Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the workof artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
| W h at t o E x p e c t f r o m D o n G i ova n n i What is Don Giovanni? Moz art called it an “oper a buffa ,” a comic opera. His librettist, Lorenzo Da Ponte, preferred “dramma giocoso,” a playful drama. Don Giovanni certainly is funny, but also deadly serious; rational, but also supernatural; sensuous but, at the same time, a cautionary moral tale—in short, it is one of the most complex and fascinating operas in the repertoire. The same could be said for its title hero—a character that audiences, scholars, and artists have discussed for more than two centuries. He is a nobleman and a rake. He is the voice of a new Age of Reason, but he also embodies sin. Is he a great lover or a cheap skirt-chaser? Does he embody liberty or license? “Don Giovanni has a charismatic lust for life, but he’s not just some serial seducer; he’s a dark, complex individual,” says Tony Award-winning director Michael Grandage, who makes his Metropolitan Opera debut with this new production. “In the portrayal of this central character, we need somebody who is able to show many layers.” Baritone Mariusz Kwiecien has won international acclaim for his performance of the role and now brings it to the Met for the first time. He heads an extraordinary cast that also includes Marina Rebeka, Barbara Frittoli, Mojca Erdmann, Ramón Vargas, Luca Pisaroni, Štefan Kocán, and Joshua Bloom. The Met’s principal conductor Fabio Luisi conducts. Through the activities in this guide, your students will encounter the many sides of Don Giovanni—both the opera and its protagonist. They will consider the work within the context of the political and philosophical excitement of 18th-century Europe, and they’ll examine the words, deeds, and moral character of its title character. By familiarizing your students with the themes and music of Don Giovanni, the guide offers an easily accessible introduction to this Mozart masterpiece. No matter whether this is a young person’s first or tenth opera, the activities contained in the following pages will enhance the experience of this Met: Live in HD presentation. The Work DON GIOVANNI (Don Juan ) Opera in two acts, sung in Italian Music by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756–1791) Libretto by Lorenzo Da Ponte First performed on October 29, 1787, at the National Theater (now called the Estates Theater), Prague PRODUCTION Fabio Luisi, Conductor Michael Grandage, Production Christopher Oram, Set and Costume Design Paule Constable, Lighting Design Ben Wright, Choreography STARRING (in order of appearance) Luca Pisaroni Leporello (bass) Marina Rebeka Donna Anna (soprano) Mariusz Kwiecien Don Giovanni (baritone) Štefan Kocán The Commendatore (bass) Ramón Vargas Don Ottavio (tenor) Barbara Frittoli Donna Elvira (soprano) Mojca Erdmann Zerlina (soprano) Joshua Bloom Masetto (baritone) Production a gift of the Richard and Susan Braddock Family Foundation, and Sarah and Howard Solomon KWIECIEN REBEKA FRITTOLI VARGAS Additional funding from Jane and Jerry del Missier, and Mr. and Mrs. Ezra K. Zilkha 1 | The guide includes four types of activities. Reproducible student resources for the activities are available at the back of this guide. CLASSROOM ACTIVITY: a full-length activity, designed to support your ongoing curriculum MUSICAL HIGHLIGHTS: opportunities to focus on excerpts from Don Giovanni to enhance familiarity with the work PERFORMANCE ACTIVITIES: to be used during The Met: Live in HD transmission, calling attention to specific aspects of this production POST-SHOW DISCUSSION: a wrap-up activity, integrating the Live in HD experience into students’ views of the performing arts and humanities A G u i d e t o D o n G i ova n n i The activities in this guide address several aspects of Don Giovanni: • The political and moral themes of the work • Its context as a work of the European Enlightenment • The rich interplay of Mozart and Da Ponte’s characters • The production as a unified work of art, involving creative decisions by the artists of the Metropolitan Opera The guide is intended to cultivate students’ interest in Don Giovanni whether or not they have any prior acquaintance with opera. It includes activities for students with a wide range of musical backgrounds, seeking to encourage them to think about opera—and the performing arts in general—as a medium of entertainment and as creative expression. | The Story Overture The Overture is in two segments. The first, in a minor key, is a dark foreshadowing of the scene at the banquet in Act II when the Commendatore (in the form of a statue) comes to dine with Don Giovanni. The second segment, in a major key, is a traditional allegro which is bright and cheerful. For a complete description of the Overture, see Musical Highlight Drama or Comedy? It’s all in the Overture! on page 31. Act I Seville, mid-18th century. Leporello, Don Giovanni’s servant, is complaining about his master as he keeps watch at night outside the palace of the Commendatore, a nobleman. Suddenly, the Commendatore’s daughter, Donna Anna, comes running out of the building, struggling with Giovanni, who is wearing a mask. She has found him hiding in her room but has resisted his approaches and now wants to know his identify. Alerted by his daughter’s cries, the elderly Commendatore appears. He challenges the masked stranger to a duel and is killed. Giovanni and Leporello escape. Anna asks her fiancé, Don Ottavio, to avenge her father’s death. Mariusz Kwiecien as Don Giovanni Photo: nick heavican / metropolitan opera The following morning, Giovanni directs his attentions toward another woman who is traveling alone. The tables turn, however, when the woman proves to be looking for him. She is Donna Elvira, who had been seduced and then abandoned Common Core ELA College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Reading: Grades 6–12 away, leaving Leporello to distract Elvira. Leporello explains to her that she is neither Integration of Knowledge and Ideas the first nor the last woman to fall victim to his master and shows her a catalogue 9. Analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics in order to build knowledge or to compare the approaches the authors take. Giovanni and Leporello run into the wedding party of two young peasants, Responding to Literature 11. Respond to literature by employing knowledge of literary language, textual features, and forms to read and comprehend, reflect upon, and interpret literary texts from a variety of genres and a wide spectrum of American and world cultures. National Center for History in the Schools Historical Thinking Standards for Grades 5–12 by Giovanni in another city and is deeply unhappy about his betrayal. Giovanni slips with the names of the 2,064 other women Giovanni has seduced. Zerlina and Masetto. Giovanni offers to provide a grand feast and tells Leporello to escort the groom, Masetto, to his palace. Masetto balks at first, but eventually complies, leaving Giovanni alone to flirt with his bride. He tells Zerlina that she is destined for a better life and promises to marry her. Just as he is on the verge of successfully seducing Zerlina, Elvira appears, denouncing Giovanni and leading Zerlina off to safety. Giovanni complains about his bad day when Anna and Ottavio appear. They ask for his help in their mission of revenge, unaware that the masked man who killed Anna’s father is Giovanni himself. Elvira returns, continuing her denunciation of Giovanni, who in turn Standard 1: Chronological Thinking tries to convince Anna and Ottavio that Elvira is mad. As soon as E. Interpret data presented in time lines and create time lines. Giovanni has left, Anna realizes that his was the voice of the man in her bedroom—Giovanni is her father’s murderer. She again asks F. Reconstruct patterns of historical succession and duration; explain historical continuity and change. Ottavio to avenge her, as he wonders how to restore her happi- Standard 2: Historical Comprehension but that Zerlina arrived there too, accompanied by the angry F. Appreciate historical perspectives. 