Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Contents Outcomes grid Introduction Glossary About the authors Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 Index iv v vi x Germany 1918–1945 1 Political, social and economic problems, 1918–1923 Golden years? Relative stability, 1924–1929 Nazi consolidation of power The transformation of social and cultural life under Nazism Nazi racial policy and the Holocaust Nazi foreign policy, 1933–1939 Personality study: Leni Riefenstahl 8 18 33 46 62 70 80 Russia and the Soviet Union, 1917–1945 89 The nature of the Bolshevik Revolution in 1917 The Bolshevik government, 1917–1924 The Soviet Union under Stalin Foreign policy and the Great Patriotic War Personality study: Leon Trotsky 95 108 123 157 172 The Cold War, 1945–1991 181 From World War to Cold War: 1945–1955 The global Cold War, 1949–1961 Crisis depth study: the Korean War The Cold War in the age of protest, 1960s–1970s Reagan and the ‘Evil Empire’: the 1980s Crisis depth study: Nicaragua and the Contra war Group studies The end of the Cold War and its legacy 190 Conflict in Indochina, 1954–1979 273 Challenges for the historian From the Geneva Accords to the NLF Insurrection Escalation Tet, ‘Vietnamisation’ and withdrawal, 1968–1973 Vietnam and Cambodia, 1973–1979 281 204 206 226 240 246 258 268 282 295 311 336 353 Outcomes grid New South Wales Modern History Stage 6 Knowledge and Understanding Outcomes Chapter 1 Chapter 2 Chapter 3 Chapter 4 H1.1 Describes and analyses the key features of specific periods of twentieth-century national and international history * * * * H1.2 Evaluates the role of key individuals, groups, events and ideas during specific periods of twentieth-century national and international history * * * * H2.1 Explains the forces that contributed to change and continuity during specific periods of twentieth-century national and international history and evaluates their relative significance * * * * H3.1 Uses historical terms and concepts appropriately within the contexts of twentieth-century national and international historical investigations * * * * H4.1 Evaluates sources for their usefulness and reliability in relation to specific historical investigations * * * * H4.2 Describes and evaluates different perspectives and interpretations of the past * * * * H5.1 Selects and organises relevant historical information from a variety of sources * * * * H5.2 Plans a historical investigation, analyses and synthesises historical information from a variety of perspectives, and presents the findings of the investigation * * * * H6.1 Communicates through well-structured texts to explain, argue, discuss, analyse and evaluate complex historical information, ideas and issues using appropriate written and oral forms * * * * H6.2 Uses planning and review strategies to manage effectively the competing demands of complex tasks making appropriate use of time and resources in order to complete historical investigations * * * * From the Board of Studies NSW Modern History Stage 6 Syllabus (1999), pages 12–13. iv Flashpoints Introduction Flashpoints: National and International Studies is a book about four fascinating periods that shaped the twentieth century, and is primarily written to meet the needs of students undertaking the New South Wales Higher School Certificate Modern History Course. Chapters 1 and 2 cover the two most popular National Studies (Germany 1918–1945 and Russia and the Soviet Union, 1917–1945), while Chapters 3 and 4 cover the two most popular International Studies in Peace and Conflict (The Cold War, 1945–1991 and Conflict in Indochina, 1954–1979). We have chosen the format of a multi-topic book to allow flexibility and choice in school programming, without sacrificing content detail and guidance for students. Each chapter explicitly covers New South Wales Board of Studies syllabus requirements including areas of historiographical debate, and interesting and illuminating source material. With this in mind, the following features, which are contained in each chapter, are designed to help students clearly understand the content and explore the issues involved in each study: • topic map • timeline • lists of key terms and key people • schematic overviews of concepts • historiography integrated into relevant sections of the text to enable students to understand the significant historiographical issues relevant to each study • detailed narrative and analysis of each study • engaging variety of written and visual sources with questions that will develop a wide range of historical skills • short answer questions and activities integrated within the text. Internet support Throughout the text you’ll notice the hi.com.au icon in the margin. This icon indicates that there is online support at hi.com.au/flashpoints. The online support comprises: • useful websites that have been carefully selected by the author team • exam-style questions and marking guidelines for each study. Introduction v Chapter 1 Germany 1918–1945 Introduction Contents At the end of World War I, Germany was a tired, divided and defeated nation. After a tradition of absolute monarchs, a democratic republic was founded with what was believed to be the most democratic constitution in the world at that time. During the 1920s the Weimar Republic struggled to survive under the shadow of the harsh Treaty of Versailles, causing deep resentment and intensifying divisions within Germany. From 1924, there appeared to be signs of recovery but the Wall Street crash of 1929 destroyed the German economy. A combination of factors gave rise to the Nazis in 1933, a group that had been on the fringes of German politics only five years before and whose rule led to the deaths of millions through the Holocaust and World War II. A study of the events that led to such horrific suffering is a reminder that none of us should take our personal or public freedoms for granted. • Political, social and economic problems, 1918–1923 • Golden years? Relative stability, 1924–1929 • Nazi consolidation of power • The transformation of social and cultural life under Nazism • Nazi racial policy and the Holocaust • Nazi foreign policy, 1933–1939 • Personality study: Leni Riefenstahl Topic map 0 100 300 500 km SWEDEN N FINLAND NORWAY ESTONIA LATVIA DENMARK LITHUANIA IRELAND UNITED KINGDOM BELARUS NETHERLANDS POLAND GERMANY BELGIUM CZECH REPUBLIC LUXEMBOURG UKRAINE SLOVAKIA LIECHTENSTEIN FRANCE SWITZERLAND AUSTRIA MOLDOVA HUNGARY SLOVENIA ROMANIA CROATIA ITALY BOSNIAHERZEGOVINA YUGOSLAVIA VATICAN CITY SPAIN MACEDONIA ALBANIA GREECE ALGERIA TUNISIA Political map of Germany, showing its place in Europe. 