Download Source: Ahmed 2004 Determinants of Spread

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts
no text concepts found
Transcript
OECD Conference
on
“How to Reduce Debt Costs
in Southern Africa?”
Johannesburg, March 25-26, 2004
Presentation by Vivek Arora (IMF)
on “Sovereign Spreads in South Africa”
This paper should not be reported as representing the views of the IMF. The views expressed are those of the author and do not
necessarily reflect the views of the IMF or IMF policy.
I
Introduction
Two main questions:
1.
2.
Why do sovereign spreads matter?
What determines sovereign spreads?
1.
Role of spreads in a small open economy with relatively free
capital flows:
•
Key determinant of domestic interest rates (i = i* + E(e) +
spread);
Close correlation with interest rates in South Africa (Figure 1 of
Ahmed (2004)).
•
Indicator of external vulnerability.
Figure 1:
Long-term Government Bond Yields vs. Risk Premium
(In percent)
20
16
12
8
4
0
1997
1999
2000
2001
2002
Long-term Government Bond Yields
Sovereign Spread
Sources: South African Reserve Bank, Quarterly Bulletin
2003
2.
Literature:
Emerging market spreads are influenced by both global factors:
•
risk appetite,
•
industrial country interest rates,
•
liberalization of investment rules;
and country-specific factors:
•
public finances,
•
international reserves and obligations,
•
inflation expectations.
II
What determines sovereign spreads in emerging markets?
Theory
Arbitrage condition: the risk-adjusted payoff on emerging market bonds and
risk-free bonds must be equal:
(1+r) = p. (1+i) + (1-p).0, where (1-p) = risk of nonrepayment.
Spread, S, or emerging market rate minus risk-free rate is:
S = (1+r).(1-p)/p
The spread rises in response to higher risk from:
(i) domestic factors (1-p); and (ii) global factors (r).
The literature focuses on:
(i) identifying sources of (1-p) and r; and (ii) the relative importance of
domestic and global risk.
Empirical evidence
Both domestic and global factors matter [Table 1, Arora and Cerisola
(2001)].
Domestic factors: Net foreign assets; fiscal balance and government debt;
foreign reserves; external debt and debt service.
Global factors: industrial-country interest rates; world market volatility.
Previous empirical literature was inconclusive partly because it focused on
launch spreads and ignored market volatility.
A
From Arora and Cerisola (2001)
Table 1. Determinants of Sovereign Bond Spreads for Selected Emerging Markets
Argentina
94:4-99:12
Brazil
94:4-99:12
Mexico
94:4-99:12
Panama
96:8-99:12
Colombia
97:4-99:12
Poland
94:11-99:12
Bulgaria
95:06-99:12
Philippines
94:4-99:12
Thailand
97:11-99:12
Korea
98:7-99:12
U.S. 10-year treasury yield
0.51
(.000)
0.96
(.000)
0.84
(.000)
0.21
(.208)
0.54
(.000)
1.01
(.000)
1.08
(.000)
0.54
(.000)
0.54
(.002)
1.54
(.000)
Net foreign assets
(in percent of GDP)
-0.05
(.000)
…
…
-0.09
(.000)
-0.47
(.001)
-0.32
(.000)
0.00
(.493)
…
-0.01
(.000)
-0.08
(.000)
Fiscal balance
(in percent of GDP)
…
-0.01
(.395)
…
-0.09
(.000)
…
…
…
…
…
…
Gross reserves to imports
…
…
-0.39
(.708)
…
…
-2.25
(.050)
…
-3.71
(.002)
…
…
Debt-service ratio
…
…
…
…
…
…
0.02
(.011)
0.01
(0.117)
0.11
(.036)
…
0.14
(.000)
0.101
(.000)
0.06
(.000)
…
0.21
(.000)
…
…
0.08
(.000)
…
…
Total external debt
(in percent of GDP)
…
…
…
0.09
(.000)
…
…
…
…
…
…
Dummy2
…
…
…
…
…
…
-0.53
(.000)
…
…
…
0.53
0.33
0.24
0.60
0.76
0.50
0.57
0.29
0.77
0.75
Period
Central government debt
(in percent of GDP)
Adjusted R -squared
Source: IMF staff estimates.
Note: Probablility values, for the null hypothesis of a coefficient equal to zero, are reported in parentheses. Standard errors have been
adjusted following the Newey-West procedure.
1
Refers to net debt.
III
Sovereign spreads in South Africa
Based on Ahmed (2004)
Data
Sample: June 1997- September 2003 monthly data.
Spread: on 20-year U.S.$500 million government bond issued in 1997 over
comparable U.S. Treasury security. [Also: EMBISA, for comparison.]
Global factors: proxied by EMBI spread for emerging markets, and its volatility.
Domestic factors: Domestic and foreign debt levels and maturities; forward
book and NOFP; inflation; exchange rate volatility; GDP growth.