2 Victor Maurel was a celebrated Don Giovanni at the Met in the 19th century. ness. Leporello tells his master that he took Masetto to his palace, 3 VOICE TYPE Since the early 19th century, singing voices have usually been classified in six basic types, three male and three female, according to their range: SOPRANO the highest-pitched type of human voice, normally possessed only by women and boys forward to an evening of dancing and drinking. Masetto has come to Giovanni’s palace to find Zerlina, who asks his forgiveness for having fallen for Giovanni’s charms. Masetto hides as Giovanni appears and resumes his flirtatious talk with Zerlina. When Giovanni spots the groom he scolds him for leaving his bride alone, then escorts them both back to the party. Elvira, Anna, and Ottavio arrive wearing masks. Prompted by Giovanni, Leporello invites them in, unaware of their identity. In the ballroom, Leporello distracts Masetto as Giovanni yet again attempts to seduce Zerlina. She cries out. Giovanni tries to pin the seduction on Leporello, but this time he’s been caught. Elvira, Anna, and Ottavio take off their masks and MEZZO-SOPRANO confront him at last. the female voice whose range lies between the soprano and the contralto (Italian “mezzo” = middle, medium) Act II Leporello tries to convince his master to abandon his pursuit of women, but CONTRALTO Giovanni insists that he needs them more than air or food. Now he has his eye on Elvira’s servant girl. To accomplish her seduction, he convinces Leporello to switch the lowest female voice, also called an alto clothes with him. Giovanni calls out to Elvira’s window. When she comes down, the TENOR Elvira’s maid. His song is interrupted by Masetto, leading a posse to find his bride’s the highest naturally occurring voice type in adult males seducer. Still pretending to be Leporello, Giovanni sends the men off in various BARITONE Costume sketch for Donna Elvira by Christopher Oram Elvira. He says that managed to lock out Elvira and lock in Zerlina. Giovanni looks disguised Leporello leads her off for a walk, leaving Giovanni free to serenade directions, then beats up Masetto and hurries off. Zerlina finds her bruised bridegroom and comforts him. Leporello is still with Elvira, baffling her with his insistence that they stay in the shadows. He manages to slip away just as Anna and Ottavio appear, but is then surprised by the arrival of Zerlina and Masetto. All four believe him to be Giovanni and are ready to punish him, except for Elvira who now, her love restored, defends him. Fearing for his life, Leporello reveals his true identity, which causes Zerlina to accuse him of beating up Masetto, while Elvira charges him with deceit and seduction. Leporello manages to escape. Ottavio proclaims his resolve to take revenge on Giovanni. Elvira is torn between a yearning for retribution and her renewed love for her seducer. the male voice lying below the tenor and above the bass Giovanni and Leporello find each other hiding in the graveyard. As he laughs over BASS statue on the Commendatore’s grave. Unflinching, Giovanni forces the terrified the lowest male voice Leporello to invite the statue to his palace for dinner. The statue accepts. his adventures of the night, a strange voice scolds him. It comes from the marble Ottavio, anticipating that Giovanni will soon be brought to justice, is satisfied, but Anna, who is still mourning her father, can’t share his sense of resolution. Ottavio accuses her of not loving him. Indeed she does, she replies, but he must be patient until time can heal her wounds. Giovanni is enjoying dinner at his palace, with Leporello serving and musicians playing. Elvira enters, in love, not in anger, and makes a last desperate attempt to convince Giovanni to change his life and make amends. He laughs at her. Exasperated, she leaves but moments is heard screaming in terror. Giovanni sends Leporello to investigate. A fearful knocking is heard—the statue has come to dinner. The marble Commendatore demands that Giovanni repent. He refuses: He will bow to no man, alive or dead. When the statue extends its hand, Giovanni coolly offers his own and is dragged down to hell. Elvira, Anna, Ottavio, Zerlina, Masetto, and Leporello contemplate their future and the fate of an immoral man. 4 5 | w h o ’ s w h o i n d o n g i ova n n i CHARACTER New Findings, New Ideas As a work of the European Enlightenment, written in the late 18th century, Don Giovanni stands at the end of a long historical process. A hundred years earlier, intellectual thought in Europe was still organized around the Christian faith. The understandings of nature were rooted in the descriptions of creation found in the Bible. Kings, queens—and their subjects—believed that the royal right to govern came directly from God. But by the dawn of the 18th century—80 years before Mozart wrote Don Giovanni—new findings about the world had begun to weaken confidence in those longheld beliefs. The seeds of this change were planted even earlier, during the explorations of the 16th century. When Europe’s kings and queens sent competing expeditions westward across the oceans, they were hoping to find speedier routes to the riches of the Orient, first discovered by overland expeditions. Instead, their ships came upon the Americas—two continents whose very existence had never been suspected, let alone that of their 6 flora and fauna. Soon plans were laid to exploit these newfound mineral, agricultural, and human resources. Over the course of the 17th century, Spain, Portugal, Holland, England, and France all claimed regions in this New World as colonies. Around the same time, philosophers like René Descartes in France and Benedict Spinoza in Holland were re-examining old perspectives on the nature of the universe. Their yardsticks were logic, reason, and a kind of optimistic doubt, not religious faith. In England, Francis Bacon introduced the method of scientific examination, a new way of finding the truth based not on scripture, but on experiment and observation. Before long, the tools of reason were being used to examine not only the natural world, but the social world as well. Political thinkers like François-Marie Arouet, known as Voltaire, in France, Jean-Jacques Rousseau in Switzerland, and, in England, Thomas Hobbes, David Hume, and John Locke, voiced the possibility that royalty and class systems were not part of the natural order. They proposed, contrarily, that all people come into the world with “natural” rights—especially a right to liberty. These rights might be masked or distorted, reinforced or weakened, defended or denied by the rules, structures, and class systems of society, but they could not be eliminated. Such views would lead, by the end of the 18th century, to a war of independence in England’s American colonies and a revolution, deposing the royalty, in France. By the end of the 18th century, the British-American writer Thomas Paine would refer to his era as “The Age of Reason.” Today, this historic intellectual upheaval is more often called the European Enlightenment. New ideas were in the air, in penny newspapers and in the coffee houses frequented by men like Mozart and Da Ponte. Churches and monarchs were still powerful across Europe. But democracy was on the rise. Aristocrats could be made the butt of Mozart’s jokes; peasants like Masetto and Leporello could pronounce his wisdom; and Don Giovanni could defy the authority even of a miraculously talking marble statue. Pronunciation VOICE TYPE THE LOWDOWN Don Giovanni A nobleman whose entire life is built around seducing women donn joe-VAHN-nee Baritone Giovanni is notorious as a seducer but ultimately goes to hell because he killed a man. Leporello Don Giovanni’s faithful servant leh-po-REL-low Bass Leporello provides both comic relief and commonsense moral commentary. Donna Elvira A noble woman from another city DON-nah el-VEE-ra Soprano Elvira is both Giovanni’s nemesis and the only character in the opera who really cares about him. The Commendatore An old nobleman co-men-da-TOE-ray Bass Killed in the opera’s first scene, the Commendatore returns in the finale as a living statue. Donna Anna The Commendatore’s daughter, Don Ottavio’s fiancée, and an adversary of Don Giovanni DON-nah AHN-nah Soprano Did Anna refuse Giovanni’s advances before the opera begins, or did she succumb? Critics have debated the point for decades. Don Ottavio Donna Anna’s fiancé donn oh-TAH-vee-oh Tenor Ottavio is honest, well-meaning, and somewhat dull. Zerlina A peasant girl, Masetto’s bride dzair-LEE-na Soprano The naive Zerlina is the only character who comes close to getting caught up in Giovanni’s web. Masetto Zerlina’s fiancé and later husband mah-ZET-toe Bass Though Masetto sees through Giovanni’s schemes, his low social status prevents him from effectively opposing the nobleman. 7 | c l a s s r o o m ac t i v i t y A Lot of “Light” Music: A Close Look at the Influence of the European Enlightenment on Mozart and Don Giovanni A comic opera about a serial seducer may seem an unlikely place to look for ideas that reshaped Western thought and culture over the course of the 18th century— but such ideas continually surface in Don Giovanni. Mozart and Da Ponte’s titular The 400-Year-Old Man Whether it’s Mozart and Da Ponte’s Italian-speaking Don Giovanni, the original Spaniard Don Juan, or any of his incarnations in Russian, Latin, German, English, or French—this character has fascinated audiences and readers for almost 400 years. Literary historians believe that the first Don Juan story was published in Spain around 1630. It’s a play written by Tirso de Molina, and its title summarizes the plot that would persist for centuries: El Burlador de Sevilla y Convidado de Piedra—“The Trickster of Seville and the Stone Guest.” Around the same time, a better known Spanish author, Miguel de Cervantes—creator of Don Quixote—turned Don Juan into a troubled but honest bridegroom in a story called “La Gitanilla,” or “The Little Gypsy Girl.” But the rake was back to his old tricks in 1643’s Latin version by Paolo Zehentner. Only a dozen years later, in 1665, the great French dramatist Molière put Don Juan on stage in Dom Juan, ou Le Festin de Pierre (“Don Juan, or the Feast with the Stone”). Molière’s depiction of the character was considered so blasphemous that the play