2 Flashpoints BULGARIA TURKEY Timeline 1918 January 1919 1923 1929 1933 1934 1935 1936 November October January September 1938 November 1939 1941 1942 1943 June January 1945 February April May World War I ends The Spartacist uprising Treaty of Versailles and the creation of the Weimar constitution The Munich Putsch; inflation and currency reform Start of the Great Depression Hitler becomes Chancellor of Germany Hitler combines positions of Chancellor and President The Nuremberg Laws Remilitarisation of the Rhineland The Berlin Olympics Anschluss, the Sudetenland Crisis and the Munich Agreement Kristallnacht Nazi–Soviet Pact, the invasion of Poland Invasion of the Soviet Union The Wannsee Conference and the Final Solution of the Jewish Problem Imposition of Total War Nazi defeat at Stalingrad Death of Hitler Germany surrenders Key terms Anschluss annexation of Austria by Germany, forbidden by Treaty of Versailles Anti-Comintern Pact treaty between Germany and Japan signed in November 1935 anti-Semitism hatred of Jews armistice agreement to end fighting in a war Article 48 a clause in the Weimar (democratic) constitution that allowed the President, in cases of national emergency, to suspend the democratic rights of the constitution and allowed the President to rule the country (pass laws and appoint new governments) Aryan originally, a term used to indicate IndoEuropeans; as a Nazi term, it was used to describe a person of ‘pure’ Germanic heritage/race Autarky the policy of economic self-sufficiency Axis the alliance of Germany, Japan and Italy during World War II Blitzkrieg German word meaning ‘lightning war’; the fast, violent war waged by Germany Chancellor Prime Minister Concordat an agreement between the Catholic Pope and the Nazi government on the relationship between the church and government in Germany conservative descriptive of people wishing to maintain the political and social status quo Dawes Plan a plan that reorganised Germany’s reparations payments and arranged large foreign loans in April 1924; stimulated improvement in the German economy after 1924 D-Day the Allied invasion of Western Europe at Normandy on 6 June 1944 dolchstosslegende the ‘stab in the back’ legend or myth that was an inaccurate blaming of Germany’s defeat in World War I on the republican government Germany 1918–1945 3 élite groups in society with power and influence Enabling Act the law passed in March 1933 giving Hitler emergency powers for four years, marking the beginning of the Third Reich Freikorps German for ‘free corps’; former World War I soldiers who were anti-communist and nationalistic Führer German word for ‘leader’; the name given to Hitler as the unquestioned leader of the Nazi Party and, later, Germany Führerprinzip literally, the ‘leader principle’; obedience to the leader (Hitler) fulfilment the policy of meeting reparations obligations under the Treaty of Versailles adopted in 1922 Gestapo an acronym for the Geheime Staatspolizei (State Secret Police), a section of the SS, the Nazi secret police led by Heinrich Himmler Gleichschaltung the process through which laws were passed that brought Germany under Nazi control during 1933 and 1934 Hossbach Memorandum the minutes of a meeting held in November 1937 in which Hitler described his foreign policy plans, particularly the invasion of Austria and Czechoslovakia hyperinflation extreme inflation Junker a member of the land-owning aristocracy Kaiser the German Emperor KPD the German Communist Party Lebensraum German for ‘living space’; the Nazi idea of ‘living space’ for the Aryan people mark the main unit of German currency Munich Agreement an agreement among Germany, Great Britain and France made on 29 September 1939, which gave Germany part of Czechoslovakia Munich Putsch a failed attempt to take power in Munich by the Nazis in November 1923 Night of the Long Knives the purge of the SA and opponents of the Nazis, which enabled Hitler to gain the support of the German army NSDAP the National Socialist German Workers Party, or the Nazis Nuremberg rallies annual Nazi Party rallies held in the city of Nuremberg putsch attempt to take power violently Reich empire Reichstag German Parliament Reichswehr the term used for the German army until 1935 Rentenmark the currency introduced in 1924 to replace the devalued mark reparations money paid by losing country to compensate for war 4 Flashpoints republic a country in which supreme power rests with the people and their elected representative rather than a monarch; this term is used to describe the government of Germany between 1919 and 1933 Rhineland the land on the border of Germany, France, Belgium and Luxembourg, which is an important mining area SA abbreviation of Sturmabteilung (stormtroopers); the Nazi private army, also known as the brownshirts soviet Russian word for council or committee Spartacists communist movement, named for the Roman gladiator Spartacus, who started a slave rebellion in ancient Rome SPD the Social Democrats, a moderate left-wing party that supported democracy SS schutzstaffel (also known as the blackshirts); originally Hitler’s personal bodyguards; after the SA was destroyed in the Night of the Long Knives (1934), the SS became the Nazi ‘police force’ Sudetenland an industrial area in western Czechoslovakia where many German-speaking people lived, and that was given to Germany under the Munich Agreement Third Reich literally, the ‘third empire’; refers to the time of Nazi rule The Germans invade Poland. Concepts overview Democracy Militarism Democracy is a political system in which, generally speaking, all adult citizens have the right to vote and to stand for election, and in which the political party or coalition of parties gaining the most votes forms the government. From 1918, Germany had a democratic constitution, considered at the time to be the most democratic of nations. However, the fact that this constitution contained a clause (Article 48) that allowed the President to rule by decree in times of ‘national emergency’ calls this into question. After 1930, President Hindenburg repeatedly used Article 48 to appoint governments, which meant that after this time democracy ceased to function. Hitler was also able to use the democratic constitution in order to become a legal dictator and destroy democracy in Germany. Militarism is an aggressive political position based on the role of armed forces in maintaining the power and security of the state and promoting the interests of the state internationally. The Nazi government was militaristic in its aims and outlook, and relied on the rebuilding of its army in order to fulfil the key aims of Nazism as outlined in Hitler’s Mein Kampf. Nazi Germany Nationalism Racism Nationalism is a feeling of strong loyalty towards one’s nation. At some points in history, nationalism has inspired independence movements or the belief that one’s nation is superior to others. In Germany, intense nationalism was expressed in extreme right-wing groups, such as the NSDAP. Racism is the belief that some races are superior to others and therefore should have more rights and privileges. Nazi ideology was deeply racist in its belief that life was a struggle between races that would be won by the superior Aryan race. The deep antiSemitism of the Nazis was also part of their racist worldview. Totalitarianism and the economy. According to historians such as Ian Kershaw, this does not apply to Nazi Germany, as their ideology was not complex, power in the Nazi state still rested in individuals (i.e., the Führer) as opposed to a mass party, and the economy was not completely controlled by the state. In the 1950s, Carl Friedrich used the term totalitarianism to describe the government of the Soviet Union, and this was also used to describe the government of Nazi Germany. According to Friedrich, totalitarian states had a complex ideology, a mass party in power, used terror, monopolised the media, and controlled the armed forces Germany 1918–1945 5 Key groups The Jewish community