Download Uncertainty Avoidance As Determined By Relations

Survey
yes no Was this document useful for you?
   Thank you for your participation!

* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project

Document related concepts
no text concepts found
Transcript
 Berget, Egan & Hughes Uncertainty Avoidance As Determined By Relations
Between Government And Society:
A Cross-Cultural Study Conducted In Egypt, India,
Hong Kong, And South Korea
Christina Berget, Elise Bundl Egan, and Claire Hughes
Psychology 257: Understanding Human Behavior in a Global Context
January 2012
Uncertainty Avoidance 1 Berget, Egan & Hughes ABSTRACT
In a globalizing world, it is important to have an understanding of cultural differences across
the globe. A dimension present in many world cultures is Uncertainty Avoidance, which this
paper defines as the number and quality of tools a country has in place to assure a smoothrunning society. Previous studies link Uncertainty Avoidance to economic prosperity. This
study measured Uncertainty Avoidance levels across Egypt, India, Hong Kong, and South
Korea through quantitative and qualitative use of Garbage Containers, Police Officers, and
Restrictive Signs. In the end, while we confirm the previously asserted connection between
economic prosperity and Uncertainty Avoidance, we further conclude that high levels of
Uncertainty Avoidance are dependent upon shared goals between government and society. In
Hong Kong and South Korea, this cooperation succeeds, indicating a high level of
Uncertainty Avoidance, while Egyptians and Indians continue to struggle with this
relationship, giving them a low Uncertainty Avoidance score.
Uncertainty Avoidance 2 Berget, Egan & Hughes Uncertainty Avoidance As Determined By Relations
Between Government And Society:
A Cross-Cultural Study Conducted In Egypt, India, Hong Kong, And
South Korea
Within the past 50 years, cross-cultural research has exploded in the psychology
world. Psychologists are now beginning to ask many questions concerning the differences
between one society and another. Are these differences due to biological forces? Or does
one’s culture define the ways in which one value’s organization, gender dominance, and
other controversial dimensions in their society?
One such study that explored cross-cultural differences is the GLOBE study, edited
by House et al.. In this study, 62 countries were examined across nine different dimensions
using a variety of methods. This paper focuses on the “Uncertainty Avoidance” dimension.
Uncertainty Avoidance, as defined by House et al., is “the extent to which life is structured,
predictable, orderly, and consistent, and the rules and regulations to regulate social practices
are emphasized” (619). As our world’s population continues to grow, Uncertainty Avoidance
will play a larger role in each of the world’s citizen’s lives. The degree to which our societies
are organized, dependable, and reliable will remain an important issue in years to come. For
as our populations continue to grow, so will our daily interactions with other cultures.
Therefore, it is our responsibility to give attention not only to Uncertainty Avoidance in our
own society, but in the societies of the world.
Additionally, House et al. created a list of nine bullet points clearly describing
Uncertainty Avoidance. Because it would be difficult to measure all nine points in a given
society, we instead chose to focus on three concepts we believed best encompass Uncertainty
Avoidance. We chose to emphasize the idea that countries high in Uncertainty Avoidance
would “show stronger resistance to change,” “show stronger desire to establish rules allowing
Uncertainty Avoidance 3 Berget, Egan & Hughes predictability of behavior,” and “show less tolerance for breaking rules” (618).
Before hypothesizing the degree to which Uncertainty Avoidance is displayed in a
given society, we conducted research concerning the correlation between Uncertainty
Avoidance and various societal factors. First and foremost, in a study conducted by Fred A.
Infortunio, it was found that there is a negative correlation between fatal accidents and high
Uncertainty Avoidance (2006). This indicates that in countries with high Uncertainty
Avoidance, more dependable infrastructure exists (eg. predictable streets, traffic signals, etc).
Additionally, House et. al. found that when governments intervene with the economy, high
Uncertainty Avoidance values are observed (630).
However, a great deal of the research conducted by both the GLOBE study
researchers and other academic journals more often links the economic stability of a given
country with Uncertainty Avoidance. Indeed, House et. al. state, “the higher the level of
Uncertainty Avoidance practices in a society, the more its economic prosperity” (630).
Additionally, a study conducted by Wennekers et. al., found a positive correlation between
the presence of business ownership and Uncertainty Avoidance (2007). Since measuring the
stability of an entire economy is difficult, we instead focused our hypothesis on the relation
between a country’s GDP per capita, its social implications, and Uncertainty Avoidance.
