is to balance these forces using three major methods or tools. These tools will help the economy grow or slow depending on what the Fed thinks is needed. Part 1: The Reserve Requirement When money is deposited in a bank, the bank is allowed to lend or invest part of that deposit. But it must keep part of the deposit in "reserve." This is the minimum amount of money that local banks must keep at their location at the end of the day. This is a requirement of the FED. If the nation is experiencing inflation, the Fed wants the economy to slow down . The Fed will raise the reserve requirement and banks will keep more money in the bank instead of loaning it to you. If the Fed wants to help the economy grow, the reserve requirement is lowered. Banks can loan more money to consumers to buy cars, houses, or other goods. This helps the economy grow by increasing spending and employment. This tool can have a big effect on the money supply. Part 2: The Discount (Interest) Rate The discount rate is the interest rate the Fed charges if your bank needs to borrow from the Fed because it doesn't have the amount of reserves it is required to have. The Fed loans money to banks at an interest rate that the Fed chooses. When there is rapid growth, the Fed wants the economy to slow. To reduce inflation, the Fed will set the interest rates high. If the Fed sets the interest high, the bank isn't as likely to borrow money from them. As a result, the bank has less money to lend to you. To help the economy grow, the Fed may lower the discount rate. If the Fed sets the interest low, the bank is more likely to borrow and have more money... to lend you money to buy a house, car, etc. Part 3: Open Market Operations (Buying and Selling Securities) When the federal government borrows money, it does so by selling treasury securities to interested buyers. These buyers may sell the bonds to other buyers. One buyer is the Fed. This is an important and frequently used tool of the Federal Reserve. To slow growth, the Fed reduces the money supply. To do so, the Fed will sell some of the government securities it owns. As a result, the money supply decreases. If the Fed wants the economy to slow, it can sell some of the securities it owns. If your bank decides to buy some of the securities the Fed is selling, it has to pay the Fed. This means it has less money to use for other things like lending money to people or businesses. To make the economy grow, the Fed buys securities and the money supply increases. If the Fed buys securities from your bank, it gives the bank more money to lend to customers. This may lower interest rates. Customers then borrow and buy more goods and services with the money they borrow. For example, if the Fed buys $10,000 worth of government securities with such a check, it creates the $10,000 used to pay for them. The sellers are not $10,000 richer, since they no longer own the securities, but the money supply grows because there is $10,000 of new money in the economy. Remember the three tools that the Federal Reserve (FED) can use to affect the money supply and help the economy grow or slow... Study the chart. HOW THE FED AFFECTS THE MONEY SUPPLY AND THE ECONOMY Changing the reserve requirement Changing the discount rate Buying or selling government securities Source: MSDE Online Government Course Now, study the flow chart below. THE AMOUNT OF MONEY BANKS CAN LEND AND THE AMOUNT PEOPLE WANT TO BORROW AFFECTS 1. THE MONEY SUPPLY AFFECTS 2. HOW MUCH MONEY PEOPLE WANT TO SPEND IN THE ECONOMY AFFECTS 3. THE HEALTH OF THE ECONOMY Check for Understanding 1. What actions can the Federal Reserve take to slow the economy? 2. What actions can the Federal Reserve take to help the economy grow? 3. How do changes in the economy affect you? Source: MSDE Government Online Course – Legislative Branches – Fiscal Policy Economic Policy Quiz Directions: Read the questions and select the best answer. 1. Which of these best reflects how the federal government manages the economy through fiscal policy? A. taxing and spending B. buying and selling securities C. controlling the money supply D. controlling interest rates 2. Which of these sets monetary policy in the United States? A. Federal Reserve System B. Secretary of the Treasury C. Senate Budget Committee D. Federal Trade Commission 3. Which of these actions by the federal government would most likely reduce inflation? A. increasing both spending and the money supply B. decreasing both spending and the money supply C. increasing loans to consumers D. decreasing the interest rate 4. Which of these actions would the Federal Reserve most likely take to help end a recession? A. print more currency B. reduce the interest rate C. sell government securities D. increase the reserve requirement 5. With which of these government actions is the Consumer Price Index (CPI) most associated? A. imposing economic sanctions B. reducing unemployment C. measuring the rate of inflation D. offering federal business loans 6. Which of these government actions is designed to lower inflation? A. hiring more government workers B. Increasing government loans C. selling government securities D. increasing government spending Source: MDK12.org Session 5: Land Use Overview Students create a plan for land use and development only to discover the challenges and complexity of public policy. The simulation shows students the steps in making public policy and these will be applied to Smart Growth, a case study, in the next session. Objectives: 1. Evaluate the effect that international, national, and regional interests have on shaping environmental policy, such as logging forested areas, oil drilling, pollution, nuclear power, or alternative energy sources (1.1.3 e) 2. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 3. Evaluate the way national, state, and local governments develop policy to address land use and environmental issues, such as urban sprawl, Smart Growth and commercial use of public (3.1.2 e) Assessment Limits Entitlements: Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental Land use, smart growth, and urban sprawl Key Questions 1. What is urban sprawl? 2. How does the national, state and local government address how land is used?? Key Terms Urban sprawl Comprehensive plans Zoning laws Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Fiscal Policy. Ask students to give a few examples of public policies. As students give examples ask: • What purpose of government does this policy meet? • What levels and branches of government are involved in this public policy? 2. Setting a Purpose of Learning – Solving a Public Issue – Land use and Development. Explain that land use and development is a major public issue that affects a community, quality of life, and standard of living. In order to understand how public issues are complex and difficult to resolve, students will solve a land use and development problem. Distribute You are the Policy Maker and Planning Map and review the situation, directions and debriefing questions. Allow groups time to discuss and plan their community. Note: it is unlikely that students will be able to complete the land use plan within the allocated time. That is what is intended. The point is to help students understand the challenges – public policies are complex and persistent. Public policy challenges those who are involved to examine their beliefs, values and knowledge about an issue. Not completing the plan may be frustrating, but now you will help them understand more about public policy – Smart Growth and Land Development. 