Nazi Party (including the SA and SS) • Two of the most important Nazi ideas were those of race and anti-Semitism. • One of the main Nazi aims was to create the Aryan master race and destroy the Jews. • Policies to make this happen were a core part of Nazi rule in Germany and were implemented as soon as Hitler came to power in 1933. • Race became an important part of most aspects of German life. For example, Race Studies was taught in schools. • The idea of the master race had two consequences: the need to conquer the ‘inferior races’ outside Germany to create ‘living space’ for the Aryan race; and the persecution and eventual extermination of ‘inferior’ races within Germany, particularly Jews. • The persecution of the Jews can be looked at in three stages: 1933–1938: removal of civil rights 1938–1941: intensification of persecution 1941–1945: the Holocaust • In 1919, Anton Drexler founded the German Workers Party in Bavaria. • Adolf Hitler joined and soon came to dominate the party, which changed its name to the National Socialist German Workers Party (or NAZI Party). • By 1921, the party had its own army, the SA, led by Ernst Röhm. The SA attacked opponents and protected party leaders. • In 1923, they felt strong enough to launch the Munich Putsch. Although it failed, Hitler had become nationally known. • The failure of the Munich Putsch made Hitler realise that the only way to come to power in Germany was through winning elections rather than by armed takeovers. The Nazi Party was restructured, better organised and Hitler consolidated his leadership of the party. • Understanding the importance of propaganda, Nazis used rallies, meetings and parades to spread their message. In 1929, the Nazis received support from Alfred Hugenberg, an industrialist who controlled 700 German newspapers and film outlets. Hitler was able to promote himself on the national stage as the country fell into the Great Depression. • The Depression caused a number of political crises in Germany. In 1930, government policies caused greater hardship, leading to widespread anger. • The Nazis promoted themselves as the only group who could save Germany. • The Nazis did not come to power by winning an election. Hitler manoeuvred his way to power legally. Wehrmacht (German fighting forces, 1935–45) • The Wehrmacht (Army) was the most powerful non-Nazi group in German society between 1935 and 1945. • After the purge of the SA in 1934, the Army gave its loyalty to Hitler (all members of the Wehrmacht gave a loyalty oath to Hitler personally). • The reintroduction of conscription in 1935 increased the support of the Wehrmacht for the Nazi regime. • Although most generals supported Hitler’s militaristic and expansionist aims, tensions did exist. Some generals doubted Germany’s ability to fight a war of conquest in eastern Europe because of its lack of resources. In February 1938, those who criticised Hitler’s policies after the Hossbach Conference (see pages 72–3) were removed from the High Command. • As the tide turned against Germany in World War II, members of the military leadership took part in opposition groups (see pages 37–43). 6 Flashpoints Women Youth organisations • The Nazis believed that women should simply become mothers and devote themselves to their families (Kinder, Kirche und Küche: Children, Church and Kitchen). • They believed that the family was essential and that the job of all Aryan women was to produce children for the Nazi state. • Women were removed from most professions. • Women who had many children were rewarded. • These policies had to be changed in the late thirties as more workers were needed to help to re-arm Germany. Women were placed in unskilled and lower paid jobs, but Nazi propaganda had been so successful that many women did not want to return to the workforce. • The Nazi Youth groups were organised to ensure a new generation of committed Nazis. • In 1936, membership of Nazi Youth Groups was made compulsory. They had nine million members by 1939. • The Nazi Youth movement was highly structured and was made up of different stages: – Little Fellows (Pimpf): Boys aged between six and ten. – Young Folk (Jungvolk): Boys between ten and 14. – The Hitler Youth (Hitler Jugend): Boys between 14 and 18. – When they reached eighteen, young men joined the Labour Front for six months’ compulsory work. After 1937, they joined the Army. • For girls, there were other youth groups: – League of German Girls (Jung-Mädelbund): Girls between ten and 14. – The League of German Maidens (Bund Deutscher Mädel, or BDM): Girls between 14 and 18. – When they reached 18, young women could then join Faith and Beauty, which focused on health, grooming and housework skills to prepare them for their role as wives and mothers. Young members of Germany’s National Socialist ranks marching before Hitler, March 1931. Germany 1918–1945 7 Things to know before you start Left or right wing? ou will read about parties or politicians being described as ‘left wing’ or ‘right wing’. Left wing refers to socialist or communist ideas, and right wing refers to more conservative or nationalist views. The Nazis were an extreme right-wing party. You will also read about parties that were more moderate or centre parties. For example, in Australia today, the Australian Labor Party could be described as a centre–left, or social democratic party. The Liberal Party of Australia is a conservative or centre–right party. Y Left wing Moderate/ Centre Right wing Communist Social Democrats (centre left) Conservatives (centre right) Nationalist Fascist KPD (Communist) SPD Zentrum (Centre Party)/ DDP/DVP NSDAP (Nazi) Political, social and economic problems, 1918–1923 29 Oct 1918 Naval mutiny at Wilhelmshaven The end of war and a new government DENMARK Baltic Sea N 9 Nov 1918 Kaiser fled to Holland 6 4 5 1 2 Nov 1918 Sailors took control of 1 Cuxhaven 2 Bremen 3 Hamburg 4 Rostok 5 Lübeck 6 Kiel 3 2 6 Jan 1919 Spartacist uprising in Berlin B C D G GERMANY A 8 Nov 1918 Bavaria declared a Socialist Republic F 8 Nov 1918 Major riots in A Cologne B Dortmund C Essen D Berlin E Stuttgart F Dresden G Leipzig E Munich SWITZERLAND AUSTRIA 0 Areas of unrest in Germany, 1918–19. 8 Flashpoints 100 200 km he failure of Germany’s Spring Offensive in September 1918 made it clear to many members of the German High Command that the German army was close to collapse. General Ludendorff told the Kaiser that they had lost the war and advised him that Germany should seek an armistice with the Allies. None of this was made known to the people of Germany, who had been encouraged to believe, through the use of propaganda, that there was still a chance for victory. When defeat came, they were completely shocked. On 1 October, Prince Max of Baden formed a coalition government that would negotiate an armistice. As news of impending defeat spread, there was unrest among the armed forces. Sailors at Kiel and Wilhelmshaven refused to fight. At Kiel, the German navy mutinied on 28 October. Soldiers sent in to control the mutineers refused to fire on them. Sailors, soldiers and other people formed soviets. By 5 November, the mutiny had spread to other ports, soviets were set up in some German towns, and a revolt in the city of Munich (the capital city of the state of Bavaria) led to the proclamation of a Bavarian