Download 13750_2015_48_MOESM8_ESM

Additional File 7: Critical appraisal scores
Project Project Name
Number
Citation
Clear and
Methodology
repeatable
relevant
methodology
Data consistent Sample size
with
appropriate
methodology
Sampling frame Confounding
specified
factors
accounted for
Overall score
1
Mucuna-maize
cropping
project, Sahcaba
(no formal
project name
given)
Eastmond, A. & Faust, B. (2008)
Farmers, fires, and forests: a green
alternative to shifting cultivation
for conservation of the Maya
forest? Landscape and Urban
Planning: 74: 267-284.
1
1
1
1
1
0
5 - Medium
2
Pro Manejo
(The Amazon
Sustainable
Forest
Management
Support
Project)
(1) Bauch, S.C., Sills, E.O. &
Pattanayak, S.K. (2014) Have we
managed to integrate conservation
and development? ICDP impacts in
the Brazilian Amazon. World
Development: 64: S135-S148.
1
1
1
1
1
1
6 - High
2
Pro Manejo
(The Amazon
Sustainable
Forest
Management
Support
Project)
(2) Weber, J.G., Sills, E.O., Bauch, S.
& Pattanayak, S.K. (2011) Do
ICDPs work? An empirical
evaluation of forest-based
microenterprises in the Brazilian
Amazon. Land economics: 87: 661681.
1
1
1
1
1
1
6 - High
3
Introduction of
Liquid
Petroleum Gas
(LPG), the
Himalayas (no
formal project
name given)
Nautiyal, S. (2011) Can
conservation and development
interventions in the Indian Central
Himalaya ensure environmental
sustainability? A socioecological
evaluation. Sustainability Science:
6: 151-167.
0
1
1
1
1
0
4 - Medium
4
Eco-Escuela de
Espanol
Langholz, J. (1999) Exploring the
Effects of Alternative Income
Opportunities on Rainforest Use:
Insights from Guatemala's Maya
Biosphere Reserve. Society &
Natural Resources: 12: 139-149.
1
1
1
1
1
1
6 - High
5
Management of
Aquatic Systems
through
Community
Husbandry
(MACH)
Mijanur Rahman, Md. And Begum
A. (2011) Implication of livelihood
diversification on wetland
resources conservation: A case
from Bangladesh. Journal of
Wetlands Ecology: 5: 59-65.
0
1
1
1
0
0
3 - Low
6
The Amani
Butterfly
Farming Project
(1) Morgan-Brown, T., Jaconson,
S.K., Wald, K., & Childs, B. (2010)
Quantitative assessment of a
Tanzanian integrated conservation
and development project involving
butterfly farming. Conservation
Biology: 24: 563-572.
1
1
1
1
1
1
6 - High
6
The Amani
Butterfly
Farming Project
(2) Engh, V. (2011) Integrated
Conservation and Development
Projects and Efforts Around the
Amani Nature Reserve Tanzania,
and their effects on livelihoods and
forest conservation. Norwegian
University of Life Sciences.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
7
The Tanga
Small Scale
Dairy Project
2) Engh, V. (2011) Integrated
Conservation and Development
Projects and Efforts Around the
Amani Nature Reserve Tanzania,
and their effects on livelihoods and
forest conservation. Norwegian
University of Life Sciences.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
8
Novella Africa
partnership
2) Engh, V. (2011) Integrated
Conservation and Development
Projects and Efforts Around the
Amani Nature Reserve Tanzania,
and their effects on livelihoods and
forest conservation. Norwegian
University of Life Sciences.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
9
Posada
Amazonas
Ecotourism
Lodge
Stronza, A. (2007) The economic
promise of ecotourism for
conservation. Journal of
Ecotourism: 6:210-221.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
10
Caohai Nature
Reserve and
Community
Development
Herrold-Menzies, M. (2006)
Integrating conservation and
development: What we can learn
From Caohai, China. The Journal of
Environment and Development:
15:382-406.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
11
Iboih Makmur
Cooperative (no
formal project
name given)
Novriyanto., Wibowo, J.T.,
Iskander, W., Campbell-Smith, G. &
Linkie, M. (2012) Linking coastal
community livelihoods to marine
conservation in Aceh, Indonesia:
Oryx: 46: 508-515.