3. Developing Understanding – Public Policy Process. Explain that public policy is complex and often difficult to solve. Explain that the debrief questions represent steps in the stages of public policy. Share some student land use plans. Use the questions to debrief the land use and development issue. Ask: • Who is most likely to start discussion about issues? • Why does government get involved in issues? 4. Checking for Understanding - Exit Card. Direct students to respond to the following: • Where do public policy issues usually begin? Individuals or in the private sector • Why is government responsibility for public policy complex? It often involves multiple branches and levels of government Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), provides limited information about land use. 2. Where Do We Grow from Here? A Teacher’s Guide on Growth and Its Impacts in Maryland, Maryland Department of Natural Resources (http://www.dnr.state.md.us ) 3. Web Resources Smart Growth Home http://www.mde.state.md.us/Programs/MultimediaProgra Smart Growth and the urban growth boundary in Baltimore County. http://www.co.ba.md.us/Agencies/planning/masterplanning Frederick County, MD - Official Website - Smart Growth (PFA) ... http://www.co.frederick.md.us/index.asp?NID=1453 Duncan Announces Smart Growth Initiatives For Silver Spring; Pepco ... http://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/mc/news/press/97 You Are the Policy Maker Planning a Community The Situation Some residents of Baltimore City are happy to hear that the open space in the area will be developed. If development occurs, a ripple effect on the economy is expected as jobs, spending and tax revenues increase. Additional housing will also be available for all income levels. However, other residents are concerned that there is to much development in Baltimore and it needs to be limited or stopped. These residents fear the loss of open space, traffic congestion air and water pollution, and increased demand for public services such as schools, roads, water, and libraries. The area under consideration for development has some open space, some forested area, and parkland. The land is located near Interstate 95, roads, mass transit, and the railroad. A stream meanders through the property that is in question and provides shelter to a variety of plants and animals. You and members of the class have been selected to plan appropriate development for the site. Before completing the plan for the area, begin by discussing the following: 1. Should all or part of the land be developed? 2. Should the area be developed by private businesses, only government, or a partnership of government and business? 3. What is the best solution to developing this area? Next, decide where and how much of the following should be included in the area: Businesses – retail stores, offices, gas stations, grocery stores, restaurants Transportation - roads/interchanges, walking and biking trails Housing – high or low rise apartments, senior citizen complex, townhouses, single family homes Open space – parks and recreation Other community services – schools, police substation, fire station, libraries, water and sewer services Debriefing Questions 1. What is the issue? 2. Who is affected by the issue? 3. Who would be the policy makers in real life? What government officials would be involved? 4. Who will be involved in the issue – individuals, groups, government (levels, branches)? 5. How can citizens, media, political parties, and interest groups influence the issue and solution? What methods will they use? 6. What is the possible impact of your plan? Will it solve the issue? 7. After implementation, does the policy solve the original issue? What are the recommendations: modification, continuation of policy, or redefine the issue? Planning Map 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Area open for Development Shopping Mall Schools Apartment Complex Office & Light Commercial Federal Property Light Industry Single Family residential with some small business M.T. Mass Transit ___ Roads +++ Multiple Rail Lines Source: Where Do We Grow From Here? Maryland Department of Natural Resources Session 6: Public Policy Case Study: Smart Growth Overview Students analyze a case study, Smart Growth, and learn the process of issue analysis. In Part 2 of the session, students apply the issue analysis approach to Baltimore. This session incorporates many of the skills and knowledge necessary for success on the Government High School Assessment. Objectives: 1. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 2. Evaluate the way national, state, and local governments develop policy to address land use and environmental issues, such as urban sprawl, Smart Growth and commercial use of public (3.1.2 e) Assessment Limits Entitlements: Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental Land use, smart growth, and urban sprawl Key Questions 1. What is urban sprawl? 2. How does the national, state and local government address how land is used?? Key Terms Urban sprawl Comprehensive plans Zoning laws Smart Growth Priority funding area Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge – Maryland Data Analysis. Ask students: • What region of Maryland has the most population? • How does that affect the region? Review regions as necessary. Distribute Maryland Data. Direct students to determine current land use and changes in population centers. Review student data analysis. Conclude by asking: • How have population centers changed? • What impact might these changes have on growth and land use? • What is the extent of the issue? Review a few student responses to clearly establish the connection between growth, land use, and development. 2. Introducing a Concept – Before and During Reading – Smart Growth. Explain that one possible solution to the issue of land use and development is a public policy plan, Smart Growth. Define Smart Growth” Smart Growth – the desire and strategy to accommodate new growth and development in the most suitable areas while protecting our most vital natural resources Emphasize that Smart Growth is a possible solution to land use that is implemented through a series of programs. Explain that students will answer the same debriefing questions as in the previous session. What is the issue? Who is affected by the issue? Who would be the policy makers in real life? What government officials would be involved? Who will be involved in the issue – individuals, groups, government (levels, branches)? How can citizens, media, political parties, and interest groups influence the issue and solution? What methods will they use? What is the possible impact of your plan? Will it solve the issue? After implementation, does the policy solve the original issue? What are the recommendations: modification, continuation of policy, or redefine the issue? Direct students to read the first section of Smart Growth News. After reading ask students to identify the issue with land use and development and to record that information on their graphic organizer. Once the problem is established, set the purpose to read: • to learn how the federal, state, and local governments, as well as nongovernmental organizations and individuals, work to solve the problems of land use and development. Note: The Smart Growth News is written in two parts: Smart Growth News and Smart Growth Case Study: Baltimore. Use only the 1st part for this session. 