Download Three Views on Aid and Growth

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts
no text concepts found
Transcript
“Aid and Growth”
Steve Radelet
Center for Global Development
June 21, 2006
MDB Meeting on Debt Issues
Three Views on Aid and
Growth
View #1: No relationship, or
a negative relationship
Boone, Rajan & Subramanian
 Almost always assumes a
linear relationship

View #2: Conditional
Relationship

Depends on recipients (good
governance; strong policies)
 Burnside
& Dollar, Collier &
Dehn
 Interaction term, assumes linear
relationship
 Fragile (Easterly, Levine, &
Roodman)

Conditional relationship could
also depend on the
characteristics of donors, but
not well researched.
View #3: Positive
relationship, on average, with
diminishing returns
Hansen & Tarp; Hajimichael,
et. al, 1995; Durbarry et al,
1998; Lensink and White,
2001; and Dalgaard, et al,
2004
 Diminishing returns
 Less well known

“Counting Chickens”



Key characteristics: Diminishing
returns and disaggregation
Three Categories of Aid
Focus on “early-impact” aid with
most direct plausible connections
to growth, with diminishing
returns
2SLS
2SLS
2SLS
OLS
OLS
Connections to other
strands of the literature:
What do the results
look like with
diminishing returns and
disaggregation?
 Burnside
& Dollar
 Hansen and Tarp
 Rajan & Subramanian
Links to Burnside and Dollar 1
B&D
B&D
replication replaication,
larger
dataset
Net EDA/PPP GDP
Net EDA/PPP GDP * policy
-0.242
(0.259)
0.253
(0.121)**
-0.218
(0.266)
0.0719
(0.0678)
Net EDA/PPP GDP squared
With aid
squared
Switch to
Short/PPP
GDP
-1.17
(0.825)
0.177
(0.149)
Short-impact ODA/PPP GDP
0.470
(0.403)
-0.0602
(0.0366)
Short-impact ODA/PPP GDP squared
Short-impact ODA/XR GDP
0.506
(0.227)**
-0.0309
(0.0131)**
Short-impact ODA/XR GDP squared
Log repayments/PPP GDP
-0.231
(0.291)
Log repayments/XR GDP
Log initial GDP per capita
Ethnic fractionalization
Assasinations
Ethnic * assasinations
Sub-Saharan Africa
East Asia
Institutional quality
M2/GDP lagged
Policy index
Observations
R -squared
Switch to
Short/XR
GDP
-0.832
(0.774)
-0.672
(0.844)
-0.760
(0.445)*
0.634
(0.903)
-2.11
(0.727)***
1.46
(0.712)**
0.845
(0.193)***
0.025
(0.017)
0.591
(0.378)
-0.365
(0.638)
-0.121
(0.816)
-0.293
(0.223)
0.047
(0.605)
-1.39
(0.648)**
0.80
(0.519)
0.395
(0.134)***
0.006
(0.012)
0.869
(0.171)***
-0.604
(0.669)
0.036
(0.834)
-0.249
(0.232)
-0.017
(0.607)
-1.20
(0.643)*
0.47
(0.502)
0.426
(0.141)***
0.001
(0.013)
1.04
(0.140)***
-0.207
(0.628)
0.071
(0.750)
-0.337
(0.227)
0.135
(0.611)
-1.65
(0.705)**
0.78
(0.507)
0.398
(0.136)***
0.001
(0.010)
1.00
(0.148)***
-0.090
(0.290)
0.248
(0.680)
0.286
(0.741)
-0.315
(0.224)
0.162
(0.611)
-1.84
(0.768)**
1.01
(0.528)*
0.409
(0.139)***
-0.007
(0.011)
0.942
(0.146)***
184
0.472
361
0.346
361
0.313
361
0.338
361
0.332
Links to Burnside and Dollar 2