1
1
1
1
1
1
6 - High
12
Pesca Artesanal
Vivencial (PAV)
Galapagos
Marine Reserve
(GMR)
Schuhbauer, A. & Koch, V. (2013)
Assessment of recreational fishery
in the Galapagos Marine Reserve:
Failures and opportunities.
Fisheries Research: 144: 103-110
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
13
Cham Island
MPA
(no formal
project name
given)
Brown, L. Marine protected areas,
co-management and livelihoods:
Coastal change in Vietnam.
University of Sydney
1
1
1
0
0
0
3 - Low
14
Fuel Efficient
Stoves (FES) in
the Juniper
forests of
Balochistan
Musakhe, M.Y.J., Abdul; Tareen, R.
B.; Bazai, Z. A. (2007) An
evaluation study of impact of fuel
efficient stove on Juniper
(Juniperus excelsa) Tract,
Balochistan. International Journal
of Biology and Biotechnology: 4:
51-55
0
0
0
0
0
0
0 - Excluded
15
Pride Campaign
(no formal
project name
given)
DeWan, A., Green, K., Li, X., &
Hayden, D. (2013) Using social
marketing tools to increase fuelefficient stove adoption for
conservation of the golden snubnosed monkey, Gansu Province,
China. Conservation Evidence:
2013: 32-36.
1
1
1
1
0
1
5 - Medium
16
Seaweed
farming,
Philippines (no
formal project
name provided)
Hill, N,A.O., Rowcliffe, J.M.,
Koldeway, H.J., & Milner-Gulland,
E.J. (2011) The interaction
between seaweed farming an
alternative occupation and fisher
numbers in the central Philippines.
Conservation Biology: 26 (2): 324334.
1
1
1
1
1
1
17
Sasan Gir
National Park
and Sanctuary India EcoDevelopment
Project
Varma, K. (2009) The Asiatic Lion
and the Maldharis of Gir Forest: An
assessment of an Indian EcoDevelopment. The Journal of
Environment and Development: 18:
154-175.
1
1
1
0
0
0
3 - Low
18
Tres Reyes
Parrot Project
(no formal
project name
given)
Martinez-Reyes, J.E. (2014)
Beyond Nature Appropriation:
Towards post-development
conservation in the Maya Forest.
Conservation & Society. 12: 2.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
19
Tres Reyes
Butterfly
Project
(no formal
project name
given)
Martinez-Reyes, J.E. (2014)
Beyond Nature Appropriation:
Towards post-development
conservation in the Maya Forest.
Conservation & Society. 12: 2.
1
1
1
0
0
0
3 - Low
20
Coral Reef
Rehablitation
and
Management
Program
Brock, A. (2013) Beyond fishing?
The impact of microcredit on
alternative livelihoods in South
Sulawesi, Indonesia. Nicholas
School of the Environment of Duke
University.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
21
Integrated
Conservation
and
Development at
Bwindi
Impenetrable
and Mgahinga
Gorilla National
Parks
Blomley, T., Namara, A., McNeilage,
A., Franks, P., Rainer, H.,
Donaldson, A., Malpas, R., Olupot,
W., Baker, J., Sandbrook, C.,
Bitariho, R. and Infield, M. (2010)
Development and gorillas?
Assessing fifteen years of
integrated conservation and
development in south-western
Uganda. Natural Resources Issues
No. 23. International Institute for
Environment and Development.
1
1
1
1
0
0
4 - Medium
22
Betel leaf and
nut farming of
the Khasia
indigenous
People in
Bangladesh (no
formal project
name given)
Islam, Md.J. and Nath, T.N. (2014)
Forest-based betel leaf and betel
nut farming of the Khasia
indigenous People in Bangladesh:
approach to biodiversity
conservation in Lawachara
National Park (LNP). Journal of
Forestry Research: 25: 419-427.
1
1
1
1
1
0
5 - Medium