closed after only 15 performances. It would not be mounted again for more than a century. By that time, Don Juan had made his Italian theatrical debut in Carlo Goldoni’s Don Giovanni Tenorio, An old engraving of Don Giovanni and the statue of the Commendatore anti-hero begins the opera by killing a man; he ends it en route to hell. And yet ossia Il Dissoluto (“Don Juan Tenorio, or the Dissolute One”), written in 1736, as well as his Viennese ballet debut in a 1761 piece with music by Christoph Willibald Gluck. Soon thereafter, he arrived in opera houses as a direct descendant of Goldoni’s character: Don Giovanni Tenorio o sia Il Convitato di Pietra (“Don Juan Tenorio, or the Stone Guest”), with music by Giuseppe Gazzaniga and words by Giovanni Bertati. Their work premiered in February 1787, only months before Mozart’s opera, which used Bertati’s libretto as one of its primary sources. Mozart’s Don Giovanni won the hearts of artists throughout 19th-century Europe. Avowedly inspired by him, E.T.A. Hoffman brought Don Juan back to short fiction in an 1813 German version. Lord Byron, the British Romantic, published the first verses of his epic Don Juan in 1819, then kept adding to it through the five remaining years of his life. Byron’s Don Juan was no seducer, but rather the serial victim of a long line of lusty women. Alexander Pushkin, Russia’s national poet, included Don Juan in a set of short plays entitled “Small Tragedies,” published in 1830. (Notably, Pushkin’s The Stone Guest was accompanied by another one-act called Mozart and Salieri.) A new Spanish Don Juan Tenorio, by Jose Zorilla, appeared in 1844. Then in 1861, the French poet of lust and sensuality, Charles Baudelaire, extended the scope of the legend to Don Juan aux Enfers, or “Don Juan in Hell.” “Don Juan in Hell” would also be the title—and subject—of the first 20th-century meditation on this theme: a lengthy scene in the middle of George Bernard Shaw’s 1903 play Man and Superman. (Shaw’s Don Juan provides a touchstone for the post-show discussion, see page 33). By now the character had become so deeply ingrained in the universal cultural consciousness that even fictional people could write about him: In Gaston Leroux’s 1910 novel The Phantom of the Opera, the Phantom himself creates an opera entitled Don Juan Triumphant. the philosophical principles embodied in, and sometimes parodied by, this opera caused such different intellectuals as the Danish philosopher Søren Kierkegaard and the Irish playwright George Bernard Shaw to lavish praise on both the work and its protagonist. Kierkegaard believed that Don Giovanni marvelously depicted the darker sides of human nature. Shaw considered Giovanni himself a powerful life force, a model for modern men. How might someone as badly behaved as Don Giovanni merit any praise at all? In this two-session activity, students will •become acquainted with key ideas of the European Enlightenment •assess commonalities and differences in Enlightenment thought •place Mozart, Da Ponte, and the world they knew in the broader context of Western history •evaluate the composer and librettist’s intentions in key scenes and statements In Prepar ation For this activity, students will need the reproducible resources available at the back of this guide. You will also need to prepare a set of index cards, each bearing one of the 14 statements found on the reproducible A Lot of “Light” Music. The audio selections for this activity are available online or on the accompanying CD. Curriculum Connections Social Studies (World history)/ Philosophy (the European Enlightenment) Language Arts (Authors’ perspective on their characters) found in Don Giovanni •express personal interpretations of scenes and characters, citing specific evidence •apply the social thought reflected in Don Giovanni to fictional and current-events situations For background on the European Enlightenment, also known as the Age of Reason, see the sidebar New Findings, New Ideas, on page 6. STEPS The title character of Mozart and Da Ponte’s opera can hardly be described as anything but irresponsible and selfish. But his creators provided numerous indications that they held a more complicated view of their protagonist. He is, at the very least, an incurable optimist. Though the audience never actually sees him successful at seduction, he remains cheerfully prepared to try, and try again. He is fearless, too, especially when confronting the supernaturally animated statue of the Commendatore in Act II. He may even be honorable at the start of Act I, when he accepts the living Commendatore’s challenge to duel: Although the result is interpreted as murder, Don Giovanni may only have been following an old-fashioned nobleman’s sense of duty. Learning Objectives •To become familiar with concepts developed during the era of the European Enlightenment that shape contemporary thinking •To explore ways in which these concepts influence the plot and characters of Don Giovanni •To practice critical thinking by interpreting characters’ speech and behaviors, as well as the intentions of the creators of these characters •To assess the complex nature of the opera’s title character •To become familiar with the relationships, ideas, and controversies embedded in Don Giovanni The complexities found in the story of Don Giovanni are largely due to the time of its creation—an era of great intellectual turmoil that eventually was to lead to the American and French Revolutions. In this two-session activity, students will discover ideas that are often taken for granted in the 21st century, but were brand new in Mozart’s day—ideas that inform the actions, the personal relationships, and the moral codes of characters in Don Giovanni. 8 9 Instructional Summary Session 1 Seeing the World Anew 1Build a timeline placing Mozart, Da Ponte, and Don Giovanni in the context of historical events. 2Introduce Mozart as a historical figure, influenced by the times he lived in. 3Discuss a set of key concepts from the European Enlightenment and assess them in terms of the categories individual liberty and social control. S e s s i o n 1: Seeing the World Anew period is called the Age of Discovery. By the 18th century, these discoveries led to Step 1: Begin the lesson by providing students with a graphic representation of a kind of information explosion, the Age of Enlightenment. Scholars began to argue Mozart’s times. Draw a line on the board and divide it into six equal sections, with a that through careful observation and the application of reason—and only through little bit extra at each end, then label it as follows: this—humans could come to understand the universe. This was the beginning of | 1500 | 1600 | 1700 | 1800 modern science. Enlightenment thinkers took nothing on faith. Immanuel Kant, the | 1900 2000 Have students add the following events to the timeline. Some will be more challenging to place than others. Students may have to guess at some of these dates. Don’t be afraid to correct them. This is simply an orienting activity. •Today (2011) 4Imagine a “hero” embodying such complicated values. •Columbus comes to the Americas (1492) Session 2 Don Giovanni: Villain, Hero, or Both? •Isaac Newton discovers gravity (1687) 5Review concepts from Session 1. •Oxygen is discovered by Joseph Priestley (1774) •The Pilgrims come to North America (1620) •Johann Sebastian Bach praises a new musical instrument called the piano (1747) •Benjamin Franklin proposes the idea that lightning is electricity (1750) 6Assess scenes from Don Giovanni in terms of individual liberty and social control. •The Declaration of Independence is signed (1776) 7Examine Mozart and Da Ponte’s intentions: What is the message of Don Giovanni? •The French Revolution begins (1789) 8Consider contemporary controversies involving the same central concerns, including individual liberty and social control. were beginning to visit faraway parts of the globe like the Americas and China. This •Hydrogen is discovered by Antoine Lavoisier (1783) •The U.S. Constitution is ratified (1788) •Toussaint L’ouverture sparks a slave rebellion that leads to the free state of Haiti (1791) Notice how many of these dates hover close to 1800. The point of this preliminary exercise is to show students what a busy, productive time the late 18th century was—a time of new ideas in science and politics, a time when liberty and equality became an important concept in societies that had long been ruled by absolute monarchs. Add one more date to the timeline: 1787. Don Giovanni had its premiere that year in Prague, in central Europe. Mozart and Da Ponte were living and working in the middle of the era of the European Enlightenment. The thinking of the times came as naturally to them as thoughts of protecting the environment or social networking might come to your students today. Explain to your students that you’ll return to Mozart and Don Giovanni during German philosopher, may have expressed these views best when he wrote, “Dare Common Core ELA College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Reading: Grades 6–12 Integration of Knowledge and Ideas 9. Analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics in order to build knowledge or to compare the approaches the authors take. to