With aid
squared
Net EDA/PPP GDP
Net EDA/PPP GDP squared
Replace
EDA with
ODA
Replace
PPP with
XRGDP
0.428
(0.446)
-0.0384
(0.0533)
Net ODA/PPP GDP
0.358
(0.205)*
-0.0268
(0.0126)**
Net ODA/PPP GDP squared
Net ODA/XR GDP
0.285
(0.111)**
-0.00845
(0.00346)**
Net ODA/XR GDP squared
Gross ODA/XR GDP
0.046
(0.622)
2.18
(0.475)***
0.302
(0.111)***
-1.81
(0.374)***
1.81
(1.91)
-2.37
(0.810)***
1.90
(0.693)***
-1.96
(0.411)***
5.13
(4.58)
1.18
(0.401)***
0.0507
(0.576)
2.27
(0.471)***
0.316
(0.107)***
-1.80
(0.377)***
1.92
(1.90)
-2.33
(0.796)***
1.86
(0.666)***
-1.93
(0.422)***
4.60
(4.63)
1.07
(0.404)***
0.277
(0.557)
2.43
(0.471)***
0.316
(0.104)***
-1.85
(0.369)***
2.50
(1.95)
-2.39
(0.798)***
2.06
(0.671)***
-1.73
(0.445)***
6.94
(4.48)
1.00
(0.400)**
0.278
(0.104)***
-0.00702
(0.00295)**
-0.219
(0.216)
0.0828
(0.655)
2.38
(0.471)***
0.321
(0.104)***
-1.84
(0.371)***
2.76
(2.12)
-2.32
(0.804)***
1.93
(0.664)***
-1.82
(0.457)***
6.43
(4.48)
1.10
(0.417)***
372
0.392
372
0.391
372
0.393
372
0.389
Gross ODA/XR GDP squared
Log repayments/XR GDP
Log initial GDP per capita
East Asia
Institutional quality
Tropics
Log initial life expectancy
Civil war
Lagged civil war
Inflation
Budget balance
Openness Sachs-Warner
Observations
R -squared
Switch to
gross and
repayments
Links to Burnside and Dollar 3
Switch to
Short/XR
GDP
Short-impact ODA/XR GDP
Short-impact ODA/XR GDP squared
0.684
(0.228)***
-0.0408
(0.0130)***
Short-impact ODA/PPP GDP
Log repayments/PPP GDP
Log initial GDP per capita
East Asia
Institutional quality
Tropics
Log initial life expectancy
Civil war
Lagged civil war
Inflation
Budget balance
Openness Sachs-Warner
Observations
R -squared
Remove
influential
obs. Core
0.960
(0.328)***
-0.0588
(0.0264)**
0.822
(0.379)**
-0.100
(0.0370)***
-0.366
(0.243)
Short-impact ODA/PPP GDP squared
Log repayments/XR GDP
Switch to
Short/PPP
GDP
-0.204
(0.224)
0.217
(0.625)
2.35
(0.465)***
0.315
(0.105)***
-1.86
(0.378)***
2.24
(2.14)
-2.39
(0.814)***
2.03
(0.679)***
-1.71
(0.453)***
6.42
(4.66)
1.17
(0.430)***
-0.220
(0.620)
2.07
(0.455)***
0.326
(0.107)***
-1.78
(0.382)***
2.14
(2.13)
-2.30
(0.810)***
1.71
(0.667)**
-2.05
(0.436)***
4.07
(4.80)
1.37
(0.439)***
-0.384
(0.188)**
-0.0593
(0.493)
2.39
(0.648)***
0.333
(0.114)***
-2.13
(0.398)***
3.49
(1.85)*
-2.19
(0.891)**
1.86
(0.730)**
-1.60
(0.558)***
8.28
(5.47)
1.41
(0.456)***
372
0.375
372
0.379
368
0.388
Rajan and Subramanian:
No independent variable in R&S is
consistently associated with growth
(not just aid)
R&S mostly impose
linearity
71 regression results; 65 test
linear relationship. No surprise
these results are weak.
 6 non-linear, all positive
coefficients (some but not all
statistically significant)
 Only one nonlinear with a
disaggregated aid variable.
Positive and significant,
supporting the basic idea of
“Chickens.”