republic. In other words, an entire German state had broken away. T One of the most important political parties in the coalition government was the SPD, a moderate socialist party with about one million members, who threatened to withdraw from the coalition unless the Kaiser abdicated. Fearful that this might lead to a civil war in Germany, Prince Max persuaded the Kaiser to give up the throne. The SPD immediately withdrew from the coalition government (which caused it to lose power) and set up their own government. Prince Max resigned and the leader of the Social Democrats, Friedrich Ebert, became Chancellor. The Kaiser fled the country and a German Republic was proclaimed on 9 November 1918. On 11 November, representatives from the new government met with the Allies at Compiègne in France and signed the armistice that ended the Great War. This meant that neither the army nor the Kaiser would be blamed for defeat; those who did not support the new republican government could blame politicians, especially the Social Democratic Party, for the humiliation of defeat and a harsh treaty forced upon Germany. This became known as the myth of the ‘stab in the back’ (dolchtosslegende). Attack from the left: The Spartacist revolt The first problem faced by the new government came from the extreme left. By mid-1919, this threat had been eradicated because the army joined forces with the government to crush communist uprisings. This did not guarantee stability for the new German Republic, however; the German army did not support the democratic system or the Republic but opposed communism even more. It soon became clear that although the army would swiftly crush any threat from the left, they refused to take any action against right-wing opposition or uprisings. At a conference of representatives of the German states in 1918, it was agreed to set up a new National Assembly. However, extreme left-wing groups opposed any kind of democratic parliament and called for revolution. The Spartacists attempted an uprising in Berlin in December and January 1918. This was put down by the army and Freikorps. The leaders of the Spartacists were murdered. Who were the Freikorps? The Freikorps (or Free Corps) comprised more than 200 paramilitary groups or private armies that were formed after World War I. Made up primarily of exsoldiers and officers, the Freikorps tended to be right wing and nationalistic, hostile towards the Republic and saw their role as being to protect Germany from communism. Uneasy allies: The Ebert–Groener Pact To ensure that there would not be a communist revolution or civil war, President Ebert had made an agreement with General Groener, Commander of the Army, in November 1918. The Ebert–Groener Pact ensured that the army, also known as the Reichswehr, would support the Republic. During 1919, Ebert used the Reichswehr against the left, but the army’s loyalty to the Republic was uncertain. In fact, most army officers were antirepublican and anti-democratic, preferring the rule of the Kaiser. The army did little to stop the murder squads that killed communist leaders and others. General Hans von Seeckt, who became Commander of the Reichswehr in 1920, believed that the army was ‘a state within a state’, arguing that the interests of the army were separate from the interests of the government, and refused to carry out reforms within the army because it was ‘non-political’. A new German constitution After elections in January 1919, the new constitution of Germany was proclaimed at the city of Weimar, far away from the unrest and violence in Berlin, which continued despite the crushing of the Spartacists. The Reichswehr and the Freikorps soon crushed these uprisings and defeated the Bavarian republic. Although the Republic faced threats from both the left and the right, it survived because the army saw the threat of a communist revolution (as had happened in Russia in 1917) as a more immediate problem to be dealt with. At no stage during the Weimar period did a single party win power in its own right. Although the SPD usually won the most votes until 1930, it was never enough to form a majority, so governments were created by parties agreeing to form a coalition. These coalitions were usually unstable and governments did not last long as a result. There were 25 different governments between 1919 and 1933. Social and economic problems The impact of the Treaty of Versailles As a result of the Treaty of Versailles, Germany lost: • 15% of land • 12% of people • 10% of coal reserves • 48% of iron • 15% of agricultural land • 10% of industry Germany 1918–1945 9 Germany was also bound to pay reparations for damage caused in battle zones, shipping losses and the pensions and benefits paid to allied soldiers and their families. The total reparations bill was set at US$32 billion dollars. The German delegates at the Peace Conference, who had not been allowed to take any part in the treaty negotiations, were horrified by the harsh and punishing terms. Ulrich von Brockdorff-Rantzau, the German Foreign Minister, suggested that they simply refuse to sign it, and the entire German cabinet resigned. With the Allies threatening to resume attacks on Germany unless they accepted the treaty, the new Foreign Minister, Hermann Müller, signed the Treaty of Versailles. Source 1.1 Today in the Hall of Mirrors [at Versailles] the disgraceful treaty is being signed. Do not forget it! The German people will, with unceasing labour, press forward to reconquer the place among nations to which they are entitled. Editorial from the Deutsche Zeitung, 28 June 1919. Source 1.2 A German cartoon from 1919 Dolchstosslegende: The ‘stab in the back’ myth The humiliating treaty was blamed on the Weimar government, members of which were branded ‘the November criminals’. The ‘war guilt’ clause in the treaty caused particular bitterness and resentment. Generals Ludendorff and Hindenburg had advised the Kaiser to seek an armistice in September 1918, and advised the Weimar government that Germany could not resist renewed Allied attacks if they did not accept the treaty in May 1919. By November 1919, however, they were promoting the idea that the treaty should never have been signed and that it was the new government that had betrayed the German army, thus leading to the military collapse of 1918. The fact that the Kaiser had abdicated before the armistice was signed meant that he was not held responsible. The ‘stab in the back’ myth also completely ignored the military weaknesses that led to Germany’s defeat. Right-wing groups now blamed Ebert, Müller and Mattias Erzburger, the founders of the German Republic, for the Schmachfrieden—the ‘shameful peace’. This simple ‘explanation’ for Germany’s defeat and humiliation became widely accepted; it undermined the faith that many Germans had in the new republic and was used to attack democracy in Germany. The caption reads, ‘Germany, work! The liars blamed us for the war. Now they also burden us with reparations’. Questions 1 Describe the attitude shown towards the Treaty of Versailles in Sources 1.1 and 1.2. 2 How are reparations presented in Source 1.2? 3 How useful are Sources 1.1 and 1.2 for a historian studying reactions to the Treaty of Versailles in Germany? 