think!” Responding to Literature While many Enlightenment thinkers explored the physical world, including the 11. Respond to literature by employing knowledge of literary language, textual features, and forms to read and comprehend, reflect upon, and interpret literary texts from a variety of genres and a wide spectrum of American and world cultures. fields of chemistry, biology, geography, and astronomy, others focused on relationships in human society. Those are the thinkers who most influenced Mozart and Da Ponte. The balance of this lesson is designed to help students develop a general sense of the views these scholars developed with respect to individual rights and the life of communities. See sidebar New Findings, New Ideas on page 6. Step 3: In this part of the lesson, students will consider a number of fundamental statements made in the period of the Enlightenment. Students may be surprised to learn that it was not until the 18th century that philosophers began to advocate the notions of civil rights and governance that inspire most people today. They may be even more surprised that such ideas would be reflected in an opera. A central idea of the Enlightenment was that social authority comes from the National Center for History in the Schools Historical Thinking Standards for Grades 5–12 Standard 1: Chronological Thinking E. Interpret data presented in time lines and create time lines. F. Reconstruct patterns of historical succession and duration; explain historical continuity and change. people being governed. No god or supernatural power chooses human leaders. But Standard 2: Historical Comprehension thinkers differed as to the question of “human nature”—notably, whether people F. Appreciate historical perspectives. were inherently cooperative and peaceful or selfish and violent. This resulted in different viewpoints on liberty and authority. Some Enlightenment thinkers supported individual liberty, no matter what. Some supported such liberty only as long as one person’s liberty did not infringe on the rights of others. Others, more worried about people’s selfish tendencies, emphasized the need for authority and social control. On the reproducible A Lot of “Light” Music on page 37, you will find 14 statements paraphrased from the writings of Enlightenment thinkers. During the next exercise, students will consider each of these statements and decide for themselves which of these two broad concerns the “speaker” is emphasizing—individual liberty or social control. the next class session, but for now, you’re going to get to know the ideas that were floating around Europe the night Don Giovanni had its premiere. Step 2: Use the events on the timeline to help your students understand the spirit of the European Enlightenment. In the 15th, 16th, and 17th centuries, Europeans 10 11 Prepare a set of cards, each bearing one of the statements on the reproducible A (You may want to point out to the class that such reasoned debate and democratic Lot of “Light” Music. (You may want to glue a copy of the reproducible to a piece of decision-making were important outcomes of Enlightenment thought.) cardboard, then cut it into cards.) Record the statement in the appropriate column on the chart. (Feel free to use the Draw two columns on a chalkboard, whiteboard, or sheet of poster paper, one short summary found in parentheses after the statement itself. You may also want to labeled “Individual Liberty,” the other labeled “Social Control.” (You will need this list the name of the thinker associated with that statement.) Then go on to the next chart for the next class session, so make sure it won’t be erased overnight.) group of students. If you like, give students their own copies of the reproducible A Divide the class into groups of two or three, and give each group one of the 14 cards. Lot of “Light” Music so they can keep track of the class’s analysis. Give the groups five to ten minutes to consider their statements and to decide Note: The point of this exercise is to get students to think about the concepts themselves whether the statement stresses individual liberty or social control. of liberty and social control. There are not right or wrong answers about any given Then, group by group: thinker’s place on the “individual liberty” or “social control” side of the chart. Fun Fact: In the dinner •Each group can present the statement they have considered to the rest of the class. •The group should make an argument for placing the statement in the category they chose. Step 4: After all 14 statements have been categorized, students can discuss whether Enlightenment thinkers, all together, were more interested in individual liberty or social control. What do your students think of this dichotomy? How do these values •The rest of the class can offer questions and/or comment on the statement. come into conflict? How do they affect daily life, even today? When might individual •The entire class should vote on the appropriate category for the statement in liberty matter more than social control? When should individual liberty be restricted question: emphasis on individual liberty or emphasis on social control. to protect the community? For example, students might consider such phenomena as •traffic laws •military service •elections •waiting in line at the post office Costume sketch for peasant girls by Christopher Oram •use of controlled substances like alcohol or prescription drugs •websites that oppose government policies FOLLOW-UP For homework, students should make up a story in which individual liberty and social control clash. It can be realistic, science fiction, a superhero story, a romance— whatever each student likes. But each story should involve a situation that prompts readers to think about the pros and cons of each of these values. For instance, a story might involve a skateboarder who rides wildly on the street, inattentive to the danger he’s creating for pedestrians. Another might present a shopper determined to get into a store offering big discounts—and trampling other shoppers in the process. The next class session will begin with a discussion of these stories. 12 Martín y Soler scene near the end of Act II, Mozart played a little joke on his audiences by incorporating three melodies from previously written operas into the music that the stage band plays for Don Giovanni’s entertainment. The first of these is from Martín y Soler’s opera, Una Cosa Rara (“A Rare Thing”) (CD 2, Track 37). Leporello comments “cosa rara” (“a rare thing”), acknowledging the music. The second of these melodies is from Giuseppe Sarti’s opera, Fra i due litiganti il terzo gode (“While two dispute the third enjoys”) (Track 38). Once again, Leporello casually announces the name of the opera from which this tune is taken. Finally, Mozart borrows from himself, a famous tune from his previous opera, Le Nozze di Figaro (“The Marriage of Figaro”), with Leporello commenting, “I’ve heard this once too often.” Knowledgeable opera goers will smile or chuckle as they hear this melody from Figaro in this context (Track 39). 13 S e s s i o n 2: D o n G i ova n n i : V i l l a i n , H e r o, o r B o t h? For context, you may want to review the synopsis of the opera found on page 3, Step 1: In the preceding class session, students were introduced to Enlightenment although it is not necessary that your students be familiar with the plot as they begin thought—in particular, to the concepts of individual liberty and social control. In this the activity. These are simply snapshots from a character’s life. session, students will explore ways Mozart and Da Ponte used to incorporate these concepts into Don Giovanni. Go around the room and have students briefly describe the stories they wrote for homework. • Who is the protagonist? • What is the conflict between individual liberty and social control? • How is it resolved? • Does the protagonist prove to be a hero? Step 2: The problem students grappled with in their writing assignment is precisely the problem that critics have long grappled with over Don Giovanni: For better or worse, the character who gives the opera its name is in constant conflict with the values of his society. Did Mozart and Da Ponte consider Don Giovanni to be a hero, a villain, or something in between? The answer rests on the concepts of individual liberty and social control discussed in the previous session. Review the chart made in the previous session in order to remind students of Step 3: The core of this session is a discussion of six scenes from Don Giovanni. Scene A presents the opening of the opera. Giovanni, fresh from an attempt to seduce Donna Anna, kills her father in a duel. Scenes B and C take place at the wedding of Zerlina and Masetto. Giovanni tries to get Masetto out of the way in order to seduce his bride. Scene D takes place near the end of Act I. This is the only point in the opera at which Mozart and Da Ponte specifically refer to the subject of liberty. Scene E, near the beginning of Act II, finds Leporello, Don Giovanni’s servant, and Giovanni discussing the latter’s attitude toward women. Scene F, at the end of the opera, includes the argument between Giovanni and the statue of the Commendatore, directly preceding Giovanni’s