Variable
1970-2000
Aid/GDP
1980-2000
1990-2000
–0.83
(–0.21)
1.31
(0.24)
–13.51
(–0.91)
–1.47
(–5.02)
0.04
(2.06)
3.35
(1.61)
0.41
(2.80)
–0.02
(–1.10)
–1.36
(–2.99)
0.03
(2.69)
–0.03
(–2.43)
2.22
(4.38)
–1.32
(–2.39)
0.82
(2.19)
6.49
(2.59)
–1.29
(–3.17)
0.06
(1.57)
2.41
(0.85)
0.6
(3.43)
–0.05
(–2.51)
–0.34
(–0.60)
0.01
(0.64)
–0.01
(–0.58)
2.34
(3.39)
–1.37
(–1.84)
0.66
(1.13)
6.7
(1.93)
–1.14
(–1.66)
–0.01
(–0.07)
5.28
(1.36)
0.31
(0.96)
–0.03
(–1.07)
–1.77
(–2.42)
–0.04
(–1.08)
–0.12
(–2.16)
0.76
(1.42)
–1.45
(–1.03)
0.93
(1.33)
14.82
(1.97)
80
81
79
Aid/GDP squared
Economic sector aid
Economic sector aid squared
Repayments on aid
Initial per cap. GDP
Initial life expectacy
Institutional quality
Geography
Initial government consumption
Revolutions
Terms of Trade growth
Std. dev. of TOT growth
Initial level of policy (SW)
Sub Saharan Africa
East Asia
Constant
Obs.
Reproduces R&S Table 4A, columns 3-5
Variable
Aid/GDP
Aid/GDP squared
1970-2000
1980-2000
1990-2000
25.65
(1.30)
–95.53
(–1.37)
6.77
(0.26)
–22.75
(–0.25)
140.41
(1.13)
–786.29
(–1.24)
–1.34
(–4.04)
0.07
(2.45)
2.96
(1.49)
0.57
(3.18)
–0.03
(–1.49)
–1.33
(–2.46)
0.04
(2.75)
–0.03
(–2.10)
2.63
(4.04)
–1.58
(–2.52)
1.04
(2.58)
2.53
(0.65)
–1.27
(–2.78)
0.07
(1.82)
2.46
(0.85)
0.63
(3.22)
–0.05
(–2.02)
–0.30
(–0.51)
0.01
(0.64)
–0.01
(–0.59)
2.38
(3.29)
–1.41
(–1.67)
0.68
(1.15)
5.89
(1.09)
–0.09
(–0.08)
0.03
(0.27)
8.21
(1.19)
0.76
(1.46)
–0.06
(–1.11)
–0.58
(–0.56)
–0.02
(–0.31)
–0.02
(–0.18)
0.40
(0.53)
–2.38
(–1.11)
1.30
(1.23)
–2.20
(–0.13)
80
81
79
Economic sector aid
Economic sector aid squared
Repayments on aid
Initial per cap. GDP
Initial life expectacy
Institutional quality
Geography
Initial government consumption
Revolutions
Terms of Trade growth
Std. dev. of TOT growth
Initial level of policy (SW)
Sub Saharan Africa
East Asia
Constant
Obs.
Variable
1970-2000
1980-2000
1990-2000
Aid/GDP
Aid/GDP squared
Economic sector aid
Economic sector aid squared
Repayments on aid
Initial per cap. GDP
Initial life expectacy
Institutional quality
Geography
Initial government consumption
Revolutions
Terms of Trade growth
Std. dev. of TOT growth
Initial level of policy (SW)
Sub Saharan Africa
East Asia
Constant
Obs.
313.42
(2.23)
–11158.27
(–2.52)
–35.79
(–1.12)
–1.46
(–4.53)
0.06
(2.39)
4.36
(1.90)
0.57
(3.12)
–0.03
(–1.42)
–1.43
(–2.34)
0.04
(3.33)
–0.03
(–1.96)
2.34
(4.46)
–1.61
(–2.40)
0.69
(1.88)
3.76
(1.20)
511.74
(2.20)
–21612.64
(–1.91)
8.96
(0.27)
–1.36
(–2.93)
0.09
(2.22)
4.92
(1.64)
0.88
(3.89)
–0.07
(–3.12)
0.30
(0.36)
0.04
(1.36)
–0.02
(–0.60)
2.24
(3.10)
–1.81
(–2.14)
0.54
(0.76)
0.71
(0.17)
834.12
(1.76)
–24310.55
(–0.59)
–25.13
(–0.44)
0.24
(0.14)
0.05
(0.51)
4.88
(0.78)
0.67
(1.38)
–0.08
(–2.84)
–1.13
(–1.75)
–0.01
(–0.17)
–0.10
(–1.90)
0.13
(0.20)
–2.28
(–1.45)
0.61
(0.63)
–3.46
(–0.27)
80
81
79
Variable
Aid/GDP
GMM
GMM
–0.23
(–0.12)
Economic sector aid
70.30
(1.90)
–144.28
(–0.59)
Economic sector aid squared
Repayments on aid
Initial level of policy (SW)
Log inflation
Institutional quality
Geography
Initial per cap. GDP
Revolutions
Initial government consumption
Sub Saharan Africa
East Asia
Constant
Obs.
First column reproduces R&S Table 9, col. 1.
Second column reproduces R&S Table 10, column 1.
0.56
(1.11)
–1.74
(–5.48)
7.15
(1.98)
0.41
(1.62)
–0.58
(–0.97)
–1.18
(–1.46)
–0.04
(–1.51)
–1.18
(–1.34)
2.06
(2.36)
3.74
(0.84)
0.56
(1.08)
–1.60
(–4.85)
3.97
(0.97)
0.68
(2.18)
–0.55
(–0.79)
–1.17
(–1.56)
–0.08
(–2.31)
–2.26
(–2.18)
1.84
(1.52)
7.02
(1.25)
539
423
Variable
Aid/GDP
GMM
GMM
–0.23
(–0.12)
Economic sector aid
70.30
(1.90)
–144.28
(–0.59)
0.56
(1.11)
–1.74
(–5.48)
7.15
(1.98)
0.41
(1.62)
–0.58
(–0.97)
–1.18
(–1.46)
–0.04
(–1.51)
–1.18
(–1.34)
2.06
(2.36)
3.74
(0.84)
0.56
(1.08)
–1.60
(–4.85)
3.97
(0.97)
0.68
(2.18)
–0.55
(–0.79)
–1.17
(–1.56)
–0.08
(–2.31)
–2.26
(–2.18)
1.84
(1.52)
7.02
(1.25)
82.12
(2.12)
–229.05
(–0.87)
–4.4E+07
(–1.88)
0.83
(1.45)
–1.51
(–4.35)
3.90
(0.88)
0.73
(2.51)
–1.19
(–1.48)
–1.42
(–1.89)
–0.09
(–2.78)
–2.97
(–2.21)
1.18
(1.11)
12.68
(1.98)
539
423
406
Economic sector aid squared
Repayments on aid
Initial level of policy (SW)
Log inflation
Institutional quality
Geography
Initial per cap. GDP
Revolutions
Initial government consumption
Sub Saharan Africa
East Asia
Constant
GMM
Obs.
First column reproduces R&S Table 9, col. 1.
Second column reproduces R&S Table 10, column 1.
Related documents