In short, we hypothesized that the higher the GDP per capita of a given country, the
greater the Uncertainty Avoidance principles will be visible within said country. Since we
were unable to conduct surveys as GLOBE researchers did, our data is entirely based on
observed Uncertainty Avoidance practices (both qualitative and quantitative). In our study,
we focused on four diverse countries: Egypt, India, Hong Kong1, and South Korea.
In each of the four countries there are cultural and historical factors that could be
possible influences on Uncertainty Avoidance. Most recently, Egypt has undergone a
1
For the sake of continuity, we've referred to Hong Kong as it’s own country as opposed to
“The Special Administrative Region of The People’s Republic of China.”
Uncertainty Avoidance 4 Berget, Egan & Hughes revolution, one that has no doubt left the society with a certain level of unavoidable
uncertainty. In the not so recent past, India has been dominated by those loyal to the Hindu
religion, which, as an individualistic faith system, emphasizes orderliness, hierarchy, and
personal accountability, often at the expense of the society at large. Hong Kong’s business
world, although largely westernized, continues to be influenced by traditional Confucian
roots and the Chinese concept of “face”. Lastly, South Korea, while traumatized by the
Japanese colonial period (1910-1945) and liberated by its own grassroots democracy
movement in the 1980s, has undertaken rapid modernization and economic prosperity. Thus,
each of the four countries is highly diverse in history, economic stability, and societal
organization.
In order to test observable Uncertainty Avoidance practices, we chose to focus on
counting Garbage Containers, Police Officers, and Restrictive Signs in each of the four
countries. We believed that these three factors were visible representations of the degree to
which a country’s citizens and government work to avoid uncertainty. Therefore, we
hypothesized that the prevalence of these components would represent the observed
Uncertainty Avoidance.
In countries of higher GDP per capita such as Hong Kong (2010 GDP per capita:
$45,900) and South Korea (2010 GDP per capita: $30,000), we expected large quantitative
numbers, indicating a high degree of Uncertainty Avoidance (CIA World Factbook, 2011).
Therefore, we believed there would be moderate to high amounts of Garbage Containers,
Police Officers, and Restrictive Signs found in these societies. Conversely, in countries of
lower GDP per capita such as Egypt (2010 GDP per capita: $6,200) and India (2010 GDP per
capita: $3,500,) we anticipated lower observable Uncertainty Avoidance practices (CIA
World Factbook, 2011). Thus, we believed that in both Egypt and India low amounts of
Garbage Containers, Police Officers, and Restrictive Signs would be observed.
Uncertainty Avoidance 5 Berget, Egan & Hughes METHODS
To measure the presence of Uncertainty Avoidance in a culture, we looked at three
different components we believed emphasize maintaining order: Police Officers, Garbage
Containers, and Restrictive Signs. Deliberately placed components (such as those listed
above) demonstrated a crucial practice in the elimination of uncertainty. An equally
important aspect of this study was the observation of a society’s adherence to these measures.
The respect given to these precautions demonstrated a culture’s own values and efforts
towards avoiding uncertainty.
The Variables:
Police Officers: To measure the number of personnel involved in avoiding
uncertainty, we counted the number of people intentionally placed in an area to maintain
order (eg. Police Officers, security guards, traffic attendants, and transport vehicles). Their
level of activity and approachability was also noted in the qualitative aspect of our research.
These people indicated the society’s emphasis on obeying laws, offering guidance, and
maintaining an authoritative presence in a busy area.
Garbage Containers: The number of both “official” and “unofficial” garbage
collection receptacles were counted each walk. Official garbage containers included
permanent trash and/or recycling containers built into a city’s infrastructure. These
containers were meant to collect waste, which would then be disposed of by an official
garbage collection service. The presence of these containers demonstrated a society’s
government’s emphasis on providing facilities where they are in need, while also increasing
the emphasis on cleanliness. Additionally, “unofficial” garbage containers (eg. garbage
contained in a plastic bag arranged intentionally on the street) were counted. These sites
demonstrated a society’s own desire for order and organization when “official” Garbage
Containers were lacking.