3. Developing Understanding – Context Clues. In earlier units, students used context clues to acquire information about government. Refer to context clues information in Unit 1 and model a few examples as necessary. Examples may include revitalization, zoning, Brownfields. 4. Checking for Understanding - After Reading – Analysis of Smart Growth. Direct students to respond to the Smart Growth Issue Analysis questions. Ask: • Is the problem of land use and development solved? • What are the trade-offs in implementing Smart Growth programs? Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), provides limited information about land use. 2. Where Do We Grow from Here? A Teacher’s Guide on Growth and Its Impacts in Maryland, Maryland Department of Natural Resources (http://www.dnr.state.md.us) 3. Web Resources Smart Growth Home http://www.mde.state.md.us/Programs/MultimediaProgra Smart Growth and the urban growth boundary in Baltimore County. http://www.co.ba.md.us/Agencies/planning/masterplanning Frederick County, MD - Official Website - Smart Growth (PFA) ... http://www.co.frederick.md.us/index.asp?NID=1453 Duncan Announces Smart Growth Initiatives For Silver Spring; Pepco ... http://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/mc/news/press/97 Identifying the Issue Maryland's Developed and Protected Lands* Developed Developed Protected County Land Acres Acres Percentage Acres Allegany 266,780 28,210 10.6% 71,413 Anne Arundel 265,388 103,679 39.1% 32,384 Baltimore City 51,732 45,585 88.1% 5,120 Baltimore County 384,893 138,632 36.0% 67,996 Calvert 137,151 34,292 25.0% 10,753 Caroline 204,739 15,603 7.6% 29,348 Carroll 286,985 51,700 18.0% 39,137 Cecil 222,868 31,076 13.9% 25,462 Charles 294,519 48,080 16.3% 23,731 Dorchester 355,180 16,630 4.7% 70,229 Frederick 424,938 52,005 12.2% 49,344 Garrett 419,576 29,532 7.0% 93,137 Harford 280,668 66,140 23.6% 59,106 Howard 124,813 57,250 45.9% 22,171 Kent 178,479 10,452 5.9% 23,411 Montgomery 317,048 135,386 42.7% 57,537 Prince George's 310,038 122,849 39.6% 56,222 Queen Anne's 237,588 18,807 7.9% 26,451 St. Mary's 230,794 37,469 16.2% 16,517 Somerset 206,808 11,982 5.8% 58,224 Talbot 171,608 20,659 12.0% 13,672 Washington 293,352 42,175 14.4% 42,124 Wicomico 240,434 30,466 12.7% 27,465 Worcester 301,646 20,830 6.9% 48,236 Totals 6,208,025 1,169,490 18.8% 969,192 Protected Percentage 26.8% 12.2% 9.9% 17.7% 7.8% 14.3% 13.6% 11.4% 8.1% 19.8% 11.6% 22.2% 21.1% 17.8% 13.1% 18.1% 18.1% 11.1% 7.2% 28.2% 8.0% 14.4% 11.4% 16.0% 15.6% * Only land area is counted. These data were derived from the spreadsheet titled "Maryland's Protected Lands August 15, 2000." From Maryland Department of Planning Data Analysis Questions 1. Which three jurisdictions have the greatest percentage of developed acres? 2. What is the percentage of protected lands in Baltimore City? 3. What conclusions can be drawn about data from Baltimore City? 4. What is it important for residents of Baltimore City to be aware of this information? Identifying the Issue PERCENT OF MARYLAND'S POPULATION BY JURISDICTION, 1900 - 2000 County 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 Allegany 4.5% 4.8% 4.8% 2.7% 1.9% 1.4% Anne Arundel 3.3% 3.0% 3.8% 6.7% 8.8% 9.2% Baltimore City 42.8% 50.6% 47.2% 30.3% 18.7% 12.3% Baltimore County 7.6% 5.2% 8.6% 15.9% 15.5% 14.2% Calvert 0.9% 0.7% 0.6% 0.5% 0.8% 1.4% Caroline 1.4% 1.3% 1.0% 0.6% 0.5% 0.6% Carroll 2.9% 2.4% 2.1% 1.7% 2.3% 2.8% Cecil 2.1% 1.6% 1.4% 1.6% 1.4% 1.6% Charles 1.5% 1.2% 1.0% 1.1% 1.7% 2.3% Dorchester 2.4% 1.9% 1.5% 1.0% 0.7% 0.6% Frederick 4.4% 3.6% 3.1% 2.3% 2.7% 3.7% Garrett 1.5% 1.4% 1.2% 0.7% 0.6% 0.6% Harford 2.4% 2.0% 1.9% 2.5% 3.5% 4.1% Howard 1.4% 1.1% 0.9% 1.2% 2.8% 4.7% Kent 1.6% 1.0% 0.7% 0.5% 0.4% 0.4% Montgomery 2.6% 2.4% 4.6% 11.0% 13.7% 16.5% Prince George's 2.5% 3.0% 4.9% 11.5% 15.8% 15.1% Queen Anne's 1.5% 1.1% 0.8% 0.5% 0.6% 0.8% Somerset 2.2% 1.7% 1.2% 0.6% 0.5% 1.6% St. Mary's 1.4% 1.1% 0.8% 1.3% 1.4% 0.5% Talbot 1.7% 1.3% 1.0% 0.7% 0.6% 0.6% Washington 3.8% 4.1% 3.8% 2.9% 2.7% 2.5% Wicomico 1.9% 1.9% 1.9% 1.6% 1.5% 1.6% Worcester 1.8% 1.5% 1.2% 0.8% 0.7% 0.9% Based on information prepared by the Maryland Department of Planning, Planning Data Services from decennial census data. Data Analysis Questions 1. What jurisdiction has the greatest percentage of population in 2000? 2. What is the population trend in Baltimore City? 3. What generalization can be drawn about percent of population by jurisdiction in Maryland, 1940-2000? In Baltimore City, Baltimore County, Anne Arundel, Prince George’s, and Howard? 4. How might this information be used prior to elections or to make decisions about government funding? Identifying the Issue Maryland Population 1900 – 2000 Maryland Allegany Anne Arundel Baltimore City Baltimore Calvert Caroline Carroll Cecil Charles Dorchester Frederick Garrett Harford Howard Kent Montgomery Prince George's Queen Anne's Somerset St. Mary's Talbot Washington Wicomico Worcester 1900 1,188,044 53,694 1920 1,449,661 69,938 1940 1,821,244 86,973 1960 3,100,689 84,169 1980 4,216,975 80,548 1990 4,780,753 74,946 2000 5,296,486 74,930 39,620 43,408 68,375 206,634 370,775 427,239 489,656 508,957 90,755 10,223 16,248 33,860 24,662 17,662 27,962 51,920 17,701 28,269 16,715 18,786 30,451 733,826 74,817 9,744 18,652 34,245 23,612 17,705 27,895 52,541 19,678 29,291 15,826 15,026 34,921 859,100 155,825 10,484 17,549 39,054 26,407 17,612 28,006 57,312 21,981 35,060 17,175 13,465 83,912 939,024 492,428 15,826 19,462 52,785 48,408 32,572 29,666 71,930 20,420 76,722 36,152 15,481 340,928 786,775 655,615 34,638 23,143 96,356 60,430 72,751 30,623 114,792 26,498 145,930 118,572 16,695 579,053 736,014 692,134 51,372 27,035 123,372 71,347 101,154 30,236 150,208 28,138 182,132 187,328 17,842 757,027 651,154 754,292 74,563 29,772 150,897 85,951 120,546 30,674 195,277 29,846 218,590 247,842 19,197 873,341 29,898 43,347 89,490 357,395 665,071 728,553 801,515 18,364 25,923 17,182 20,342 45,133 22,852 20,865 16,001 24,602 16,112 18,306 59,694 28,165 22,309 14,476 20,965 14,626 18,784 68,838 34,530 21,245 16,569 19,623 38,915 21,578 91,219 49,050 23,733 25,508 19,188 59,895 25,604 113,086 64,540 30,889 33,953 23,440 75,974 30,549 121,393 74,339 35,028 40,563 86,211 24,747 33,812 131,923 84,644 46,543 Data Analysis Questions 1. In what decade was the greatest change for Baltimore City? 2. What trends are seen for Baltimore City? What are possible reasons for this? 3. What general conclusions can be drawn about population growth in Maryland 19002000? Identifying the Issue Percent Change in Population for Maryland Jurisdictions 1950 - 2000 Area 1950-1960 1960-1970 1970- 1980 1980-1990 1990-2000 Allegany -6.0% -0.1% -4.2% -7.0% 0.0% Anne Arundel 76.0 44.0 24.6 15.2 14.6 Baltimore City -1.1 -3.5 -13.1 -6.5 -11.5 Baltimore 82.2 26.1 5.6 5.6 9.0 County Calvert 30.8 30.7 67.5 48.3 45.1 Caroline 6.7 1.6 17.0 16.8 1.01 Carroll 17.5 30.7 39.6 28.0 22.3 Cecil 45.1 10.1 13.4 18.1 20.5 Charles 39.1 46.4 52.6 39.0 19.2 Dorchester 6.7 -0.9 4.1 -1.3 1.4 Frederick 15.5 18.1 35.2 30.9 30.0 Garrett -3.9 5.2 23.4 6.2 6.1 Harford 48.2 50.4 26.4 24.8 20.0 Howard 56.4 71.3 91.5 58.0 32.3 Kent 13.2 4.3 3.4 6.9 7.6 Montgomery 107.4 53.3 10.8 30.7 15.4 Prince George’s 84.1 84.8 0.7 9.54 10.0 Queen Anne’s 13.6 11.2 38.5 33.1 19.5 St. Mary’s 33.7 21.8 26.4 26.8 -67.4 Somerset -5.4 -3.6 1.4 22.2 267.8 Talbot 11.1 9.8 8.1 19.3 10.7 Washington 15.6 13.8 8.9 7.3 8.7 Wicomico 23.7 10.6 19.0 15.2 13.9 Worcester 2.5 3.0 26.4 13.4 32.9 Totals 32.3% 26.5% 7.5% 13.4% Source: Maryland Department of Planning, Planning Data Services 10.8% Data Analysis Questions 1. In what decade was the greatest percentage change for Baltimore City? 2. What trends are seen for Baltimore City? 3. What might account for the increase in population in the decade 1950-`960? 