Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Trade Openness and Labour Market Institutions during Global Economic Downturns Elisa Gamberoni (World Bank) Erik von Uexkull (ILO, Trade and Employment Programme) Sebastian Weber (HEID) Presented by Marion Jansen (ILO) Latin American and Caribbean Labor Markets and the Global Economy, Santiago de Chile, June 14, 2011 The crisis has led to declines in GDP and employment growth around the world: 0,7 0 -0,8 -3,9 -6,2 -4,3 -5,1 -0,6 -3,7 -0,3 -2,1 -1,9 -4,7 -6,1 -0,2 -5,7 -8,2 -14,1 Change in Real GDP growth (2009 - 2007) Change in Employment growth (2009 - 2007) Source: ILO Global Employment Trends -1,2 -6,2 This raises some obvious questions... • What role can policy play to mitigate the employment effect and promote recovery? • How long will it take for employment growth to recover? • Will there be “catch-up” growth in employment, or will employment remain below its pre-crisis trend? Past global downturns 5 4 World GDP growth 3 2 1 Employment growth 1991 crisis Asian crisis .com bubble and 9/11 -1 -2 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 0 The impact of crises on employment • Alternatively: Laeven and Valencia (2008) dataset on domestic debt and banking crisis (country specific) • Employment growth from 1985 to 2008 from ILO Laborsta and KILM (excluding TREND estimations) • Sample of 42 countries with at least 10 years of data: 20 industrialized and 22 developing countries • Data on severance pay in monthly salaries after 9 months, 4 years, 20 years of employment from IMF / Fondazione Debenedetti • Data on share of previous wage replaced by unemployment benefits 1 year after job loss from IMF / Fondazione Debenedetti • Trade openness from WDI Some Stylized Facts Global Downturn Domestic Debt or Banking Crisis 1. Reduced Employment growth for 2 years 2. Little evidence of catch up 3. Stronger decline under domestic crisis (~ -2%) than global downturn (~ -1%) The Model and its Limitations • Arellano-Bond dynamic GMM estimation • Model captures the impact of crisis and policy variables in the first 3 years short run view • Asymmetric: only negative shocks • Does not capture all labour market policies, nor impact on wages, working hours, informality • Why? DATA restrictions Higher severance pay dampens the negative effect on employment growth… Global Crisis -2 -2 0 0 Domestic Crisis -4 -4 High severance pay (Mean + 1 SDev) 90%-CI High Low -6 -6 Low severance pay (Mean - 1 SDev) 0 2 4 6 Years after crisis 8 010 2 4 6 Years after crisis 8 10 ....And unemployment benefits are associated with stronger reductions in employment growth... Global Crisis Crisis Global -1 0 2 4 6 Years after crisis 8 -6-4 High UBs -2 -2 Low UBs High UBs (Mean - 1 SDev) -3 -4 -2 -4 Low UBs (Mean + 1 SDev) -6 countries Sample Excluding Total with very high benefits 0 00 Domestic Crisis 10 0 0 2 2 4 6 4Years after crisis 6 Years after crisis 8 8 90%-CI 90%-CI Low Low High High 10 10 ...Greater trade integration means larger initial shock but also faster recovery -2 -2 0 Global Crisis 0 Domestic Crisis High Openness (Mean + 1 SDev) -4 -4 Low Openness (Mean – 1 SDev) -6 -6 90%-CI Low High 0 2 4 6 Years after crisis 8 0 10 2 4 6 Years after crisis 8 10 Conclusions 1. First line of defense is to avoid for global downturn to lead to domestic crisis 2. Preferred labour market policy makes may depend on whether shocks are temporary or structural: keeping people employed may be preferable in times of crisis 3. Raising trade protection during crisis endangers the recovery of the labour market