Uncertainty Avoidance 6 Berget, Egan & Hughes Restrictive Signs: Finally, signs and other stationary enforcement indicators were
counted and studied. Most frequently, these included traffic signs, pedestrian signs,
temporary and/or permanent blockades, and street paint. The frequency of these indicators
demonstrated the importance of instruction within a society. The more observable signs there
were, the more reminders citizens had of the laws in place. An equally important aspect of
this observation was the civilians’ adherence and respect towards the signs. This was the real
indicator of how successful these enforcement reminders were in each country studied.
The Study:
In each country we found a populated area that included both pedestrian and vehicle
traffic. It was important to find an area that had consistent traffic flow and a busy civilian
population in order to yield an Uncertainty Avoidance reading that served as a representation
of the society. We also emphasized more urban areas because we believed it would offer
higher data numbers and a wider spectrum of qualitative observations. We walked the
chosen route three times in each country (to ensure consistent data), incorporating at least
two-week days and one day of the weekend to account for varying busyness and activity.
The walk was performed at a typical, easy walking pace and was timed to thirty minutes.
The walks were performed in the mid-to-late afternoon to ensure busy activity. For all three
days, one researcher counted the number of Police Officers and observed their authority.
Additionally, another researcher counted the number of Garbage Containers while the final
researcher, in both Egypt and India, counted the number of Restrictive Signs all three days.
However, in Hong Kong and South Korea, she performed quantitative data collection for the
first two days, reserving the third day to collect more detailed qualitative data.
The Locations:
Egypt: In Egypt we chose Tahrir Square for our walking location. It represented a
heavily populated area with shops, a subway station, and both vehicle and pedestrian traffic.
Uncertainty Avoidance 7 Berget, Egan & Hughes Due to the unrest in the country at the time, we placed a large emphasis on the adherence to
and respect towards the police force and regulation signs. As this area was famous for
protests, violence, and unrest, we believed it was important to monitor whether it was the
government or civilians that facilitated the organization of Tahrir Square.
India: We chose the area of Whitefield for this observation because it was a more
urban location than the surrounding rural areas. The vehicle traffic was consistently heavy
and the pedestrian traffic was bustling because of the many storefronts. For this route, we
walked down one side of the street, counting only the data visible from that side and then
walked back up the other side to complete remaining observations.
Hong Kong: The area of Hung Hom was chosen for this observation. Located near a
busy subway station, this area represented Hong Kong’s busy urban lifestyle including
multiple restaurants, corporate buildings, shops, and vehicle intersections. Because of the
impressive subway system, many of the areas in Hong Kong did not have both pedestrian and
vehicle traffic, thus, Hung Hom was selected because it represented both dimensions.
South Korea: The Sinchon area was chosen for our observations in South Korea. The
vehicle traffic was very heavy, and the large presence of coffee shops and restaurants in the
area encouraged a large flow of pedestrians. Sinchon also has a busy subway stop in the area,
which dramatically increased human traffic.
Please see Appendix for maps of the chosen walking routes.
RESULTS
Quantitative Data
Over twelve total days of observation in Egypt, India, Hong Kong, and South Korea,
we collected raw data on each of our three determinants of Uncertainty Avoidance: number
of Garbage Containers, Police Officers, and Restrictive Signs (see Table 1 and Graph 1
below). The numbers of Garbage Containers were highest in Hong Kong (61.67, sd= 1.53)
Uncertainty Avoidance 8 Berget, Egan & Hughes and South Korea (66.67, sd= 16.04), while India exhibited the lowest numbers (5.33, sd=
0.58). Police Officers were most prevalent in Egypt (27.33, sd= 8.14), while almost equally
low numbers of officers were observed in India (4, sd= 1.73), Hong Kong (6.33, sd= 1.53),
and South Korea (7, sd= 1). Restrictive Signs and barriers dramatically increased from Egypt
(31.33, sd= 0.58) to India (72.33, sd= 7.02) to Hong Kong (106.5, sd= 12.02), and then
showed a slight decrease in number in South Korea (104, sd= 1.41).
Table 1
Egypt
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Avg.
sd
India
Trash Cans
40
47
32
39.6666667
7.505553499
Police Officers
31
18
33
27.33333333
8.144527815
Restrictive Signs
31
32
31
31.33333333
0.577350269
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Avg.
sd
H. K.
Day 1
Day 2
5
6
5
5.33333333
0.577350269
5
2
5
4
1.732050808
65
79
73
72.33333333
7.023769169
63
62
8
5
115
98
Day 3
Avg.
sd
S. K.
Day 1
Day 2
60
61.6666667
1.527525232
6
6.333333333
1.527525232
106.5
12.02081528
50
82
8
7
105
103
Day 3
Avg.
sd
68
66.6666667
16.04161255
6
7
1
104
1.414213562
UA Index
Extras
1 police van
4 police vans
32.77777778
6.292264504
recycling ctr, 2 speed
bumps, 5 security
2 security
garbage truck, 5 security
27.22222222
39.07305598
8 + empty police van
use lanes, follow signs to
fault - run over peds.