4. What general conclusions can be drawn about population growth in Maryland 19502000? Smart Growth News Directions: Before you read Smart Growth News Part 1, review the following questions. After reading, respond to these questions. Issue • What is the issue? • Who is affected by the issue? • What are possible solutions to the issue? Influences • How can citizens, media, political parties, and interest groups influence the issue and solution? What methods will they use? Involvement • Who will be involved in the issue – individuals, groups, and/or government? • Which levels and/or branches of government may be involved? Impact • What is the possible impact of the plan? Will it solve the issue? • Does the policy solve the original issue? Should it continue, be modified, or the issue be redefined? Smart Growth News Baltimore, MD, August 2007 Do you ever walk out of your home, take a deep breath of air, and, instead, cough on the fumes and pollutants in the air? Do you see cars, trucks and busses backed up for blocks waiting for traffic to move? Do you see blocks of boarded up rowhouses? Do you see large industrial sites that are not in use? Have you ever thought about how air and water pollution affect the Inner Harbor and the Chesapeake Bay? The economy drives development across Baltimore City and into other counties. The local governments are stretching their limited resources to provide services. While development pumps up the economy, there are increased costs for state and local governments to build more roads and provide for schools, fire and police How do people deal with these issues related to growth and land use? How do these issues affect local government services and budgets? How do decisions of government address the issue of land use and the effects of land use on the environment? The Issue: Urban Sprawl Large numbers of people began moving from cities to suburbs prior to World War II. Increased reliance on the automobile and a growing network of roads made this move easier. As people moved out of these central cities, rural lands were changed to residential, commercial, and industrial uses. These changes led to the decline of many urban areas. Tax revenue decreased. Schools, roads, water and sewer systems deteriorated. By 1970, the population of suburban residents was greater than that of city or rural residents for the first time. Development in suburban areas affected rural areas by reducing the amount of land available for farms, parks, and open space. It changed the way Americans live, work, play, and live. It also changed the way they use energy and impact the environment. In the suburbs, developments of houses and businesses replaced the farmlands. Residents of these areas no longer went to the cities to shop. Strip malls and shopping centers replaced the stores in the cities. These suburbs blended into one another creating a continuous network of towns and cities. The area between Baltimore and Washington, D.C. is an example of this. Many view the region between Boston and northern Virginia as one continuous network. Others consider Los Angeles, California as an example of this type of development. This continuous development is called sprawl, a spreading out of development into areas adjoining a city. Sprawl is characterized by strip development along roads, lack of functional open spaces and habitats, and a dependence on the automobile. Development helps the local economy, but it also increases the demand for public services and more taxes. Local and state governments hear about the increased need for roads, schools, water and sewage treatment plants, and fire and police protections. People in the suburbs want the same services that are available in cities. Study the maps below to see the development patterns in Maryland between 1929 and 1959. What conclusions can you make about development? Development Patterns – 1929 Development Patterns – 1959 By the 1970s, many government officials and private citizens were concerned about this type of development that encouraged sprawl. They tried to stop or slow growth. Developers claimed that they had the right to build wherever they were able to find land. Both sides filed lawsuits. Candidates in local elections took positions on development or opposition to development. This led to periods of growth or no growth depending on who won the election. There had to be a better way to manage development! Examine the last map in this series. What conclusions can you draw about development between 1929 and 1997? Development Patterns – 1997 Source: http://www.dnr.state.md.us/education/growfromhere/LESSON2/LESSON2_1.HTM#P4X for all maps Smart Growth and Land Use Maryland is a small state and doesn’t have as much land to develop as some other states. But many citizens were tiring of string after string of shopping centers destroying available land. Some shopping centers became obsolete or fell into disrepair. Developers continued to move further out from the city. Planners in Maryland wanted to call a halt to this type of development. They developed a strategy called “Smart Growth.” This plan is used nationwide at all levels of government. It is a plan in which growth is allowed in more suitable areas and natural resources are protected. Parris Glendening (D), former governor of Maryland, proposed this plan to the General Assembly in 1997. He said, “The goal of smart growth is not no growth, or even slow growth. Rather the overall goal is sensible growth that balances our need for jobs and economic development with our desire to save our natural environment.” Source: http://www.msa.md.gov/msa/mdmanual/08conoff/former/html/msa11536.html Governor Parris N. Glendening - Democrat, 1995-2003 Since then individuals, organizations, and national, state, and local governments have joined to promote a better way to grow. It is a way in which open space is protected, neighborhoods are revitalized, and efforts are made to keep housing affordable. The goal is to make communities more livable. Smart Growth principles include: 1. Mixed Land Use. A mix of business, residential, and public uses are in the same area, instead of being spread out. 2. Compact Living Design. Existing community infrastructure (public systems such as transportation, roads, schools, etc) is used instead of creating all new development. 3. Housing Choices. Townhouses, apartments, and single-family homes are mixed together with a range of prices/affordability. 4. Walkable Neighborhoods. Create close-knit communities with stores and parks within walking distance of homes. 5. Distinctive Communities. Foster distinctive, attractive communities with a strong sense of place. Repurpose and rehabilitate building, preserving and use historic buildings in the plan. 6. Open Space. Preserve open space, farmland, natural beauty, and critical environmental areas from development. 7. Strengthen Existing Communities. Strengthen and direct development toward existing communities, areas that are already built up. 8. Transportation Choices. Provide a variety of transportation choices, not totally depending on the automobile. 