10 Flashpoints Attack from the right: The Kapp Putsch The importance of the Kapp Putsch The Treaty led to political instability. Many on the right simply wanted the Republic overthrown by force. In October 1919, General Ludendorff, Wolfgang Kapp (a journalist and founder of the right-wing Fatherland Party) and General von Luttwitz (a leader of the Freikorps) formed the National Association to organise anti-republican forces. One of Kapp’s aims was to restore the German monarchy. When the German government tried to reduce the number of soldiers in the army and the Freikorps (as demanded by the Treaty) in March 1920, the National Association saw the opportunity for an uprising. In Berlin, Luttwitz refused to disband Freikorps units and on 13 March, units of ex-soldiers (who had simply joined the Freikorps after leaving the army) rebelled—5000 troops seized government buildings. Led by Wolfgang Kapp, they marched to Berlin and a right-wing government was declared under his leadership. Although the Commander-in-Chief, General Reinhardt, was prepared to act against the Putsch, all other commanders refused. The army’s refusal to move against this takeover of the government was in stark contrast to their actions against the Spartacist revolt, claiming ‘Reichswehr does not fire upon Reichswehr’ (‘the army does not fire upon the army’). It was only when President Ebert (who had fled to the city of Dresden) called on workers to help save the Republic that the Kapp Putsch could be defeated. A general strike was called, which so completely paralysed Berlin that Kapp’s government fell after only a few days in power. However, in Bavaria the SPD government was forced to resign and a right-wing government took its place. After the failure of the Kapp Putsch, the government was unable to punish those behind the Putsch, mainly because of their reliance on the army to put down leftwing attacks. The Putsch had set off a wave of strikes and communist-led uprisings in other parts of Germany, including a massive revolt led by the Spartacists in the mining area of the Ruhr. The government had to call on the army (following the Ebert–Groener Pact) to crush this uprising. Although the Kapp Putsch collapsed, it was a significant event because it showed that nationalist or right-wing groups were prepared to take action against the Republic just as readily as the left. It also showed, however, that workers and unions would fight against any attempted military takeover (coup). The Putsch widened the divisions between the army and the Republic. It showed the government that the army would only act in its own interests and would never take action against those whose ideas it supported. This meant that the army was not a non-political servant of the government but a group in German society with a clear agenda of its own and no loyalty to democracy. The army would ruthlessly crush opposition or uprisings from the left but supported right-wing or nationalist groups, or at the very least would not stop them. It became clear that the relationship between the army and the government rested solely on their opposition to communism and their determination to put down any left-wing revolts. In other words, the Republic’s survival relied on an army whose leaders did not support it. Source 1.3 The general strike in Potsdamer Platz caused transport chaos. Germany 1918–1945 11 Source 1.4 Questions 1 Describe the effects of the Kapp Putsch as shown in Source 1.3 on page 11. 2 How can Source 1.3 be useful to historians studying the reasons why the Kapp Putsch failed? 3 Explain the significance of the flag that the soldiers in Source 1.4 are holding. 4 What do Sources 1.4 and 1.5 show you about the aims of those who took part in the Kapp Putsch? The ‘White Terror’ Kapp soldiers holding the Imperial flag during the Kapp Putsch. Source 1.5 The proud German Army, after victoriously resisting an enemy superior in numbers for four years, performing feats unprecedented in history, and keeping our foes from our frontiers, disappeared in a moment. Our victorious fleet was handed over to the enemy. The authorities at home, who had not fought against the enemy, could not hurry fast enough to pardon deserters and other military criminals, including among these many of their own number, themselves and their nearest friends. They and the Soldiers’ Councils worked with zeal, determination and purpose to destroy the whole military structure. Such was the gratitude of the new homeland to the German soldiers who had bled and died for it in millions. The destruction of Germany’s power to defend itself —the work of Germans—was the most tragic crime the world has witnessed. A tidal wave had broken over Germany, not by the force of nature, but through the weakness of the Government, represented by the Chancellor, and the paralysis of a leaderless people. From General Ludendorff, My War Memories, 1914–1918, 1920. 12 Flashpoints In 1921 and 1922, there was continued political violence in Germany. Although there were significant KPD uprisings in Hamburg and central Germany, these were put down by the army. Most incidents of mob violence, terror attacks and assassinations came from the right in a campaign known as the ‘White Terror’. The most prominent victims were Mattias Erzburger (leader of the SPD, and member of the German delegation at the Paris Peace Conference) and the German Foreign Minister, Walter Rathenau. Both were murdered by members of Operation Consul, a group of ex-army officers. In 1922, the Law for the Protection of the Republic was passed to combat such attacks, setting harsh penalties for acts of political violence and terrorism. Although the majority of assassinations and acts of political violence were carried out by right-wing groups (354 out of 376), the German judiciary who tended to oppose the Republic refused to pass heavy sentences on right-wing defendants. Of the 22 left-wing defendants, ten were sentenced to death, while none from the right received the death penalty and only 28 received any punishment at all. Their average prison sentence was four months. The growth of private armies During this time, a number of private paramilitary groups began to appear on both the left and right wings of the political scene: Right wing Left wing The Stalhelm (steel helmet) The Reichsbanner • a group of army veterans founded by former officers Franz Seldte and Theodor Duesterberg • main aim was to fight any attempts at a left-wing or communist revolt • wanted Germany to return to a monarchy and was fiercely nationalistic • began to play an important role in politics by the late 1920s (see page 29) • an unarmed movement organised on military lines, formed in opposition to the Stalhelm • made up mainly of ex-servicemen who tended to be SPD and trade union members The Sturmabteilung (the SA) The Red Fighting League (Rotfrontkampferbund) • the private army of the KPD • the main opponent of the Stalhelm and the SA • the stormtroopers of the Nazi Party • attracted many ex-Freikorps members and ex-soldiers (see page 9) Source 1.6 Here in Bavaria, I am in the stronghold of reaction. At night I am often awakened by the military commands and the march of men (Monarchists) who are training at night in the forests and in the mountains. It is a gruesome feeling—this secret training of men to kill other men. And these men being trained are peasants and working-men—not the