Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
PLATINUM v. PANLILO - orders of Judge Diokno did not affect the In 1994, Platinum filed a case before the jurisdiction of the Makati RTC branch 62. RTC for Collection of money against Pan Asiatic and its president, Galvez. The - The stocks to Manila Polo Club Propriety Membership was levied and sold to Ms. Khoo to satisfy the judgement. PR Panlilo filed for a motion to intervene claiming that the stocks were mortgaged by Galvez to him to secure her debt. The RTC denied this motion. The sale was later declared null and void. Galvez and made another attempt to in the first case by incorporating a motion to consolidate. Judge Tensuan (Panlilo Collection) granted the motion on the condition that Judge Diokno (Platinum Collection) consents. Judge Diokno consented. Platinum filed for a petition for certiorari before the CA assailing Judge Diokno’s order. The CA annulled Diokno’s order but left it to Diokno to decide to return Panlilo’s collection suit to Judge Tensuan or decide it. Platinum assails the jurisdiction of the Makati RTC on the ground that the order of Judge Diokno was annulled. WON the Makati RTC has jurisdiction? HELD: decision rendered therein. - Accordingly, where a court has jurisdiction over the person and the subject matter, as in the instant case, the decision on all questions arising from the case is but an exercise of such jurisdiction. Any error that the court may commit in the exercise of its jurisdiction is merely an error of judgment which does Panlilo filed a collection case against intervene Jurisdiction refers to the authority to decide a case, not the orders or the RTC ruled in favor of Platinum. YES. The fact that the CA annulled the not affect its authority to decide the case, much less divest the court of the jurisdiction over the case.