9. Fair Development. Make decisions about development that are fair and cost effective. 10. Citizen Participation. Encourage citizens to participate in development decisions. In 1997, the Maryland General Assembly passed five pieces of legislation and budget initiatives: • • Priority Funding Areas Brownfields (reclaiming areas of abandoned or underused industrial facilities • • • where redevelopment is complicated by environmental contamination) Live Near Your Work Job Creation Tax Credits, and Rural Legacy These initiatives are known collectively as "Smart Growth." Smart Growth directs the State to target programs and funding to support established communities and locally designated growth areas, and to protect rural areas. One reason why the Maryland General Assembly supported this program is because of urban sprawl. Governor Glendening left office in 2002 and his successor, Governor Robert L. Ehrlich, Jr. (R), continued this program. He signed an executive order called Maryland Priority Places Strategy including a refocused state policy for Smart Growth and land use. Governor Ehrlich stated, “My administration intends to build upon smart growth by preserving its core mission – encouraging redevelopment in older communities and neighborhood.” Most land-use decisions are made through zoning and comprehensive land use plans by local governments. Each local government develops a Master Plan that provides for longrange planning to address growth and other land issues. Zoning regulates the type and size of development that is described in the plan. Today, zoning regulations would not permit construction of towns that look like historic Annapolis or Frederick. In Baltimore, there is a Planning Commission and a Department of Planning. The Planning Commission in its current form dates back to a revision of the City Charter in 1947. The Commission is a nine-member board composed of: six citizens appointed by the Mayor, the Director of the Department of Public Works or his designee, a member of the City Council, and the Mayor or his representative. The key responsibilities of the Commission are: Preparing and updating plans showing the physical development of the City; Developing a capital budget and six-year capital development program for consideration of the Board of Estimates; Developing and maintaining a Comprehensive Master Plan for the City; Reviewing all proposals for the subdivision of land within the City for conformance to specified standards; and Reviewing all proposed amendments to the City's Zoning Ordinance and making recommendations to the City Council. The Planning Commission relies on the staff of the Department of Planning to accomplish these mandates, as well as to carry out new responsibilities. Meetings of the Planning Commission are open to the public. Influencing Development In 2001, Baltimore’s Department of Planning began to address the economic and social trends that occurred since the previous rezoning in 1971. The Department sponsored a conference on rezoning and invited citizens, groups, and experts to explore issues related to zoning. In the months that followed, a plan was developed based on many of the ideas presented at the conference. State agencies also influence development by providing incentives for building in certain areas and by investing in transportation. In Maryland these areas include cities, areas inside the Baltimore and Washington beltways, industrial areas, and other areas designated by local jurisdictions. These areas receive funding for the infrastructure such as roads and schools. Both state and federal environmental agencies may influence development by requiring protection for wetlands or sensitive areas such as the Chesapeake Bay. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), a federal agency, is involved in Smart Growth initiatives. The EPA provides technical assistance and resources to communities to better manage open space conservation and redevelopment of contaminated industrial areas (brownfields). The EPA and the U.S. Conference of Mayors launched a Clean Air/Brownfields Partnership Pilot In Baltimore and other cities to demonstrate the effectiveness of innovative strategies designed to enhance both air quality and economic vitality. In addition to its duties of enforcing clean air and water standards, the EPA and a network of Smart Growth organizations wrote and distributed booklets about land use issues and possible solutions. A number of land use and other strategies could reduce air emissions in urban areas by reducing vehicle travel. Land Use and Development - Silver Spring Smart Growth has already changed land use and development in some neighborhoods in Maryland. Silver Spring, in Montgomery County, followed a pattern of development that is familiar. Through the years, it moved from a thriving suburb to a deteriorating town plagued with crime and empty buildings. Located on the Washington, D.C.Maryland line, it was an area ready for change. Local government, business, and community representatives stepped forward to meet the challenges of this area. County Executive Doug Duncan, builders, planners, state and local governments, and citizen activists worked together to develop a plan based on the principles of Smart Growth. The plan included residential, commercial, and public development with a combination of restaurants, stores and cultural entertainment. Leaders persuaded the owners of the Discovery Channel to locate in Silver Spring and build their worldwide corporate headquarters. This was helped by a state approved tax-credit. A key feature of Smart Growth is to encourage businesses to locate in existing urban areas instead of developing farms or forests. A tax rebate costs the government income, but saves spending by not having to support newly developed areas. The tax rebate also attracts businesses that may want to move to the state. Silver Spring serves as a model of the principles of Smart Growth. The town went from a deteriorating central business district to a commercial center with mixed-use development. Housing and the Metro, a major transportation system, are included in the mix. Urban sprawl was stopped and people are encouraged to live and work in this now thriving community. Land Use and the Chesapeake Bay Smart Growth impacts other policy areas. The Chesapeake Bay is Maryland’s greatest natural resource. The question of how to save the bay is a question that has been around for decades. In the 1980s, agreements to restore and protect the bay were signed by Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, Washington, D.C. and the EPA. A new agreement in 2000 focuses on the basic causes of the Bay’s decline – poor land use and sprawl development, excess nutrients and habitat destruction. Those who signed this agreement know that the fate of the Chesapeake Bay is tied to land use and development. The agreement includes commitments to principles of Smart Growth development. Smart Growth and Patapsco River Watershed Many of you may have enjoyed the beauty of Patapsco State Park or walked along the waters of the Patapsco River at the harbor. Will you continue to enjoy its beauty or walk or go fishing in this watershed? The 375,000 acres of the Patapsco River Watershed are located within Anne Arundel, Baltimore, Carroll, and Howard Counties, as well as Baltimore City, Maryland. The South branch of the Patapsco flows about 85 miles from Carroll County to the Middle Branch in Baltimore City. The North branch flows, through