Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
The politics of pension reform in western Europe Giuliano Bonoli Two worlds of pension policy in Europe • Social insurance systems (France, Germany, Italy, Sweden) • Multipillar systems (Denmark, Switzeralnd, Netherlands, UK) | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 2 | Social insurance systems • Generous public pensions (ca. 70% of earings) • Contributory, earnings related benefits • Occupational fragmentation • PAYG (pay-as-you-go) financing | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 3 | Multipillar systems • Basic pension at subsistence level (20-40% of average earnings) • Provision is insufficient for the middle classes • Development of a second pillar • In the 1960s-1970s, extension of second pillar coverage | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 4 | Public pension expenditure as a percent of GDP (1996) and financial assets of pension funds (1998 or most recent), selected OECD countries. Expenditure on public Financial assets of pensions, % GDP pension funds, % GDP France Germany Italy Sweden Average Social insurance countries 10.36 10.29 10.99 8.27 9.97 na 3.3 3.2 2.7 3.1 Multipillar countries Denmark 7.73 21.5 Netherlands 6.75 85.6 Switzerland 6.71 74.9 United Kingdom 6.46 83.7 Average 6.91 66.4 Source: OECD SOCX (CD-ROM); OECD, Institutional Investors Statistical Yearbook, 2000, Table S.8. | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 5 | Different problems… Social insurance systems Systèmes à plusieurs piliers • Long term financing • Include atypical employment • Regulate private pensions | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 6 | Public pension expenditure projections (percent of GDP) France Germany* Italy Sweden Average Social insurance countries 2000 2010 2030 2050 9.8 11.5 12.6 11.1 11.2 13.5 16.5 20.3 15.0 16.3 14.3 17.5 21.4 14.5 16.9 9.7 11.8 13.2 12.4 11.8 Multipillar countries Denmark 6.4 7.6 10.9 11.5 Netherlands 5.7 6.1 11.2 11.4 Switzerland 7.1 8.4 11.7 Na United Kingdom 4.5 5.2 5.5 4.1 Average 5.9 6.8 9.8 9.0 Source: Roseveare et al. 1996, Table 3, pp 17-18 (baseline scenario), for Switzerland: own calculations. * Note: For Germany, the effects of the 2001 reform are not included. | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 7 | Reform in social insurance pension systems • Path dependency • Strong entrenched interests • High mobilisation capacity of the defenders of the status quo | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 8 | What will social insurance pension systems in 2030-2040 look like? • Germany: replacement rate of social insurance pensions = 46% • Italy: replacement rate for new pensioners: 49% • At the same time, funded provision is expected to expand substantially How was it possible? | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 9 | Delay • Delay: many of the reform successfully enacted were characterized by long phasing in periods • Long phasing in period means that many of those who are entitled to vote, will not be affected by the reform • Delay can be seen as a divisive strategy | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 10 | Year of reform, full implementation date and time lag in France, Germany and Italy Year of reform Full implementation Time lag France 1993 2004 11 France 2003 2020 17 Germany 1989 2012 23 Germany 1999 2025 ca. 26 ca. Germany 2006 2029 24 Italy 1992 2032 40 Italy 1995 2035 40 | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 11 | Proportion of the voting age population affected by reform, depending on phasing in period, 2001 Length of phasing in/country France Germany Italy 10 years 58% 74% 55% 20 years 40% 47% 38% 30 years 21% 27% 19% 40 years 4% 10% 3% | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 12 | Sequencing • Stage 1: Adjustment through contribution increases or government transfers (which contribute to government deficits) • Stage 2 : Moderate retrenchment. Concern for the long term financing of pension pushes the middle classes towards private alternatives • Stage 3: More radical retrenchment • Stage 4: Development of generalised second pillar provision | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 13 | Pension optimists among working age individuals (percentage answering the items underlined) Year (survey) Question France Germany (west) Italy 1992 (EB37.1) Do you think that the pensions you will receive when you retire will be… Completely adequate/Just about adequate/Somewhat inadequate/Very inadequate 44.5 70.6 52.7 1999 (EB 51.1) In the future there will be more elderly than there are now. Do you think that people will get less pension for their contributions? Yes/No/Don’t know 11.5 24.4 24.9 2001 (EB 56.1) Do you think that the state pension you will receive when you retire will allow you to get by…With great difficulty/with difficulty/easily/very easily 24.4 23.3 13.8 | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 14 | Financial liabilities of life insurance companies, in million EUR (assets for Financial liabilities of life insurance companies (assets for D and CH) D and CH) 1200000 1000000 800000 France Germany Italy Netherlands Switzerland 600000 400000 200000 0 1992 1993 1994 1995 | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 | Diapositive 15 | Conclusion • Slow convergence towards the multipillar model • Multipillar may become the new norm, but be adopted with some degree of national variation • Sequencing: shifting opportunity structures – never say never | ©IDHEAP – [email protected] | | Diapositive 16 |