58.16666667
50.17497163
5 parking, 3 police
5 traffic, 2 cars w/ lights
3 traffic, 1 police, 2 cars w/
lights, j walking, int. sitters,
1 red light run
59.22222222
48.92662685
For ease in observing the data’s general trends, we created an Uncertainty Avoidance
Index value for each country. The “UA Index” number is simply the mean average of the
data for each of the three observational measures – Garbage Containers, Police Officers, and
Restrictive Signs. Since the Index numbers all have high standard deviations, this data set
will not be a main focus for our quantitative analysis. Nevertheless, the Index remains a good
general guide to our data as a whole, despite not being of real statistical significance.
As
shown in Graph 1, the data indicate a general upward trend and a definite difference in
Uncertainty Avoidance 9 Berget, Egan & Hughes observable facets of Uncertainty Avoidance across the four countries studied. The collected
data is statistically significant as determined by the Analysis of Variance—or ANOVA—test,
which shows a statistically significant lower number of Garbage Containers in India
(F11=29.56, p=0.0001), statistically significant higher count of Police Officers in Egypt (F11=
19.46, p= 0.0005), and statistically significant lower amounts of Restrictive Signs in Egypt
and India (F9=76.28, p< 0.0001).
Graph 1
120 100 80 Garbage Cans 60 Police OfMicers Restrictive Signs 40 UA Index 20 0 Egypt India Hong Kong South Korea As explained in the introduction, the GLOBE study on which our study was based concluded
that economic prosperity was the best determinant of a country’s level of Uncertainty Avoidance.
We then chose to use a country’s GDP per capita as a means of determining their economic
prosperity and inadvertently, socioeconomic status. However, since Uncertainty Avoidance
cannot be explained wholly by a country’s GDP per capita, we also looked to the following data
connected with socioeconomic status: average age, the age structure of the national populations,
and average life expectancy. Socioeconomic status has been proven to have greater social
implications, namely related to health and the quality of life of individuals in a given society
(Heine). To test these hypotheses against our data, we collected data from the CIA World
Factbook 2011 on each of the four countries’ GDP per capita, statistical median age of the
populations, percentage of the population between 0 and 14 years, and life expectancy (see Table
Uncertainty Avoidance 10 Berget, Egan & Hughes 2).
Table 2
GDP per capita
Med. Age
0-14 yrs
Life Expectancy
Egypt
$6,200.00
24.3
32.7%
72.66
India
$3,500.00
26.2
29.7%
66.80
Hong Kong
$45,900.00
43.4
11.6%
82.04
South Korea
$30,000.00
38.4
15.7%
79.05
When the correlation tests were applied, the most consistently significant coefficients are with
the Uncertainty Avoidance Index (see Table 3 below). Although these figures correspond well
with our hypotheses, there is such a wide standard deviation between the data points that these
results cannot be used to draw a statistically relevant nor reliable conclusion.
Table 3
GDP
Median Age
Garbage Cans
0.82
0.78
Police Officers
-0.41
-0.54
Restrictive Signs 0.81
0.90*
UA Index
0.94*
0.95**
*critical value p<0.1; **critical value p<0.05
% 0-14 yrs.
-0.77
0.58
(-0.92*)
(-0.95**)
Life Expectancy
0.96**
(-0.14)
0.64
0.95**
Restrictive Signs significantly correlate with GDP per capita (r= 0.81), Median Age (r= 0.90,
p<0.1), and national percentage of population 0-14 years (r= -0.92, p<0.1). Although Garbage
Containers correlate most significantly with Life Expectancy (r= 0.96, p<0.05), the data very
closely correlates with GDP per capita (r= 0.82), Median Age (r= 0.78), and national percentage
of population 0-14 years (r= -0.77) as well. The only measurement not found to be statistically
significant with any of the four national data categories is Police Officers.