Liberty Reservoir and then joins the South branch not far from the town of Sykesville. After flowing into the Baltimore Harbor, the Patapsco River enters the Chesapeake Bay. Source: http://www.baltimorecountymd.gov/bin/g/o/patapscowshedcomap.gif The Patapsco River watershed's land use is diverse. The watershed contains forested areas, rural areas, productive farms, suburban, urban, and industrial areas. It is experiencing significant urban development. In the areas that are zoned, the land is mostly residential and about one-third is categorized as agricultural. Smart Growth programs give the jurisdictions in the Patapsco River Watershed the tools to purchase land and development rights within the area. Sound land use policies are key to protecting resources like the Patapsco River Valley Watershed. Debating Smart Growth Smart Growth policies still cause debate. Critics say that Smart Growth has not lived up to its claims of decreasing congestion or improving air quality. They say that in some areas traffic increased, land and housing prices increased, and commercial spaces were not useable. Proponents argue that the total economic, social and environmental benefits are tremendous. They point to increased use of public transportation, protected natural resources, and coordinated planning for neighborhoods and public spaces. They point to lower costs for infrastructure and preservation of open space. The nation is continuing to assess the impact of Smart Growth as more areas apply these principles to land use and development. Smart Growth Case Study: Baltimore Baltimore, MD, August 2007 The Issue So what does Smart Growth have to do with Baltimore? Baltimore has many of the elements that characterize smart growth - density, mixed-use neighborhoods, a vibrant waterfront, economic revitalization, and a transit system. According to the Baltimore City Department of Planning, the city also has vacant and brownfield properties, distressed versus growing neighborhoods, and the need for an improved transit system. Let’s look at several examples of the use of Smart Growth at work in Baltimore. Involvement, Implementation, and Influence American Can Company The City of Baltimore has been very successful in pursuing brownfield clean up and redevelopment opportunities for sites that were environmentally contaminated. There have been 30 brownfield projects completed since 1996. This has produced more than 3,000 new or retained jobs and $300+ million in new investment. A combination of federal, state and local initiatives aided these redevelopment efforts. Study the picture. Do you recognize this area in the photograph? Source/ www.mde.state.md.us: assets:image:amercan_can.jpg Abandoned for more than a decade, the former American Can site became the first property in Maryland to complete the state's Voluntary Cleanup Program. At its prime, American Can Company employed 800 residents of Baltimore. When it merged with the National Can Company in the 1980s, the factory was boarded up. The site is located at the intersection of Boston and Hudson Streets in Baltimore's Inner Harbor district. This site contained industrial contaminants and had to be cleaned before it could be used for other purposes. The project was completed by Struever Bros. Eccles & Rouse, Inc. in 1998 and involved a $19 million renovation of a vacant factory into a vibrant retail and office center. It is now home to an office complex that houses 1,525 employees. http://www.dnr.state.md.us/education/growfromhere/LESSON13/LESSON13_1.HTM#Slide10 American Can Company - After Montgomery Park Business Center The 1925 art deco-style Montgomery Ward Catalog Building in Baltimore was an eyesore. Located off Interstate 95 and Route 1, the building has easy access to Washington D.C and Thurgood Marshall Baltimore Washington Airport. Again, planners, businesses and all levels of government worked together to transform the former Montgomery Ward building from a shell into a powerful model for innovative development. This rehabilitation shows how an historic landmark can be transformed into an ecologically minded center. The adaptive reuse project by an architecture/engineering firm in Washington D.C., restored the facade of the landmark building and installed a 30,000-square foot "green" roof. The project incorporates many "green" features, including: a green roof planted with Alpine vegetation; high-efficiency mechanical and electrical systems; a gray water conservation system capturing storm run-off; recycled building materials; insulated glass; energy saving lighting with photocell dimming and occupancy sensors; and energy efficient, high-speed elevators. http://www.montgomerypark.com/img/photogallery/mp-ext-02.jpg Now home to the State of Maryland's Department of the Environment, the renamed "Montgomery Park Business Center" had been an abandoned brownfield site for 15 years. The urban revitalization project preserves some of Maryland's valuable open land by providing new office space without causing further sprawl. The warehouse conversion both preserves historic integrity and fulfills the high technology needs of modern business tenants. Support for this $100 million redevelopment project came from Brownfields Assessment Pilot and Showcase Community staff, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) grant and an $8 million HUD loan. National Aquarium Officials at the Baltimore National Aquarium are also working with the Brownfields Showcase Community team to create the federal, state, and local partnerships needed to develop a 60,000 to 80,000 square-foot Center for Aquatic Life and Conservation. In addition to providing care for marine wildlife, Aquarium officials plan to use the center to teach visitors about environmental stewardship by showing them the connections between themselves and the natural world around them. The center will partner with universities to train students in marine biology and other subjects. Aquarium officials have also formed a partnership with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to create new wetlands and habitat areas along the harbor. The Aquarium will use these new natural areas to teach citizens and organizations about the importance of environmental preservation. Poppleton Neighborhood In an area just west of the downtown business district lies the Poppleton neighborhood of Baltimore City. It is poised for a turnaround after losing 37% of its population in the 1990s. In 2005, this neighborhood became part of the Priority Places initiative to help communities achieve Smart Growth by designating projects for state assistance and attention. The City hopes to transform Poppleton into a mixed-income neighborhood that will attract middle-income homebuyers and improve quality of life for current residents. The University of Maryland, Baltimore, is building a BioPark in the area that is expected to bring about 3,000 jobs to the area. A unique aspect of the BioPark is that the residents of the neighborhood - Poppleton - were integrally involved with the development of the project. The project is expected to eventually generate about $290 million in economic activity, $1.4 million in city tax revenue and 3,000 jobs, more than a third of which would be open to lower-skilled workers. As you study the map, note the location of Poppleton. Also note the other areas where Baltimore City planners are working to make our city better. Source: http://www.ci.baltimore.md.us/government/planning/images/small-area-plans.gif