class we usually think of. In Saxony the same thing occurs; there at night the men who are under training are also working men, but the leaders are Communists. And they are preparing to kill their kind also. Sometimes I see no difference between the two. What is this business everywhere—men preparing to murder their own kind for the sake of an idea? Not their own idea either, but that of men who use them as tools to set themselves in power. We only wait for the day when the two groups will start massacring each other. Both groups are bitterly opposed to passive resistance as a method; it isn’t bloody or sadistic enough. Extract from a letter written by Agnes Smedley (an Englishwoman living in Germany) to a friend, 11 August 1923. Source 1.7 The week has witnessed looting of many shops in various parts of the city, unrest in most cities throughout the country, and actual street fighting in many. Looting and rioting are regarded as so much grist to the mills of the Communists and the reactionaries alike. The Communists take advantage of it and preach their dogma; the monarchists do the same. They smile cynically when they read of the frightful increase in the cost of living and say, ‘It has not yet gone far enough. It must be worse still before the masses realize the mistake they have made in establishing a republic! We shall wait a bit longer.’ But most of the townspeople are so weary, so destroyed by uncertainty and long years of nervous strain, that they do not care what happens. They are tired of it all. From an article written by Agnes Smedley in The Nation, 28 November 1923. Germany 1918–1945 13 Source 1.8 Nothing could be heard but the sound of marching boots. A small boy in the crowd of onlookers laughed … two members of the Ehrhardt [a Freikorps unit] broke ranks, knocked the boy down and beat him with their rifle butts until he was quite still. Nobody else moved, although someone had the courage to hiss. An officer barked a command and machine guns opened fire on the crowd. Questions 3 To what extent are sources 1.6, 1.7 and 1.8 useful for a historian studying paramilitary groups in Germany in the early 1920s? 1 What activities are being described in Sources 1.6 and 1.7 on page 13? 2 Describe the attitude of Agnes Smedley to these events. Failed coalition governments Reichstag elections held after the Kapp Putsch in 1920 reflected weakened support for the Republic. The prorepublican coalition of the SPD, the Centre Party and the DDP saw their majority of 78 per cent of seats plummet to 45 per cent. This meant that moderate pro-republican parties were unable to gain an outright majority in the Reichstag. Smaller extreme parties who were antirepublic, such as the KPD on the left and the DVP on the right, played a more important role in a series of coalition governments. Between 1919 and 1923, a series of coalition governments rose and fell, as no single party was able to win an outright majority. Between 1919 and 1923 there were six separate coalition governments. This added to the atmosphere of chaos and instability that seemed to be the main feature of republican government. From G.S. Graber, History of the SS, 1978. Allies had occupied Duisburg, Düsseldorf and Ruhrort. By 4 May, the government resigned. The Allies showed little sympathy with Germany’s pleas that the Plan was economically damaging, and made a threat (known as the London Ultimatum) to invade the coalmining area of the Ruhr if the new German government did not accept the Plan. Under the policy of fulfilment, the new German government accepted the London Payments Plan. During the Genoa Conference in April 1922, called to discuss international economic problems, Germany’s international isolation and diplomatic weakness was highlighted. When the French government continued to insist that Germany pay the full reparations bill, Germany decided to negotiate with the Soviet Union. The Treaty of Rapallo was signed in April 1922 between Germany and the Soviet Union, with an agreement to drop any war compensation claims and set up trade and diplomatic relations, ending Germany’s isolation. The problem of reparations The most pressing problem for the new government was fulfilling the Treaty of Versailles. On 1 May 1921, the Allies finally set the figure that Germany had to pay at 20,000 billion gold marks under the London Payments Plan. Under the London Plan, Germany had to make an annual payment of 2000 million gold marks plus 26 per cent of the value of its exports. Germany was also bound to pay reparations for damage caused in battle zones, shipping losses, and the pensions and benefits paid to allied soldiers and their families. The total reparations bill was set at US$32 billion. Under the threat of Allied occupation if they refused the Plan, the government accepted—when Germany had rejected earlier plans, the 14 Flashpoints Economic meltdown: Reparations and the Ruhr crisis The Treaty of Versailles also caused economic instability. After the devastation of war and the losses of territories, the German currency was unstable and it was impossible for Germany to pay the massive reparations bill. The reparations debt worsened Germany’s economic problems. Germany made the first payment in 1921, then asked the Allies in July 1922 to suspend payments in order to help the German economy to recover—at this stage, their national debt was 469,000 million marks. The Allies refused, so Germany stated that they could not make further reparations payments in 1923 or 1924. In December 1922, the Reparations Commission declared that Germany had failed to supply the coal and timber ordered by the Treaty of Versailles. In January 1923, France and Belgium sent 60,000 troops to the coalmining area of the Ruhr to get this ‘payment’. The people of Germany were outraged. The government called for a campaign of passive resistance against the French occupation and the coal miners and other workers in the Ruhr went on strike. Chancellor Cuno put an immediate stop to all reparations payments. More French and Belgian troops were sent to the Ruhr and occupied it for the next two years. Mine owners were arrested and the mines and railways were taken over. Although the campaign of passive resistance was successful because coal production in the Ruhr fell dramatically, it had a disastrous effect on Germany’s economy. The Ruhr was an extremely important mining and industrial area. Germany was forced to import coal and lost the income that it would have earned from the Ruhr. The government paid everyone who lost income during the passive resistance. This ran to millions of marks. Government costs had risen by 700 per cent, and more banknotes were simply printed. Inflation quickly became hyperinflation, with German currency completely losing its value. Date Value of US dollar in German marks The impact of hyperinflation • Working-class and middle-class Germans lost the value of their wages; savings and pensions were wiped out. • Farmers and landowners survived the crisis as they could barter their crops. • Industrialists and big business benefited from the crisis: they could wipe out their debts. Businesses that had access to foreign currency or exported goods made fortunes. • Radical parties took advantage of the hardship and despair caused by the Ruhr crisis. The communists won an extra 58 seats