Results
Both global and domestic factors matter. The forward book was a
significant contributor to sovereign spreads.
Source: Ahmed 2004
Determinants of Spread (Specification 1)
Independent Variables
Dependent Variable:
SPREAD
EMBISP
0.41
(6.47)
0.42
(6.99)
0.43
(7.84)
DEBT_F
9.27
(0.57)
16.50
(0.92)
22.45
(1.34)
MATURITY_F
2.97
(2.03)
3.19
(2.17)
2.98
(2.29)
DEBT_D
-2.10
(-0.77)
-2.38
(-0.83)
-3.52
(-1.26)
MATURITY_D
5.44
(1.27)
4.45
(1.01)
2.83
(0.74)
FORWB
7.43
(1.77)
36.94
(2.97)
-21.88
(-1.87)
NOFP
INFL
2.67
(0.72)
2.60
(0.71)
1.22
(0.34)
EXCHDEPR
-0.12
(-0.10)
0.16
(0.14)
0.58
(0.46)
RGDPGROWTH
-17.70
(-2.04)
-21.48
(-2.35)
-26.40
(-3.07)
-0.77
(-2.42)
FORWBSQR
-0.49
(-1.57)
NOFPSQR
R-squared
0.93
.93
.94
Specification 1:
Significant variables:
• EMBI spread
• Maturity of foreign debt
• NOFP, consistent with previous analysis by Jonsson (2001)
• Forward book, non-linear impact
• GDP growth
Not significant: levels of debt; inflation; exchange rate volatility.
Source: Ahmed 2004
Determinants of Spread (Specification 2)
Sample: 1997:06-2003:09
Independent Variables
SPREAD (-1)
EMBISP
DEBT_F
MATURITY_F
DEBT_D
MATURITY_D
FORWB
Dependent Variable: SPREAD (Dynamic Specification)
0.37
(3.03)
0.26
(2.62)
13.31
(0.91)
1.94
(1.03)
-2.66
(-0.98)
2.75
(0.88)
5.84
(2.28)
NOFP
INFL
EXCHVOL
RGDPGROWTH
1.17
(0.39)
-1.44
(-0.15)
-18.40
(-2.36)
0.39
(3.15)
0.27
(2.77)
23.72
(1.73)
2.21
(1.15)
-3.17
(-1.21)
0.53
(0.16)
-26.86
(-3.26)
0.49
(0.16)
2.73
(0.29)
-27.11
(-3.39)
FORWBSQR
NOFPSQR
Adj R-squared
0.38
(3.40)
0.27
(3.10)
27.02
(2.20)
1.87
(1.08)
-4.31
(-1.81)
-0.26
(-0.09)
36.99
(4.09)
-0.39
(-0.13)
1.68
(0.20)
-29.99
(-4.08)
-0.83
(-3.44)
-0.69
(-3.01)
0.94
0.95
0.95
Specification 2 (with lagged dependent variable):
Significant variables:
• EMBI spread
• Persistence, measured by previous month’s spread
• Level of foreign debt
• NOFP
• Forward book, again a non-linear impact
• NIR
• GDP growth
Not significant: debt maturity; inflation; exchange rate volatility.
B
Source: Ahmed (2004)
Regression with significant variables
Independent
Variables
Dependent Variable: SPREAD
Dependent Variable:
EMBISA
EMBISP
0.42
(9.10)
0.45
(9.11)
0.41
(7.41)
0.32
(8.03)
0.32
(6.29)
0.30
(6.64)
MATURITY_F
3.17
(1.88)
3.08
(1.79)
3.16
(1.89)
3.21
(1.69)
3.20
(1.67)
3.23
(1.74)
FORWB
9.59
(3.18)
9.98
(4.67)
14.74
(4.66)
14.77
(5.09)
-8.13
(-2.41)
NOFP
RGDPGROWTH
R-squared
-13.58
(-3.37)
-17.61
(-2.16)
-24.04
(-2.89)
-15.22
(-1.78)
-18.46
(-1.61)
-18.90
(-1.42)
-14.93
(-1.21)
.93
.93
.92
.89
.89
.88
Regressions with significant variables
(Dynamic Specification)
Independent Variables
Dependent Variable: SPREAD
SPREAD(-1)
0.36
(3.76)
0.35
(3.67)
0.38
(3.88)
EMBISP
0.29
(4.69)
0.32
(4.62)
0.28
(4.31)
MATURITY_F
2.36
(1.68)
2.33
(1.68)
2.31
(1.64)
FORWB
5.70
(3.46)
6.12
(3.73)
-4.64
(-3.13)
NOFP
RGDPGROWTH
R-squared
-16.61
(-2.45)
-20.59
(-2.76)
-15.48
(-2.27)
0.95
0.95
0.94
Parsimonious specification:
• NOFP (8bp)
• Forward book(10bp)
• GDP growth (15-24 bp)
• EMBI spread (0.4bp)
•Debt Maturity (3bp)
Main message: Eliminating first the NOFP and then the forward book contributed
significantly to lower spreads. Building up reserves should help further reduce spreads.