Taking another look at our raw data on Police Officers, it is clear that the Egyptian data is an
obvious outlier (see Table 1 and Graph 1 above). In Egypt, we observed an average of 27.33
officers each day, whereas India, Hong Kong, and South Korea all averaged less than 10
officers per day. Recognizing this outlier data, we wanted
Table 4
Police Officers (all)
GDP
-0.41
Median Age
-0.54
% 0-14 yrs.
0.58
Life Expectancy
-0.14
Uncertainty Avoidance 11 Police Officers (excl. Egypt) 0.83
0.88
Berget, Egan & Hughes -0.91
0.92
to see how the Police Officer correlations would be affected by removing the Egypt data. Indeed,
these new correlation coefficients are much more favorable and statistically significant across all
four variables (see Table 4).
Qualitative Data
Egypt
Although Egyptian police were certainly present in large numbers, they were rarely
seen to be effective in any way other than serving as a physical reminder that there was still
some form of authority in power.
The garbage disposal system in Egypt was mostly carried out in the traditional manner, which
involved the work of people referred to literally as “garbage people”. Matters of cleanliness and
order did not seem to be of utmost importance to either the Egyptian people or the authorities.
Unfortunately, we have no way to say whether the large amounts of trash and litter outside the
(mostly unused) public Garbage Containers in Tahrir are more than “normal” levels.
Restrictive Signs in Tahrir were mainly regarding traffic laws or smoking bans in the Metro
Station. Although we never witnessed anyone smoking in the Metro Station during our
observation walks, there were several traffic law violations in Tahrir Square that did not seem to
be enforced by the many present Police Officers. ‘No Parking’ signs were blatantly ignored on the
main streets leading to Tahrir, and it was common practice throughout the country to run red lights
or stop signs without much risk of legal consequence.
India
Cleanliness in India was relative. Private spaces – stores, restaurants, houses of worship,
homes, etc. – were kept tidy and clean, while public spaces were poorly maintained and often
served as garbage dumping grounds. Garbage Containers in India were few. The only unique
offering Whitefield had was an informal “recycling center” we passed during our observations.
We never saw an official policeman during our walks in Whitefield, so we substituted in
Uncertainty Avoidance 12 Berget, Egan & Hughes private security officers who sat guard in front of well-to-do properties. During the entirety of our
stay in India, we rarely saw police.
Restrictive Signs in India were plentiful. However, the majority of those counted in our study
were privately made ‘No Parking’ signs posted on private entrances or gates. The abundance of
traffic signs did not seem to make much of a difference to the haphazard driving style of most
Indian motorists. However, speed bumps were seen to be a frequently used tool in lieu of speed
limit signs.
Hong Kong
We observed that the majority of Garbage Containers were not only more prevalent, but were
also designed to be used. They were painted a bright fluorescent orange color, were significantly
larger than their Egyptian counterparts, were emptied regularly by fluorescently-clad public
servants, and were well utilized. Moreover, it was a highly fined offense to litter (among other
deeds) in Hong Kong, and signs to that effect were posted on nearly every garbage can2.
The Hong Kong Police Officers, when present, were authoritative, approachable, and
helpful. In our total 90 minutes of observation, we saw officers walking on regular rounds,
responding to pedestrians or motorists’ queries, and directing traffic. Furthermore, over the
course of our entire time in Hong Kong, we also observed officers ticketing faulty drivers
and standing guard at posts throughout the city.
The majority of observed signs addressed the city’s laws against smoking in certain areas. On
only one occasion was one of these signs disobeyed, but the perpetrator still seemed to respect the
law, as he promptly put out his cigarette after only a few short puffs. Signs addressing driving
laws were largely respected, including lane markings and other notations painted on the pavement.
South Korea
On our walks and throughout our time in South Korea, we observed a general
reverence for rules and laws. While South Korea was not nearly as clean as Hong Kong, it
2
These signs were not included in the Restrictive Signs data.
Uncertainty Avoidance 13 Berget, Egan & Hughes did not seem to be for a lack of care – rather, trash bags (piles of them, in places) on the
sidewalks, curbs, or alleys were taken care of by the city’s garbage disposal system. The
majority of these “unofficial” Garbage Containers were removed before our 3rd day of
observation.
We noted that South Korean officers were more frequently asserting their presence by flashing
their squad car lights, directing traffic, or even ticketing faulty motorists. There seemed to be a
greater concern for traffic flow, since we observed more parking attendants than police. However,
it was difficult to tell whether this was common throughout South Korea or unique to the areas
with which we had contact.