in the elections of 1924. The Nazi Party began to grow and increase its influence. • Although the government was weakened, it benefited economically as hyperinflation resulted in a loss of government debts. People who had suffered devastating financial losses turned against the Republic. This loss of support can be seen as one of the longterm causes of the failure of democracy in Germany by 1933. • Political instability escalated: in Bavaria, the Land (state government) suspended democratic rule and ordered the army to swear allegiance to the state rather than the Republic; Freikorps units known as the Fehme or Black Army revolted in Spandau near Berlin; SPD state governments in Saxony and Thuringia invited communists to become ministers as money and advisers from the Soviet Union set up leftwing paramilitary groups; in the Rhineland the French encouraged the setting up of a republic to break away from Germany. July 1914 4.2 marks July 1919 14 marks January 1921 65 marks Solving the problem January 1922 191 marks July 1922 493 marks January 1923 18,000 marks July 1923 350,000 marks August 1923 4,600,000 marks November 1923 4,200,000,000,000 marks In August 1923, a new Chancellor, Gustav Stresemann, came to power. He ended passive resistance and stabilised the currency by introducing the Rentenmark. Ending passive resistance caused an outcry by right-wing nationalists and resulted in a failed Putsch by the Nazis in Munich (see page 16). After Stresemann resigned as Chancellor, he served as Foreign Minister until his death in 1929. Germany 1918–1945 15 Source 1.9 Source 1.11 Two women were going to the bank with a washing basket filled with notes (money). They passed a shop and saw a crowd standing around the window, so they put down the basket for a moment to see if there was anything going that could be bought. Then they turned round and found that all the notes were there, untouched, but the basket had gone. A Berlin joke, 1923. Questions Cartoon from the German magazine Simplicissimus, 1923. The mother is crying out ‘Bread! Bread!’ Source 1.10 On Friday afternoons in 1923, very long lines of workers waited outside the pay windows of the big German factories, department stores, banks and offices, watching the clocks until at last they reached the pay window and received a bag full of paper bank notes. According to the figures on the notes, they were worth anything from 700,000 marks up to 380 billion or even 18 trillion marks; the figures rose month by month, then week to week, then day to day. People began running as soon as they could. They dashed to food stores where there were further slow queues. Had you got there first, a half kilo of sugar might have been bought for 2 million marks. If you were at the back, by the time you got to the counter, 2 million would buy only a quarter kilo. The government printing presses could not keep up. People carried their money around in sacks or prams. Life was madness, nightmare, desperation, chaos. From K. Heiden, Der Führer: Hitler’s Rise to Power, 1944. 16 Flashpoints 1 What were the effects of hyperinflation as described in Sources 1.9, 1.10 and 1.11? 2 What were the differing reactions towards hyperinflation as described in Sources 1.9, 1.10 and 1.11? 3 To what extent does Source 1.10 help you to understand the reasons why hyperinflation caused a drop in support for the Republic? Use the evidence from the text to support your answer. The Munich Putsch The right-wing government of the state of Bavaria was outraged by Stresemann’s ending of passive resistance against the French. It gave its leader the powers of a dictator and refused to obey the Berlin government. Although the Bavarian government toned down its resistance to the federal government after Stresemann’s government called on the army to restore order in Saxony and Thuringia, it remained the stronghold of anti-republican feeling. During a meeting of Bavarian ministers with businessmen in a Munich beer hall, the Nazi stormtroopers (SA) led by Adolf Hitler burst in and announced that Hitler had taken over the Bavarian government. Hitler asked the ministers to join a new national government led by himself and General Ludendorff. When the Nazis marched on Munich the next day, they were stopped by the Bavarian police. Hitler was arrested and the Putsch ended. Hitler was able to use his trial to publicise his views throughout Germany, and was given a light sentence by the judges, who sympathised with him. Source 1.12 Kahr was sending us off to sleep. He had just said the words ‘and now I come to the consideration’ which, for all I know, was to be the high spot of his speech, when the door behind us which we had come through flew open and in burst Goering with about twenty-five brownshirts with pistols and machine-guns. Hitler began to plough his way towards the platform and the rest of us surged forward behind him. Tables overturned with their jugs of beer. On the way we passed a major named Mucksel, one of the heads of the intelligence section at Army head- quarters, who started to draw his pistol as soon as he saw Hitler approach, but the bodyguard had covered him with theirs and there was no shooting. Hitler clambered on a chair and fired a round at the ceiling. It is always maintained that he did this to terrify the gathering into submission, but I swear he did it to wake people up. Anyway, on home ground at last, Hitler barked an impromptu proclamation: ‘The national revolution has broken out. The Reichswehr is with us. Our flag is flying on their barracks.’ From Ernst Hanfstaengel, Hitler: The Missing Years, 1957. Source 1.13 The Bavarian Ministry is removed. I propose that a Bavarian government shall be formed consisting of a Regent and a Prime Minister invested with dictatorial powers. I propose Herr von Kahr as Regent and Herr Pohner as Prime Minister. The government of the November criminals and the Reich President are declared to be removed. I propose that, until accounts have been finally settled with the November criminals, the direction of policy in the national Government be taken over by me. Ludendorff will take over the leadership of the German National Army, Lossow will be German Reichswehr Minister, Seisser Reich Police Minister. From Adolf Hitler’s speech made in the Munich Burgerbraukeller, 8 November 1923. Source 1.14 Hitler shouted, ‘Close the ranks,’ and linked arms with his neighbours. The body of the man with whom Hitler was linked shot up into the air like a ball, tearing Hitler’s arm with him, so that it sprang from the joint and fell back limp and dead. Hitler approached the man and stooped over him. Blood was pouring from his mouth. Hitler picked him up and carried him on his shoulders. ‘If I can only get him to the car,’ Hitler thought, ‘then the boy is saved.’ From the official biography of Adolf Hitler published by the Nazi Party in 1934. Germany 1918–1945 17 Questions 1 Compare the accounts of the Putsch in Sources 1.12 and 1.14 on page 17. 2 Explain the reasons why the descriptions of the Putsch differ in 1.12 and 1.14. 3 According to Source 1.13 on page 17, what were the aims of the Beer Hall Putsch? 4 Who were the ‘November criminals’? 5 To what extent were these aims in Source 1.13 widely accepted? Use the text to support your answer. Short answer questions 1 Who advised the Kaiser to seek an armistice in 1918? 