descent into hell. Discussion guides for each scene follow. Texts and translations for the audio clips discussed can be found on the reproducibles A Lot of “Light” Music on pages 38–46. Students should read along in the libretto excerpts as they listen to each scene. Then, after discussing each scene, students will be asked to rate the relative influence of individual liberty and social control ideas in Don Giovanni. They will record their assessments on the reproducible Which Side Are They On? Enlightenment thinking on liberty and social control. These will again be the two Discussing Scene A central themes of the class session. In this session, however, students will try to The Opera: Music and Libretto figure out where Mozart and Da Ponte stood on these critical conflicting values: Track 1 begins with a scream, but the high-energy music that follows doesn’t Is Don Giovanni, the opera, a lesson in the necessity of social control, as indicate fear or danger. In fact, the libretto specifies that the woman who was heard suggested by Hobbes in statement #14 (Pleasure and pain) and Voltaire in state- screaming has the situation well under control. She has a tight grip on a masked ment #6 (Necessary inequality)? man’s arm, singing, “Don’t hope that if you don’t kill me, I will let you escape.” Or is Don Giovanni, the character, a paragon of individual liberty in spite of what, Students may want to guess what’s going on here before you play the next to all other characters (and perhaps to your students too), seem like antisocial excerpt: In Track 2, failing to break loose, the man replies, “Crazy woman! You cry behavior and deep moral flaws? out in vain! You’re not going to find out who I am!” This adds a bit more information, but not much. The tones of their voices and their parallel melodies suggest that this woman and man are social equals. This can be heard even more clearly in Track 3, where, in harmonic lines, they yell at one another and call one another names. The characters are Donna Anna and Don Giovanni. She is obviously angry at him, though we don’t know yet exactly why. Still, even in her fury, their exchange has a quality of romantic banter. 14 15 That changes a few seconds later. In Track 4, the music played by the cellos intro- Both Donna Anna and Don Giovanni seem capable of taking care of themselves, in duces the first sounds of genuine tension into the scene. Then, in Track 5, a new the spirit of arguments for individual liberty such as voice is heard. This is Donna Anna’s elderly father, the Commendatore. He has heard #3 (Locke: The drive to be independent) her scream and has come running to her aid. He challenges the masked man to a #4 (Locke: Natural liberty) duel. Don Giovanni’s tone changes in Track 6. He does not want to fight an old man. But the Commendatore insists. As they argue, a third male voice is heard, Giovanni’s manservant Leporello, who foresees trouble (“I just want to get out of here!”). In Track 7, a beat of silence focuses all attention on Don Giovanni. With both resignation and condescension, he agrees to duel the Commendatore: “Wretch! Wait just a moment if you want to die.” The instrumental stretch that follows provides a musical description of the duel. The outcome is clear from the climax in Track 7, but any doubt disappears in the music heard in Track 8, where Mozart and Da Ponte weave together the old Commendatore’s last words, Don Giovanni’s thoughts on his fatal blow, and Leporello’s commentary on the whole affair. This entire scene can be heard continuously in Track 9. Enlightenment Influences The opera begins with fast-paced moral drama. Some students may resist the challenge to interpret this brief episode through the lens of Enlightenment thought, but point out that Mozart’s acquaintance with Enlightenment thinkers and proposals is well documented. (Interested students may enjoy the reading resources suggested at the end of the activity.) If, in that spirit, you wanted to interpret the scene as influenced by the Enlightenment, what might you find? What do the characters’ actions convey? What message can be drawn from Mozart’s music, where energetic, bantering strings open the scene only to be supplanted by mournful woodwinds? Point out key elements and ask students to consider which of the statements on the reproducible A Lot of “Light” Music might apply: The Commendatore rises to his duty, representing social control, in the spirit of #9 (Locke: Punish when needed) Which Side Are They On? On the reproducible Which Side Are They On?, each student should rate the influence of each of the Enlightenment values, individual liberty and social control, on Mozart and Da Ponte, based on the evidence in this scene. They should also note Costume sketch for Don Giovanni by Christopher Oram which Enlightenment statements apply to this scene. This part of the activity should be repeated after analyzing each scene. Discussing Scene B The Opera: Music and Libretto The next scene brings Don Giovanni and Leporello into a different social setting, the wedding of a peasant couple. His eye on the lovely Zerlina, Don Giovanni has directed his manservant to escort the groom, Masetto, to his palace, ostensibly to celebrate the wedding. Track 10 begins with Masetto’s objection. He doesn’t want to leave his bride alone. Leporello and his master both assure him that Zerlina is safe in the hands of a nobleman like Don Giovanni. In Track 11, the issue of social class is introduced: Zerlina assures Masetto that a nobleman can do her no harm. Masetto remains suspicious, but Don Giovanni cuts their conversation short. In Track 12, he turns on the peasant with a soft, but steely “Watch out!” Students should pay particular attention to the sarcastic, ironic words of Track 13, in which the defeated Masetto comments on the imbalance in his and Giovanni’s social status, then attacks his fiancée Zerlina. Don Giovanni has done something that angers Donna Anna. This is the subject of several statements supporting the concept of social control: #8 (Locke: Do no harm) #9 (Locke: Punish when needed) #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) #11 (Rousseau: Zero tolerance) Whatever Don Giovanni’s offense might have been, it seems to have been the kind of self-centered act that some Enlightenment thinkers saw as natural and unavoidable, in the spirit of #5 (Voltaire: The drive to control) 16 17 Enlightenment Influences Key points in this scene, and Enlightenment viewpoints which may apply to them, Don Giovanni, relentless, promises to marry her in the music heard in Track 18. include: The seduction plays out musically in Tracks 19 to 22, the duet “Là ci darem la Don Giovanni’s unapologetic claim on Zerlina. This certainly embodies a hardheaded position like Voltaire’s in #5 (The drive to control) together with the universal right declared by John Locke in #4 (Natural liberty) mano” (“Let us put our hands together”). As the duet begins, Giovanni and Zerlina’s lines alternate, expressing their thoughts in delicate, decorous four-line verses (Track 19). Their conversation becomes a bit more intimate in Track 20, where they alternate in shorter, one-line bursts. Zerlina at first insists upon her betrothal to Masetto. Giovanni explicitly promises to improve her fortunes. Zerlina is tempted, as depicted by the repetition of her wish that she were made of stronger stuff. Giovanni’s confidence and success, grounded in social status, seem to support As Track 21 begins, Zerlina repeats that wish a third time. Now Mozart and Da Voltaire’s view in Ponte present an intricate play of emotion. Sensing her weakness, Giovanni jumps #6 (Necessary inequality) in without pause, passionately calling upon her to come away with him. Then On the other hand, Rousseau might have argued that Don Giovanni is betraying the he catches himself, and his tone shifts from an insistent plea back to the gentler unspoken commitment of opening tactic of “Là ci darem la mano”—only this time Zerlina responds after one #10 (Agree to be moral) line, not four. Her resolve is wobbling. First, they alternate lines within the verse. The American and French Revolutions put Enlightenment principles of social equality into practice, overturning class relationships that had long organized European Cesare Siepi was a memorable Don Giovanni of the 1950s and 60s. Giovanni’s status as nobleman may not be the guarantee of virtue he has claimed. society. In the encounter of Don Giovanni, Masetto, and Zerlina, Mozart and Da Ponte play on those relationships. Masetto’s protest, then his defeated sarcasm, support the Enlightenment values of #2 (Locke: Equal at birth) #3 (Locke: The drive to be independent) Then they repeat the one-line assertions of Track 20, only now overlapping, without pause, until Zerlina again sings three times, plaintively, “I’m not strong enough!” With Track 22, Giovanni moves to close the deal: “Let’s go!” Zerlina, as if hypnotized, agrees, “Let’s go!” They continue to sing, now in harmony, of their “innocent love.” The seduction would seem a success—until we reach the music heard in Track 23. Out of nowhere, the scorned Donna Elvira appears, denouncing Giovanni. Zerlina is mystified, Elvira will prove to be her guardian angel, and Giovanni is caught