Observed signs mostly concerned traffic or parking laws, but there were additional
signs of note, namely two which alerted viewers to the presence of police/camera
surveillance in the area, and several smaller signs indicating the direction and distance to the
nearest public toilet facility. Overall, Restrictive Signs were respected, with the exceptions of
a few red light runs, some j-walking, and many cars staying in the middle of intersections
during a red light.
DISCUSSION
Our data indicates noticeable differences in the levels of Uncertainty Avoidance
between Egypt, India, Hong Kong and South Korea. Using official CIA data on GDP per
capita, Median Age, percentage of population 0-14 years, and Life Expectancy, we were able
to quantitatively prove our general hypothesis that countries with greater economic prosperity
(and therefore, higher socioeconomic status) would have correspondingly greater levels of
Uncertainly Avoidance, as measured by frequency and effective use of Garbage Containers,
Police Officers, and Restrictive Signs. However, we also discovered that, while our
quantitative data is telling, there are other factors that should be considered as more
descriptive indicators of Uncertainty Avoidance.
Uncertainty Avoidance 14 Berget, Egan & Hughes Based on our quantitative analysis, the four countries in order from most to least
Uncertainty Avoidance are Hong Kong, South Korea, Egypt, and India. More generally, we
can put Hong Kong and South Korea in one category of high Uncertainty Avoidance, while
Egypt and India represent a group with lower Uncertainty Avoidance levels. Given the
obvious economic prosperity of both Hong Kong and South Korea and less success of Egypt
and India, it can be said that our data does indeed correspond with House et. al.’s findings
regarding economic stability. Within this categorization, we draw our conclusion based on
the impact of relationships between government and society on overall measures of
Uncertainty Avoidance.
An overall analysis of our data indicates that Hong Kong has the highest level of
Uncertainty Avoidance. This is of no surprise because of the impressive success of the
government and society’s mutual goal of economic growth and prosperity. The country’s
rapid acceleration towards becoming a major business capital of the world has encouraged
the society to work closely with the government, thus instilling a strong emphasis on law
adherence and respect. Because of its economic status, rapid growth and industrialization,
Hong Kong needs a strong force of stability and orderliness, which is willingly delivered by
the government.
Our data indicates that Hong Kong has the highest number of Restrictive Signs and a
high number of Garbage Containers. The immaculate cleanliness of the Hung Hom area
indicates the society’s strong adherence towards these measures. Additionally, Hong Kong
was also the only country to have clearly-marked city workers consistently cleaning and
enforcing the laws of the area, further indicating their focus on orderliness in the society. The
strict adherence to the Restrictive Signs emphasizes the people’s own self-governance
towards the regulations set by the government. It was easy for citizens to follow the signs as
they were large, bright, and very clear. Finally, the small but effective police force
Uncertainty Avoidance 15 Berget, Egan & Hughes demonstrates the government’s trust in the society to follow the regulations without constant
supervision. Because there is a strong mutual trust between the two, there is less need to
present a harsh authoritative force.
South Korea is also highly ranked for its Uncertainty Avoidance. Like Hong Kong,
the government and the society are unified and assume mutual respect because of their shared
goals for prosperity and gaining international prestige. As opposed to Hong Kong, South
Korea is still in its ‘instructional phase.’ The government understands its role in ensuring the
reduction of uncertainty through regulations, and the society respectfully recognizes this
authority.
South Korea’s high number of Restrictive Signs indicates the government’s goal of
educating and reminding its people of proper rules and regulations that will help the country
function. Signs serve as gentle reminders from the government to follow regulations, while
also demonstrating the government’s goal of societal self-governance. Cars blocking
intersections and frequent j-walking are incidents that demonstrate inconsistent responses to
the governmental regulations; the society seems to not yet have an overall cohesive priority
of adhering to every governmental regulation.
South Korea also boasts the highest number of Garbage Containers of the four
countries. While the South Korean government may not have implemented official public
garbage cans, the removal of unofficial containers demonstrates a joint effort between society
and government to maintain orderliness. South Korea also has the highest number of people
fitting under the Police Officer category outside of Egypt. The consistent presence of traffic
attendants during the study demonstrates the government’s emphasis on consistency and
order, which undoubtedly offers its citizens more certainty. The presence of active police
squad cars reinforces the authorities’ dedication to maintaining order.