2 What events took place in Germany as news of impending defeat spread? 3 Who were the SPD? 4 Why did the Kaiser abdicate? 5 When was the German Republic proclaimed? 6 Who signed the armistice for Germany? 7 What is the Dolchstosslegende? 8 Who were the Spartacists? 9 How was the Spartacist uprising defeated? 10 Who were the Freikorps? 11 What was the Ebert–Groener pact? 12 Was the German Army completely loyal to the Republic? Explain your answer with evidence. 13 Define the term ‘reparations’. 14 Was wasn’t the Kaiser blamed for the armistice? 15 What was the Schmachfrieden ? 16 How was the Dolchstosslegende used to undermine democracy in Germany? 17 What did right-wing opponents of the Republic want? 18 Describe the events of the Kapp Putsch that led to its failure. 19 What was the importance of the Kapp Putsch? 20 What was the ‘White Terror’? 21 Why was the law for the Protection of the Republic passed? 22 Describe the attitudes of German judges towards right-wing defendants. Why did they have these attitudes? 23 Describe the attitudes of German judges towards left-wing defendants. Why did they have these attitudes? 24 Who were the SA? 25 What was the Red Fighting League? 26 What did election results after the Kapp Putsch show? 27 How many coalition governments ruled Germany between 1919 and 1923? 28 What was the London Plan? 29 Describe the events that led to hyperinflation in Germany in 1923. 30 What was the Munich Beer Hall Putsch? Golden years? Relative stability, 1924–1929 traditional view of events between 1924 to 1929 is that this was a time of economic recovery, foreign policy successes and political stability (often called a ‘Golden Age’) for the Republic, which A 18 Flashpoints was destroyed by the economic collapse of the Great Depression that began in October 1929. This caused the rise of Hitler, who succeeded because he offered Germans a solution. However, a closer look at Germany’s Short answer questions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 When was Leni Riefenstahl born? What was her original career? What prompted Riefenstahl to become an actress? What kind of films did she appear in? What type of heroine did she play? Why were these films popular? Which film marked Leni Riefenstahl’s debut as a director? Why was this unusual? How successful was her first film as a director? How did Leni Riefenstahl first come to meet Adolf Hitler? When did this meeting take place? What did many Germans who worked in the film industry do after the Nazis seized power in 1933? When did Hitler ask Leni Riefenstahl to film the annual Nüremberg rally? What was the name of the first rally film and when was it released? What was the theme of the first rally film? How does this film portray the Nazi Party in 1933? Why was this film withdrawn after 1934? What is the subject matter of Triumph of the Will? How successful was Triumph of the Will? 20 What changes within the Nazi Party are clearly evident in Triumph of the Will? 21 Which Nazi values are communicated in Triumph of the Will? 22 What was the main subject matter of Day of Freedom? 23 How did the Ministry for Propaganda ensure that as many people as possible would see Day of Freedom? 24 Which specific Nazi policies are reflected in Day of Freedom? 25 Who commissioned Olympia? 26 What was the subject matter of Olympia? 27 In what ways did Riefenstahl revolutionise the filming of sporting events in Olympia? 28 To what extent do you think Olympia communicates Nazi ideals? 29 How was Riefenstahl received during her tour of the United States? 30 What controversy is associated with the making of Tiefland? 31 What happened to Riefenstahl after World War II? 32 How does Leni Riefenstahl describe her actions in the 1930s? Concluding section Checklist You should use this checklist to ensure that you understand the Key Features, Concepts and Groups required for your study of Germany 1918–1945. Fast page references are provided for revision of these essential elements of the study. Key features of Germany 1918–1945 • a survey of political, economic and social problems in the period 1918–1923 (pp. 8–18) • characteristics of relative stability in the period 1924–1929 (pp. 18–21) • collapse of the Weimar Republic, 1929–1933 (pp. 22–30) • foundations of the National Socialist German Workers Party or Nazi Party (NSDAP) and its role, structures, policies and impact (pp. 23–9) • roles and impact of conservative parties and élites on the political process (pp. 29–30) • the social, economic and political impact of the Great Depression (p. 20) • Hitler’s accession to power and his role as Führer (pp. 29–32 & 36) Germany 1918–1945 87 • consolidation of Nazi power, 1933–1934 (pp. 33–6) • conformity, dissent and resistance in response to the goal of Volksgemeinschaft (People’s Community) (pp. 36–45) • the transformation of German social and cultural life under Nazism (pp. 46–50) • nature and impact of Nazi propaganda, terror and repression within Germany and in occupied territories (pp. 55–61) • Nazi racial policy, anti-Semitism and the Holocaust (pp. 62–70) • nature of Nazi foreign policy, its aims, strategies and military successes (pp. 70–4) • the Nazi war machine and its implications for the war effort (pp. 74–5) • support for, and opposition to, Nazism on the home front (pp. 41–2) • military defeat and the collapse of Nazism (pp. 75–9). Concepts to be studied in relation to the key features of Germany 1918–1945 • • • • • democracy militarism nationalism racism totalitarianism (all p. 5) Groups to be studied in relation to the key features of Germany 1918–1945 • the Jewish community (pp. 6 & 62–70) • Nazi Party, including the SA and SS (pp. 6, 23–9 & 55–6) • Wehrmacht (German fighting forces 1935–1945) (pp. 6, 41–2 & 74–9) • women (pp. 7 & 46–8) • youth organisations (pp. 7 & 50–5). Resources Books Bracher, K.D., The German Dictatorship, Weidenfeld and Nicolson, New York, 1971. Bullock, A., Hitler: A Study in Tyranny, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, 1962. Carr, W., A History of Germany 1815–1990, Edward Arnold, New York, 1991. Freidlander, S., Nazi Germany and the Jews: Years of Persecution 1933–39, Phoenix Press, London, 1998. Heyes, E., Children of the Swastika, Millbrook Press, Millbrook, CT, 1993. Hiden, J., Republican and Fascist Germany, Addison Wesley Longman, New York, 1996. Kershaw, I., The Hitler Myth: Image and Reality in the Third Reich, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1989. Koonz, C., Mothers in the Fatherland, St Martin’s Press, New York, 1988. Landau, R., Studying the Holocaust, Routledge, New York, 1998. McDonough, F., Opposition and Resistance in Nazi Germany, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2001. Overy, R.J., The Penguin Historical Atlas of the Third Reich, Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, 1996. Shirer, W., The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, Secker and Warburg, New York, 1972. Films and videos Cabaret (film), dir. Bob Fosse, 1972. Europa Europa (film), dir. Agnieszka Holland, 1991. The Nasty Girl (film), dir. Michael Verhoeven, 1989. The Pianist (film), dir. Roman Polanski, 2002. Web support For a full list of relevant websites, exam-style questions and marking guidelines, go to hi.com.au/flashpoints. Hans and Sophie Scholl 88 Flashpoints