between Of course both Don Giovanni and Masetto—and perhaps Zerlina as well—also them. In Track 24, he tries to salvage the situation, then turns on Elvira for spoiling represent the observation of Hobbes in his fun. She, having been in Zerlina’s shoes, is not deterred. #13 (Pleasure and pain) Enlightenment Influences Scene B can be heard, continuous with Scene C, in Track 25. Key points in this scene, and Enlightenment concepts which may apply to them, include: Which side are they on? Don Giovanni’s personality—manipulative in seduction, fierce when caught out by DISCUSSING Scene C Elvira: The Opera: Music and Libretto #4 (Locke: Natural liberty) Moments later, the audience can assess Don Giovanni’s true intentions. As he sings #5 (Voltaire: The drive to control) in Track 14, he is at last alone with Zerlina, free of that “idiot.” That idiot, replies #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) the naïve Zerlina, “is my fiancé!” In Track 15, we finally see Don Giovanni in action #12 (Hobbes: Death and power) as a seducer. He lays it on thick, praising Zerlina and insulting Masetto, laying the #13 (Hobbes: Pleasure and pain) groundwork to convince her, in Track 16, to betray her nuptial vows. Zerlina is more savvy than she might have seemed in Scene B: In Track 17, she makes clear that she is concerned not only about betraying Masetto, but also that 18 19 Elvira’s personality—her fury at Don Giovanni’s behavior past and present, her Enlightenment Influences sense of responsibility toward Zerlina: Key points in this scene, and Enlightenment viewpoints which may apply to them, #1 (Smith: Self-interest) include: #7 (Hume: No judgment) Don Giovanni’s reference to liberty #8 (Locke: Do no harm) #1 (Smith: Self-interest) #9 (Locke: Punish when needed) #4 (Locke: Natural liberty) #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) #11 (Rousseau: Zero tolerance) Zerlina’s capitulation to Giovanni’s seduction: #1 (Smith: Self-interest) #4 (Locke: Natural liberty) #5 (Voltaire: The drive to control) #6 (Voltaire: Necessary inequality) Elvira, Anna, and Ottavio’s reference to generosity #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) Don Giovanni’s welcome of masked guests #2 (Locke: Equal at birth) #7 (Hume: No judgment) Which side are they on? #13 (Hobbes: Pleasure and pain) #14 (Hobbes: Defense from selfishness) Scenes B and C can be heard continuously in Track 25. Which side are they on? Discussing Scene D The Opera: Music and Libretto Halfway through Don Giovanni, Mozart and Da Ponte reprise a bit of stagecraft that seemed incidental in the opera’s opening scene. The beginning of Act I found Don Christopher Oram’s set model for Act II, Scene 4 Photo: Alison Cherry / Metropolitan Opera Giovanni, masked, in the home of Donna Anna. As Act I approaches its climax, his adversaries —Anna, her fiancé Don Ottavio, and Donna Elvira—arrive at Giovanni’s own home, wearing masks themselves. Track 26, the quintet they share with Giovanni and Leporello, highlights the philosophical differences these characters represent. The track begins with Leporello welcoming the guests. He pointedly identifies them as masked. Here Mozart and Da Ponte provide a sharp contrast to the opening scene, in which Giovanni’s mask upset Donna Anna enough to prompt him to say, in Track 2, “You’re not going to find out who I am.” Here, in Track 26, Giovanni does not ask that the masked guests reveal themselves. He declares that his home is open to all, framing this welcome in terms of individual liberty: “Viva la libertà!” Anna, Ottavio, and Elvira, on the other hand, reply in terms of social convention. In Track 27, they thank Giovanni for his generosity—in the view of the Enlightenment, a socially cultivated interpersonal attitude, not a “natural” right like liberty. In other words, despite the cordiality of their words and the dainty grace of their song, the adversaries’ response indicates a worldview different from Giovanni’s. The two sides oppose each other in harmony through Track 28. Scene D can be heard continuously in Track 29. 20 21 Discussing Scene E atmosphere. The rhythm is the same as the opening of the Overture, but instead The Opera: Music and Libretto of minor chords, here they are diminished, creating a more terrifying result (see As this scene begins, in Track 30, Don Giovanni asks Leporello to perform an as yet Musical Highlight Drama or Comedy? It’s all in the Overture! on page 31). After four unspecified service. Leporello, aware of the trouble Don Giovanni has caused him, measures, the Commendatore, in stentorian tones calls out, “Don Giovanni! You asks his master to stop chasing women. Giovanni responds, as might be expected, invited me to supper, and here I am.” It is one of the most chilling effects in all of in Track 31: “Leave women alone? Are you crazy?” Then, in Track 32, he explains opera, as everyone shudders except Don Giovanni himself (Track 34). why—in language that’s surprisingly serious, coming from such a devil-may-care character. Not only does Giovanni call women as necessary to him as food or air, but he justifies his ceaseless pursuit both ethically—were he monogamous, he would be denying his love to many other deserving women—and, in Enlightenment terms, scientifically: Women don’t understand his incalculable capacity to love. Leporello, sarcastic and true to social convention, responds that he has never met anyone with Mozart deploys the full power of the orchestra in Track 35, percussive and so vast and kind a nature. ominous. “Repent!” intones the statue. “Change your life! It’s your last chance!” Scene E can be heard continuously in Track 33. But Don Giovanni responds in Track 36 with equal gravity. He is as passionate here as he has been carefree until now: He will not repent. He will not renounce the Enlightenment Influences life he has led. And so he insists, arguing with the statue throughout Track 37, until, Key points in this scene, and Enlightenment viewpoints which may apply to them, in Track 38, the statue drags Giovanni down to hell. include: Don Giovanni’s philosophy of love #1 (Smith: Self-interest) #6 (Voltaire: Necessary inequality) #7 (Hume: No judgment) #13 (Hobbes: Pleasure and pain) The scene also parodies the Enlightenment’s interest in science and mathematics. See the Musical Highlight Count the Ways, on page 26. Scene F can be heard continuously in Track 39. Enlightenment Influences Key points in this scene, and Enlightenment viewpoints which may apply to them, include: The statue’s demands that Don Giovanni repent #8 (Locke: Do no harm) #9 (Locke: Punish when needed) Leporello’s sarcastic response #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) #8 (Locke: Do no harm) #11 (Rousseau: Zero tolerance) #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) #12 (Hobbes: Death and power) #14 (Hobbes: Defense from selfishness) #14 (Hobbes: Defense from selfishness) Which side are they on? Don Giovanni’s refusal to back off #1 (Smith: Self-interest) Discussing Scene F #3 (Locke: The drive to be independent) The Opera: Music and Libretto #4 (Locke: Natural liberty) Don Giovanni meets his fate in the final scene of the opera. He is hosting another #6 (Voltaire: Necessary inequality) one of his lavish banquets, when at the height of the festivities a knock is heard #7 (Hume: No judgment) at the door. The marble statue of the man he killed at the start of Act I arrives at Giovanni’s home to offer him one last chance to apologize for his actions. Suddenly there is a crash of thunder and powerful chords peal out. Three trombones have a sinister effect and a roll in the timpani adds to the eerie 22 23 Don Giovanni’s punishment FOLLOW-UP: #9 (Locke: Punish when needed) For homework or in class, students should write a persuasive essay on the question #10 (Rousseau: Agree to be moral) “Is Don Giovanni a hero or a villain?” Essays should cite evidence from the opera, #11 (Rousseau: Zero tolerance) based on students’ notes from class discussions of Enlightenment philosophy and #12 (Hobbes: Death and power) the scenes from Don Giovanni. Students may choose to mention their interpreta- Which side are they on? tions of Mozart and Da Ponte’s views of their protagonist, but they should feel free to state their own opinions of Don Giovanni and his victims or adversaries. Step 4: Depending on the quality of the discussions in your classroom up to this point, you may want to conduct a summary discussion reviewing •the concepts of individual liberty and social control •the importance of these concepts in societies moving from monarchy and the “divine right of kings” toward democracy •your students’ interpretations of Mozart and Da Ponte’s views of these principles SUGGESTED READING Students interested in reading about Mozart and the Enlightenment can find an essay on that topic by R.N. Lebow, a professor at Dartmouth University, at www.dartmouth.edu. The opera director Nicholas Till has written an entire volume on the subject, available at most booksellers: Mozart and the Enlightenment (New York: Norton, 1996). Did they believe in radical individual liberty? Did they believe social control Students interested in general reading about the European Enlightenment may was necessary to deter and punish bad behavior? find