The Poppleton project is part of the Priority Places program and the state sees it as an opportunity for many state agencies to support transit, housing, business development and neighborhood recreation elements in Poppleton. Mount Vernon Urban Renewal Plan As part of the Smart Growth Plan, Baltimore City planners use Mount Vernon as a case study for residential development. A plan was developed in 2005 and it uses regulatory controls for preservation of architectural and historic character. In other words, the area was preserved rather than demolished. The main goals are: • To help maintain and protect the existing architectural and historic fabric of the community; • To use the historic architecture of the neighborhood as a theme to attract growth and development; • To ensure an active, pedestrian-friendly environment that encourages pedestrian activity; • To encourage urban accessibility by providing sufficient parking while encouraging the shared use of parking spaces and promoting transit; • To assure that the neighborhood and business associations participate in the conceptual process for future development in their area. Impact Lessons Learned Baltimore is a showcase of Smart Growth projects. The Baltimore City Planning Department reviewed hundreds of examples of projects to develop priorities relevant to this city. They asked individuals, groups, business and government leaders for ideas. These ideas led to a master plan that will continue to sustain development and improve the livability of the city. The planners incorporated many national Smart Growth strategies, but developed the plan with a focus on urban environment. Baltimore studied the national Smart Growth principles and then created a set of principles to reflect the challenges – and opportunities – of the city. National Smart Growth Principles 1. Mix land use. 2. Compact Living Design. 3. Housing opportunities and choices. 4. Create walkable neighborhoods. 5. Foster distinctive, attractive communities with a strong sense of place. 6. Preserve open space, farmland, natural beauty and critical environmental areas. 7. Strengthen and direct development towards existing communities. 8. Provide a variety of transportation choices. 9. Make development decisions predictable, fair and cost effective. 10. Encourage community and stakeholder collaboration in development decisions. Baltimore Smart Growth Principles 1. Promote quality urban design and improved permitting processes to encourage development. 2. Implement mechanisms to encourage redevelopment of declining commercial districts. 3. Target redevelopment for maximum City and neighborhood benefit. 4. Implement measures to ensure housing affordability and diversity. 5. Implement mechanisms to promote economic opportunities that stimulate pedestrian activity. 6. Improve transportation access and choice. 7. Promote preservation and reuse of historic structures. 8. Strengthen relationships with universities and colleges. 9. Improve and preserve public parks and open space. 10. Promote public schools and libraries as community assets Source: http://www.ci.baltimore.md.us/government/planning/images/SmartGrowthReport.pdf The Challenge Are you interested in the development and revitalization or Baltimore? If so, begin by reviewing the Baltimore Smart Growth principles. These principles are a stepping-stone to discussion of ways to redevelop a city with an aging infrastructure, historic structures, commercial/industrial properties, and cultural institutions into a vibrant urban center. You hold the key to this vibrant city. Are you the individual or group member who will take the time to help renew and revitalize Baltimore? Session 7: Smart Growth Case Study: Baltimore Overview Students analyze a case study, Smart Growth: Baltimore, and apply the issue analysis approach to Baltimore. This session incorporates many of the skills and knowledge necessary for success on the Government High School Assessment. Objectives: 1. Compare climate, land use, natural resources, population distribution, demographic and density maps of Maryland and the United States 2. Evaluate the way national, state, and local governments develop policy to address land use and environmental issues, such as urban sprawl, Smart Growth and commercial use of public (3.1.2 e) Assessment Limits Entitlements: Social Security, welfare; Health care and public health; censorship, Crime, Equity, Environmental Land use, smart growth, and urban sprawl Key Questions 1. What is urban sprawl? 2. How does the national, state and local government address how land is used?? Key Terms Urban sprawl Comprehensive plans Zoning laws Smart Growth Priority funding area Directions 1. Activating Prior Knowledge. Ask students: • What are advantages and disadvantages of Smart Growth to solve land use and development issues? • Will Smart Growth principles help with land use and development issues in Baltimore? 2. Developing Understanding – Before and During Reading – Smart Growth: Baltimore. Explain that some of the advantages and disadvantages may be seen in Baltimore, a city that uses many of the Smart Growth principles. Distribute Smart Growth Case Study: Baltimore. Set the purpose to read: Describe how problems of land use, development and revitalization are solved by government as well as non-governmental groups and individuals in Baltimore Direct students to the graphic organizer to analyze the issue. 3. Checking for Understanding - After Reading –Smart Growth - Baltimore. Make a transparency of the Smart Growth organizer to record student response. Conduct a brief whole class discussion: • Is the problem of land use and development solved in Baltimore? • What are the options to Smart Growth for Baltimore? • Will you contact the mayor, other elected officials, or Department of Planning to give your ideas about development in Baltimore? What methods will you use? 4. Checking for Understanding - BCR. Conclude this unit with the following BCR as a check for understanding. • What is public policy? • Evaluate how governments, individuals, and groups shape and set public policy? • Include details and examples to support your response. Additional Resources: 1. United States Government Democracy in Action (Remy, Glencoe/McGraw-Hill), provides limited information about land use. 2. Where Do We Grow from Here? A Teacher’s Guide on Growth and Its Impacts in Maryland, Maryland Department of Natural Resources (http://www.dnr.state.md.us) 3. Web Resources Smart Growth Home http://www.mde.state.md.us/Programs/MultimediaProgra Smart Growth and the urban growth boundary in Baltimore County. http://www.co.ba.md.us/Agencies/planning/masterplanning Frederick County, MD - Official Website - Smart Growth (PFA) ... http://www.co.frederick.md.us/index.asp?NID=1453 Duncan Announces Smart Growth Initiatives For Silver Spring; Pepco ... http://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/mc/news/press/97 Smart Growth News: Baltimore Directions: Before you read Smart Growth News Part 2, review the following questions. After reading, respond to these questions. Issue • What is the issue? • Who is affected by the issue? • What are possible solutions to the issue? Influences • How can citizens, media, political parties, and interest groups influence the issue and solution? What methods will they use? Involvement • Who is involved in the issue – individuals, groups, and/or government? • Which levels and/or branches of government may be involved? Impact • What is the possible impact of the plan? Will it solve the issue? • Does the policy solve the original issue? Should it continue, be modified, or the issue be redefined? Unit 6 End of Unit Assessment 1. Between 1946 and 1964, a large population increase, known as the "baby boom," occurred in the United States. Which of these federal agencies will probably be most affected by the aging of these "baby boomers"? A. the Department of Labor B. the Social Security Administration C. the Agriculture Department D. the Federal Trade Commission 2. Which of these is the most likely impact on counties experiencing population growth? A. a decrease in revenue from local sales tax B. a decrease in housing costs C. an increase in the need for public services D. an increase in school closings 3. Which of these local population statistics would be most useful in deciding where to construct a public high school? A. political party identity B. family composition C. occupation D. religion Look at the graph below. 