South Korea has had less time to develop their trusting relationship and mutual goals
Uncertainty Avoidance 16 Berget, Egan & Hughes between its government and people, so the greater emphasis on reminding its people of
enforcement policies is understandable; the country is clearly increasing their level of
Uncertainty Avoidance through the cohesive efforts of both parties.
Our observations in Egypt portray the tattered relationship between the government
and its society both before and after the January 25th Revolution. Pre-revolution, the
Egyptian government, plagued with corruption and greed, placed little emphasis on
decreasing the uncertainty in its society. As a result, the Egyptian people were inspired to
revolt. Our data reflects the opposing goals of the government and the society, as the
government is attempting to gain more authority through its police force, while the society
continues to rebel against the few regulations that are in place.
The lack of Restrictive Signs and Garbage Containers emphasizes the government’s
dismissal of the society, as their corrupt pre-revolution goals left little time to focus on
decreasing the society’s uncertainty. Additionally, the society’s dismissal of these minimal
government regulations is also evident in our data through the large presence of litter on the
streets and consistent overlooking of Restrictive Signs.
The large presence of Police Officers demonstrates the government’s attempt to gain
control of its society. However, this force has no power in the eyes of the Egyptian society,
whose goal is to disregard the government’s actions. The officers’ inactivity (as indicated in
our data) is a clear reflection of the severed relationship between the government and the
people, as, in reality, neither party truly cares about the certainty and stability of the other.
The tumultuous relationship between the government and its people began before the
revolution, yet both parties have continued to polarize themselves during this chaotic period.
Thus, the lack of continuity between the parties results in a very uncertain and unstable
society.
The Indian government’s sense of apathy towards forward progress has created a
Uncertainty Avoidance 17 Berget, Egan & Hughes strong disconnect within the society. Thus, a majority of Indian people have instead turned to
Hinduism, another authoritative presence, to act as a guiding force in their lives. While
Hinduism may not be the sole religion of India, it is often described as the Indian way of life
and much of the society is influenced by its beliefs, as evident in the growing loyalty to
Hindutwa philosophies. This ideology emphasizes social hierarchy and the completion of
one’s personal dharma at the expense of collectivistic responsibility.
Our data indicates India’s government does not work to avoid uncertainty in the
“public spaces” of society (eg. roads). The Restrictive Signs aimed at traffic control were
largely ignored, resulting in a haphazard driving scenario and demonstrating a clear disregard
of the government’s wishes. The lack of both “official” and “unofficial” Garbage Containers
represents both the government’s inability to control public waste and the society’s general
apathy towards said waste. Finally, the lack of an authoritative police presence (as indicated
by the sole existence of private security guards) indicates the government’s disregard for
public safety and organization. In short, India’s government is not taking care of “public
spaces,” which is effectively slowing the society’s progression towards cohesive organization
and goals. As a result, the Indian society retreats into their “private spaces” to achieve their
own goals and organization.
Indians take their own initiative towards improving both organization and stability in
their lives, as demonstrated by the makeshift recycling center in Whitefield (the center was
by no means supported by the government). Additionally, the high number of ‘No Parking’
signs on private doors appeared homemade, which indicates the Indian society’s initiative to
increase certainty and protect their own private space. Private space, encouraged by
Hinduism, is therefore a means of providing stability and organization for India’s people.
Thus, the Uncertainty Avoidance of the “private space” (although not measureable in this
study) may in fact be quite higher than was observed in the “public space”. Nevertheless, a
Uncertainty Avoidance 18 Berget, Egan & Hughes great disconnect between the government and its people remains in the public spaces of India,
as exemplified by this study’s low Uncertainty Avoidance observations.
Based on this analysis of our quantitative and qualitative data, it becomes clear that
high levels of Uncertainty Avoidance in a country go hand in hand with mutual goals
between the government and its people. In the cases of Hong Kong and South Korea, these
cooperative goals revolve around economic prosperity and global reputation, resulting in two
countries high in Uncertainty Avoidance. Meanwhile, the current state of the relationships
between government and society in Egypt and India are still fraught with power struggles and
disagreements between factions that continue to impede joint progress towards cohesive
national goals, resulting in low levels of Uncertainty Avoidance for both countries. In
conclusion, the quality of the relationship between society and government dictates both the
numbers of regulations present in a society (our three variables) and the adherence and
respect towards these measures in practice; or, put simply, Uncertainty Avoidance.