the works of Enlightenment philosophers to be tough going, but places to start Did they believe there might be a reasonable compromise between individual liberty and social control? include an anthology published by Cambridge University Press, The Enlightenment (Cambridge Readings in the History of Political Thought) or Fordham University’s primary-sources website at www.fordham.edu. This discussion, together with your students’ notes on the reproducible Which Side The historian Peter Gay has written a comprehensive two-volume intellectual Are They On? will provide a basis for the follow-up assignment. history, The Enlightenment, introducing readers to the ideas and debates that characterized the period. An intriguing set of podcasts published by the BBC interprets the Enlightenment in terms of five physical objects (www.bbc.co.uk), while the website of the British Museum in London offers a virtual visit to the museum’s Enlightenment Gallery at www.britishmuseum.org. Finally, an online course on the Enlightenment, featuring texts, pictures, and videos, can be found at openlearn.open.ac.uk. 24 25 | Musical Highlight Count the Ways: A Close Look at the “Catalog” Aria from Act I Musical Highlights are brief opportunities to Don Giovanni has a strong reputation as an incorrigible ladies’ man. It is worth Having rattled off these numbers, Leporello takes a breath, then slows down to noting that audiences have little to rely on but this reputation, for at no point in deliver a kind of scholarly talk on Don Giovanni’s findings on how women differ •help students make sense of opera Mozart’s opera does Giovanni successfully complete a seduction. He’s seen after from group to group: gentle blondes, dependable brunettes, sweet white-haired •whet their interest in upcoming Live in HD transmissions the fact, he’s seen caught by Donna Anna, and he’s seen sweet-talking Zerlina and women; and the sorts of women Giovanni prefers, season by season. His melody Donna Elvira. But most of what opera-goers know about Giovanni’s track record rises dramatically as he describes “majestic” large women, then tip-toes along as his Each focuses on audio selections from Don Giovanni available online at metopera.org/education or the accompanying CD. Texts and translations are available in the back of this guide. These “mini lessons” will in practice take up no more than a few minutes of class time. They’re designed to help you bring opera into your classroom while minimizing interruption of your ongoing curriculum. Feel free to use as many as you like. comes from this aria, sung by Leporello early in Act I. topic turns to the charms of “little ones” (CD 2, Track 5). The Catalog Aria does more than establish Don Giovanni’s amorous bona fides. Leporello ends with a philanthropic justification of his master’s exploits. In CD 2, Leporello also hopes to assuage Donna Elvira’s pain by assuring her that his master Track 6, with placid dignity, he explains how Giovanni engages women young and meant nothing personal by abandoning her—that’s just the way he is. Some critics old, poor and rich, ugly and beautiful alike. As long as they wear skirts, Leporello believe that Mozart and Da Ponte, with the careful counts and categorizations says, they capture the nobleman’s interest. In Track 7, in the spirit of “quod erat displayed verbally in the aria, poke fun at the Enlightenment’s dependence on demonstrandum,” Leporello seems to believe he’s made his case, declaring gravely, detailed observation and demonstrable fact, as if even passion could be quantified over and over, “So you see what he does… as long as they wear skirts…” and sorted out. If he expects this disquisition to appease Donna Elvira, CD 2, Track 8 sets him As Leporello begins, in CD 2, Track 1, it’s immediately clear that this is not an aria straight. Undeterred, she sings, “So that’s the way the scoundrel betrayed me? in which a character talks to himself, expressing inner feelings. This piece is all about That’s the prize with which that barbarian returns my love?” explaining the man Don Giovanni to Donna Elvira. “Look,” Leporello sings, “read The entire Catalog Aria can be heard on CD 2, Track 9. along with me.” The number themselves appear in Track 2: 640 women seduced by If you have time, your students might be interested in looking beyond the Catalog Giovanni in Italy, 231 in Germany, 100 in France, 91 in Turkey, and 1,003 in Spain—a Aria to consider the idea of statistics: how they are used nowadays, for instance in figure Leporello repeats twice to impress it upon Elvira, herself Spanish. Having politics or advertising, to convince people to change their minds. provided a count by nationality, Leporello proceeds, in Track 3, to sort his master’s conquests by social status, by body type, and by age, then repeats the whole set of statistics (Track 4). 26 27 | Musical Highlight | Musical Highlight Another View of Love: A Close Look at Donna Anna’s Aria from Act II Last Words: A Close Look at Don Giovanni’s Final Sextet Through most of Don Giovanni, Mozart and Da Ponte offer a lighthearted view of Throughout Don Giovanni, the title character is on stage almost continuously, until love. Giovanni’s unsuccessful attempts at conquest are depicted in a Romantic, and his descent into hell. The final ensemble that follows Giovanni’s death and brings sometimes comical, fashion. Elvira’s fury dissolves into renewed devotion in the the opera to a close balances its dramatic and humorous aspects one last time. This wake of Giovanni’s sweet talk. The unlucky Masetto provides comic relief. So Donna is similar to an epilogue in a film in which end titles tell the characters’ fates. Each Anna’s “Non mi dir” (“Tell me not”), an aria expressing honest, complex feelings of them announces his or her plans, then they collectively agree that Don Giovanni may come as something of a surprise, especially when sandwiched between two got what he deserved. scenes that are dominated by a walking, talking statue. The scene begins with Elvira, Ottavio, Masetto, and Zerlina, who are then joined Donna Anna sings in response to Don Ottavio, who is gleeful at the prospec- by Donna Anna, demanding that Leporello bring forth his master (CD 2, Tracks tive punishment of Giovanni. Ottavio accuses Anna of cruelty for not marrying 19–21). When the servant recounts his master’s fate, the others realize that they, too, him immediately. Following a brief orchestral introduction, she responds in lyrical saw the Commendatore’s ghost earlier. They all end, together, on a long, sustained sorrow, “Troppo mi spiace” (“I am too upset”) about the death of her father, the note, as if taking a deep breath: This will be the first day of their lives without Don Commendatore (CD 2, Track 10). That she cares deeply about Ottavio is obvious Giovanni (Track 22). in the music heard in Track 11, when she speaks, for the second time, of the happy Little seems to have changed, though, and they quickly revert to form. Ottavio thought of marriage, long awaited by “our soul” (“nostr’alma”), but deferred by “the asks Anna to marry him soon. She asks for another delay (CD 2, Track 23) and world, o God!” (“il mondo, o Dio!”). Love alone, she sings in Track 12, makes Ottavio’s Ottavio, over the course of a brief duet, gives in (Track 24). Elvira announces that case. Careful listeners may detect, however, that Anna’s melody here is in the key of she plans to enter a convent. Zerlina and Masetto announce they’re going home for D minor, associated throughout the opera with the Commendatore: Anna may be in dinner. And Leporello, ever the servant, declares that he’s off to find a new, better love, but she is consumed by mourning for her father. master (Track 25). Their unimaginative but safe futures affirmed, they join vocal Mozart set Donna Anna’s aria in two sections. The first is slow and thoughtful, the forces, bound together by the absent Giovanni, to censure him one last time and, second speedier and more showy. Opera singers of the 18th century expected the while they’re at it, to praise themselves: “And all of us good people, will happily opportunity to shine with such a piece toward the end of a performance. In this case, repeat the ancient song again: This is the end of someone who acts wickedly” Mozart provided a smooth transition from slow to faster. The melody with which the (Track 26). orchestra introduced “Troppo mi spiace” (CD 2, Track 10) returns in Track 13, now The sextet can be heard in its entirety on Track 27. with the lyric “Non mi dir, bell’idol mio”, followed by an assertively rhythmic “che son io crudel con te” (“My love, don’t tell me I am cruel to you”). In Track 14, the vocal line becomes ever more colorful and varied as Donna Anna assures Ottavio of her love. She advises him that his anger might cause her own death (Track 15), then Christopher Oram’s set model for Act I, Scene 5 Photo: Alison Cherry / metropolitan opera reprises key sentiments, elaborating her grief (Track 16). All at once, in CD 2, Track 17, the mood brightens with the transition to a faster tempo. The lyric turns from grief to the hope of a day when “heaven will again have pity” toward Donna Anna, and in the following section Mozart provides the soprano with ample opportunity to display her vocal virtuosity. Students familiar with opera may notice that Donna Anna’s aria is a precursor to the two-part solos that became standard in 19th-century Romantic opera, with an introspective, slower “cavatina” followed by an upbeat “cabaletta.” It’s interesting to consider the ways in which this musical structure reflects true emotional experience. Later composers generally introduced some piece of dramatic action or new information between the two parts, as if to “explain” the change in sentiment. The complete aria, “Troppo mi spiace… Non mi dir” can be heard on Track 18. 