4. Increasing the budget for which of these programs would most help the United States government prepare for the trend shown in the graph? A. B. C. D. defense education social security employment opportunities 5. Which of these is an example of government funding based on population? A. City councils award contracts to waste management companies. B. The federal government gives grant money for environmental clean up. C. School districts receive money from the state for each student enrolled. D. A state approves placing stoplights at busy intersections. 6. Which of these activities is most likely a part of the United States Census? A. B. C. D. polling experts to establish foreign policy inspecting businesses to enforce safety laws surveying homes to determine population figures training workers to increase industrial productivity 7. In 2000, the population of Frederick County, Maryland, was 195,277, which was an increase of 30 percent from 1990. Which of these contributed to the change in population? A. approval of development plans by local county officials B. implementation of strict environmental regulations C. adoption of higher property tax rates D. establishment of farmland preservation plans 8. The Maryland State Highway Administration is considering a plan to widen three miles of a major route from two lanes to six lanes. Which of these most likely caused this planned action? A. a decrease in trucking B. an increase in population C. an increase in unemployment rates D. a decrease in construction work 9. Which of these is a purpose of Social Security? A. B. C. D. to provide income for retirees to regulate the health care industry to give relocation assistance to immigrants to encourage taxpayer contributions to charities 10. What do Medicaid, food stamps, and Social Security have in common? A. They are funded by private corporations. B. They are administered by state governments. C. They provide economic assistance around the world. D. They provide support for people in the United States. 11. Which region of Maryland would benefit most from research on Chesapeake Bay's infectious water diseases? A. Eastern Shore B. Central Maryland C. Western Maryland D. Baltimore–Washington area Read the scenario below. In Congress, representatives from the Northwest are asking for funds to clean up the Pacific Ocean after an oil spill, while representatives from the Southeast are asking for money to rebuild after a devastating hurricane. 12. What problem does this present to Congress? A. balancing the needs of different regions B. choosing representatives to serve on committees C. developing the ability to predict natural disasters D. deciding the role of the local governments in natural disasters 13. The states of Maryland, Virginia, and Delaware joined together during the 1980s and 1990s in an effort to reduce pollution in the Chesapeake Bay. This is an example of a government policy being shaped by A. regional interests B. national interests C. community interests D. international interests 14. Which of these actions would the Federal Reserve most likely take to help end a recession? A. print more currency B. reduce the interest rate C. sell government securities D. increase the reserve requirement 15. Which of these sets monetary policy in the United States? A. Federal Reserve System B. Secretary of the Treasury C. Senate Budget Committee D. Federal Trade Commission 16. Which of these public agencies usually decides local land-use issues? A. zoning board B. treasurer's office C. police department D. transportation department 17. Which of these is an economic goal of United States government policy? A. to limit competition B. to create a classless society C. to promote full employment D. to own the means of production 18. Maryland lost approximately 10,000 acres of forest land each year between 1985 and 1990. Which of these government actions would have done the most to reduce the loss? A. eliminating zoning laws B. limiting the development of real estate C. reducing funds for environmental studies D. decreasing the number of wildlife preservation areas Read the scenario below. At last night's city council meeting, environmentalists objected to plans for building a new shopping center. The environmentalists said that many native species of plants and animals found at the proposed site would become endangered if the land were developed. Developers say the shopping center will provide new jobs. 19. What problem does the scenario present for the city government? A. assessing the safety of building codes B. balancing opposing opinions about land use C. settling a conflict between competing private businesses D. determining the responsibilities of local and state agencies 20. Maryland's Smart Growth Areas Act of 1999 encourages the building of new homes in vacant city lots. Which of these is a reason Maryland's government passed this law? A. to eliminate the use of unsanitary water B. to prevent over-development of rural areas C. to encourage farmers to produce larger crops D. to encourage more people to own small businesses Source: Public Release Items Government HSA Study the graph below and use it to answer the BRIEF CONSTRUCTED RESPONSE that follows. Using the information in the bar graph, identify funding decisions the Maryland General Assembly would make regarding money for local governments. Describe the effects these decisions would have on local government decisions. Include details from the graph to support your answer. Source: Public Release Items Government HSA Study the table below and use it to answer the EXTENDED CONSTRUCTED RESPONSE that follows. Year 1963 1967 1972 1990 Legislation Equal Pay Act Description Forbids wage discrimination based on race, sex, color, religion, or national origin Age Discrimination Prohibits discrimination against employees forty years in Employment Act of age and older Higher Education Forbids discrimination on the basis of gender in Act universities and colleges that receive federal aid Americans with Forbids discrimination in employment, transportation, Disabilities Act and public accommodations against people with physical or mental disabilities Explain how these government actions protect the rights of citizens. Explain how these actions have expanded the role of government. Do you believe these government actions were effective? Explain why or why not. Include details and examples to support your answer. Source: Public Release Items Government HSA