Limitations and Suggestions for Further Research
Had we had more time and resources, we would have liked to investigate Uncertainty
Avoidance in more countries, rural settings, and other areas of the chosen countries. Our
study was also limited in that we were only able to complete observations and would have
preferred to also conduct surveys. Although we believed that the variables chosen (Garbage
Containers, Police Officers, Restrictive Signs) were strong representations of Uncertainty
Avoidance, there is no telling how the members of the observed societies feel. While
Uncertainty Avoidance positively influences the countries we’ve studied, it is worth noting
that this may not always be the case. As shown in the GLOBE study, countries with high
degrees of Uncertainty Avoidance sometimes wish to have less organization within their
respective society. This is indicated by the discrepancy found between the ‘practices’ and
‘values’ Uncertainty Avoidance scores (622-623). Including surveys in our study would have
Uncertainty Avoidance 19 Berget, Egan & Hughes added this invaluable societal ‘values’ dimension to our ‘practices’ focused study.
More specifically, the number of police found in Egypt hindered the study. It was not
until we removed the Egypt Police Officers data that the remaining three countries’ (India,
Hong Kong, South Korea) Police Officers data was statistically significant. We would have
preferred to investigate a different variable through the study had we foreseen these
problems. Additionally, the location chosen in India (Whitefield) was not nearly as
metropolitan as the areas chosen in the other countries and may have affected the data. In
both South Korea and Hong Kong, the study was also hindered by the third day of qualitative
observations completed in lieu of a quantitative count of Restrictive Signs. While this day
was necessary to observe the degree to which the Restrictive Signs were followed, it
nevertheless left some inconsistency within our data.
Due to the overwhelming statistical significance between median age of the
population and Uncertainty Avoidance, we suggest further research be conducted concerning
the correlation between the ages of observable citizens and Uncertainty Avoidance. Further
research regarding the changes in Uncertainty Avoidance at different times of the day could
also add to the literature.
In today’s globalizing world, Uncertainty Avoidance remains a relevant issue for
many reasons, but notably for its implication in international business endeavors. According
to the GLOBE study, each of the four countries studied reported higher ‘values’ Uncertainty
Avoidance averages than ‘practices’ averages (622-623). This indicates that in each of the
four countries, the people desire further organization. Therefore, if one wishes to open a new
business in one the four countries, it is important to do so with organization and clear goals.
Accordingly, in order to successfully integrate into the business world of one of these four
countries, information regarding Uncertainty Avoidance is invaluable. In a broader sense, as
discussed in the Introduction, growing globalization and cross-cultural interactions are
Uncertainty Avoidance 20 Berget, Egan & Hughes imminent in today’s world. Populations continue to grow at alarming rates. Businesses
continue to expand beyond country borders. The world’s citizens will continue to travel and
interact with one another on a variety of levels. For these and other reasons, it is essential
that one is not only aware of the Uncertainty Avoidance (and inadvertently, the organization
and structure) of one’s own society, but of other societies in the world.
REFERENCES
Central Intelligence Agency [US]. (2011). Egypt; India; Hong Kong; South Korea. In The
World Factbook. Arlington, VA: Author. Retrieved January 10, 2012
Heine, S. J. (2008). Cultural Psychology (Vol. 1, pp. 450-451). New York, NY: W. W.
Norton & Company, Inc.
Uncertainty Avoidance 21 Berget, Egan & Hughes House, R. J., Hanges, P. J., Javidan, M., Dorfman, P. W., & Gupta, V. (2004). Culture,
Leadership, and Organizations. The GLOBE Study of 62 Societies, 618-631.
Infortunio, F. A. (2006). An exploration of the correlations between fatal accident rates
across nations and the cultural dimensions of power distance, Uncertainty Avoidance,
individuality, and masculinity. Dissertation Abstracts International Section A:
Humanities and Social, 67(5-A).
Wennekers, S., Thurik, R., van Stel, A., & Noorderhaven, N. (2007). Uncertainty Avoidance
and the rate of business ownership across 21 OECD countries, 1976-2004. Journal
of Evolutionary Economics, 17(2), 133-160.
Uncertainty Avoidance 22 Berget, Egan & Hughes APPENDIX
Egypt: Tahrir Square
India: Whitefield
Uncertainty Avoidance 23 Berget, Egan & Hughes Hong Kong: Hung Hom
South Korea: Sinchon
Uncertainty Avoidance 24