Also, reduce currency volatility
IV
Impact on domestic interest rates
How do spreads matter for the economy? Impact on domestic interest rates.
• Channels:
Repo rate (through inflation expectations);
Longer-term rates through shift in the term structure and (for
nongovernment debt) through change in credit risk.
• In South Africa, Ahmed: 100bp increase in spreads  40-65 bp increase
in long-term domestic government interest rates.
• Inflation is significant in determining domestic interest rates, as expected
through the interest parity condition:
Vocke (2003): a 1 percentage point inflation gap (deviation of inflation
from target) adds 13–15 basis points to spreads of domestic-currency
interest rates to U.S. rates.
Ahmed (2003): 100 bp increase in SA-US expected inflation differential
 80 bp increase in domestic interest rates.
Exchange rate volatility is reduced through higher reserves: Hviding et al.
(2004).
Gross foreign exchange reserves and the ratio of gross reserves to shortterm debt plus the forward book were both significant, with negative sign.
Table 3: Determinants of RESIDUAL
Dependent Variable: Log of RESIDUAL
Sample size: 2000:03-2003:06
Independent
Variables
LINFLDIFF_B
1.07
(9.22)
1.06
(8.73)
0.96
(6.56)
0.97
(8.78)
0.93
(8.07)
0.84
(5.75)
LREER
0.28
(1.45)
0.44
(2.16)
0.49
(2.41)
-0.67
(-2.00)
-0.76
(-2.14)
-0.77
(-2.32)
NETBRSA_GDP
0.05
(0.95)
0.04
(1.03)
0.04
(0.74)
LDEBT_F
0.20
(1.37)
0.03
(0.37)
0.07
(0.66)
LDEBT_D
0.64
(2.63)
0.74
(2.82)
0.78
(2.94)
INDCOIN
-0.01
(-1.89)
-0.02
(-1.45)
-0.03
(-0.91)
CAPUTIL
0.03
(0.97)
GROWTH
EXCHCON0203
Adj. R-squared
-0.01
(-0.25)
0.07
(1.05)
0.29
(4.48)
0.21
(4.29)
0.26
(3.50)
0.22
(3.35)
0.21
(2.84)
0.24
(3.15)
0.79
0.77
0.77
0.81
0.80
0.81
Determinants of long-term interest rates
• Spread
• Expected inflation differential (S.A. – U.S.)
• Debt
• Exchange controls
Contribute to the currency
premium
V
Conclusion: main messages
Both domestic and global factors affect South Africa, but domestic factors
matter more.
Eliminating first the NOFP and then the forward book contributed
significantly to lower spreads. Building up reserves should help further
reduce spreads.
Source: Ahmed (2004)
Regressions with log specifications
Independent
Variables
Dependent Variable: LSPREAD
LEMBISP
0.73
(9.58)
0.74
(10.69)
0.70
(9.75)
LDEBT_F
0.22
(1.27)
0.15
(0.91)
0.26
(1.49)
MATURITY_F
0.009
(2.40)
0.008
(2.22)
0.008
(2.48)
LDEBT_D
-0.37
(-1.74)
-0.27
(-1.26)
-0.34
(-1.72)
MATURITY_D
0.02
(1.61)
0.02
(1.55)
0.01
(1.09)
LFORWB
0.31
(2.57)
LNIR
-0.47
(-2.43)
LGFEXRSV
-0.29
(-3.46)
LRESSTDEBTFB
INFL
0.008
(0.90)
0.01
(1.71)
0.008
(1.03)
EXCHDEPR
0.003
(0.82)
0.002
(0.71)
0.003
(0.86)
RGDPGROWTH
-0.08
(-3.03)
-0.06
(-2.22)
-0.07
(-2.86)
0.94
0.94
0.94
R-squared
References
Ahmed, Faisal, 2004, “Determinants of Interest Rates in South Africa,” draft, IMF,
March.
Arora, Vivek and Martin Cerisola, 2001, “How Does U.S. Monetary Policy Influence
Sovereign Spreads in Emerging Markets?” IMF Staff Papers, Vol. 48, 3, pp.
474-98.
Giavazzi, Francesco, 2003, “Inflation Targeting and the Fiscal Policy Regime,” Bank of
England Quarterly Bulletin, Autumn, pp. 334-342.
Jonsson, Gunnar, 2001, “The Risk Premium in South African Long-Term Interest
Rates,” in South Africa—Recent Economic Developments (unpublished,
IMF).
Vocke, Matthias, 2003, “Sovereign Risk Spreads Under Inflation Targeting,” in South
Africa, Selected Issues: IMF Staff Country Report, January 2003.
Related documents