28 29 | Musical Highlight | Musical Highlight Three Different Dances at the Same Time: A Close Look at Don Giovanni’s Party Scene Drama or Comedy? It’s all in the Overture! A Close Look at the Overture of Don Giovanni The Act I finale takes place in a ballroom in Don Giovanni’s palace. There are three Don Giovanni is known as a “dramma giocosa” or “humorous drama.” Nowhere is small orchestras on stage, besides the regular one in the pit. Mozart, with his this better illustrated than in the Overture to the opera. ingenious creativity, has given each one of these stage orchestras different dance The Overture starts with foreboding syncopated chords over low, tremolo octaves music to play. Each of these dances was meant for different social strata of guests at in the strings in the dark key of D minor (CD 2, Track 32). (Figure A below) the party, for the classes were not to mix and intermingle at such occasions. This is followed by an insistent dotted rhythm with alternating minor and dimin- The first of these dances is the famous Minuet, a popular 18th-century dance in ished chords in the strings. (Figure B below) 3/4 time (CD 2, Track 28). A syncopated melody in the violins, with the pulses between the beats, increases the tension. (Figure C below) Soon the rarely used melodic minor scale—with its raised 6th and 7th tones ascending and lowered back in its descent—creates an eerie atmosphere (Track 33). These are repeated higher and higher, getting louder in their ascent and softer in their descent. A repetitive dotted rhythm supports these rising and falling scales. The “drama” portion of the Overture abruptly shifts to the brighter, parallel key of D major in a traditional sonata-allegro form with a “giocosa” feel, representing the character of the impetuous pleasure-seeking Don Giovanni (Track 34). This “drama” part of the Overture music will return at the climactic scene near the end of the opera when the statue of the Commendatore accepts Don Giovanni’s Over the minuet music, snippets of conversation are heard by Don Giovanni, offer to dine with him. Here Mozart adds the dark sonority of three trombones for Leporello, and Donna Elvira. As the minuet continues, a second dance is started by the first time in the opera, to create a more dramatic effect (Track 35). another group of guests (Track 29). This dance is a quadrille—a dance for four or When the Commendatore calls out “Don Giovanni,” it is one of the most chilling more even numbered couples in 2/4 time. effects in all of opera. The powerful fortissimo diminished chords, the insistent dotted rhythms, the rising and falling melodic minor scales, all previously heard in the Overture, create a terrifying effect. Soon a fiery pit, representing the gates of hell, opens up. Two pounding timpani and a male unison chorus of spirits from down below intones the horror that awaits Don Giovanni in the inferno (Track 36). In a Finally, a third dance is added to the other two, a waltz (Track 30). This is a traditional final scream of agony, echoed by his servant Leporello, Don Giovanni is swallowed waltz in triple meter. Only a scream by Zerlina, whom Don Giovanni has spirited off up by the netherworld below as downward rushing minor scales accompany his final to another room, puts a sudden halt to the festivities. outcry. A B This dance scene can be heard in its entirety on Track 31. C 30 31 | P e r f o r m a n c e Ac t i v i t y | P o s t- S h o w D i s c u s s i o n Supporting Students During The Met: Live in HD Transmission Don Giovanni in Hell: A Discussion of the Afterlife of Mozart and Da Ponte’s Protagonist Thanks to print and audio recording, much about opera can be enjoyed long before a performance. But performance itself brings vital layers of sound and color, pageantry and technology, drama, skill, and craft. Performance activities are designed to help students tease apart different aspects of the experience, consider creative choices that have been made, and sharpen their own critical faculties. Each Performance Activity incorporates a reproducible activity sheet. Students bring the activity sheet to the transmission to fill out during intermission and/or after the final curtain. The activities direct attention to characteristics of the production that might otherwise go unnoticed. Ratings matrices invite students to express their critique: use these ratings to spark discussions that call upon careful, critical thinking. The basic activity sheet is called My Highs & Lows. Meant to be collected, opera by opera, over the course of the season, this sheet points students toward a consistent set of objects of observation. Its purpose is not only to help students articulate and express their opinions, but to support comparison and contrast, enriching understanding of the art form as a whole. The second activity sheet, Little Boxes, directs students’ attention to the complex, modular set design of this Live in HD production. Your students will need at least three copies of this worksheet, as the set changes numerous times. The Performance Activity reproducibles can be found in the back of this guide. Either activity can provide the basis for class discussion after the transmission. On the next page, you’ll find an activity created specifically for follow-up after the Live in HD transmission. Students will enjoy starting the class with an open discussion of the Met performance. What did they like? What didn’t they? Did anything surprise them? What would they like to see or hear again? What would they have done differently? This discussion will offer students an opportunity to review the notes on their My Highs & Lows sheet—in short, to see themselves as Don Giovanni experts. The character of Don Giovanni has had a long literary life. Students may enjoy considering what aspects of his personality prompted later artists and thinkers to discuss, deconstruct, and re-invent him. Allow them to come up with their own terms to describe Don Giovanni’s personality; these might include: • Sexual prowess • Bad behavior • Charisma • Self-assurance • Refusal to submit to authority • Love of pleasure Then introduce students to one of the most provocative Don Giovanni “sequels,” George Bernard Shaw’s Don Juan in Hell, published at the beginning of the 20th century. (The complete text is available online at the public-domain literature site bartleby.com). As the title suggests, Shaw’s play finds Giovanni in hell, long after the events of the opera. An old woman shows up; she turns out to be Donna Anna, who has died many years later. The hell of Shaw’s play is not a place of fire and pitchforks. It is a place without a sense of time; a moment is like a year. It is a place where no one feels pain, or much of anything. Shaw’s Don Juan complains, “it bores me, bores me beyond description, beyond belief.” He goes on to say: In Prepar ation This activity requires no preparation other than attendance at The Met: Live in HD transmission of Don Giovanni. Curriculum connections Language Arts/Social Studies (Social theory/Philosophy) Learning Objectives •To explore the implications of Don Giovanni’s finale •To review and encourage active attention to the philosophical issues posed by the opera •To consider the re-use of literary tropes and figures in later works Common Core ELA College and Career Readiness Anchor Standards for Reading: Grades 6–12 Integration of Knowledge and Ideas 9. Analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics in order to build knowledge or to compare the approaches the authors take. Responding to Literature 11. Respond to literature by employing knowledge of literary language, textual features, and forms to read and comprehend, reflect upon, and interpret literary texts from a variety of genres and a wide spectrum of American and world cultures. There are no social questions here, no political questions, no religious questions, best of all, perhaps, no sanitary questions. Here you call your appearance beauty, your emotions love, your sentiments heroism, your aspirations virtue, just as you did on earth; but here there are no hard facts to contradict you, no ironic contrast of your needs with your pretensions, no human comedy, nothing but a perpetual romance, a universal melodrama. 32 33 The met: LIve in HD don giovanni Don Giovanni Educator Guide Track List What do your students make of this? • Does hell have to be a place of physical suffering? • Mental suffering? • Plain boredom? • Could hell be different for different people? • Why would this be hell for Don Giovanni? Shaw is making the point that Giovanni’s hell represents the absence of anything he held dear in life. Invite your students to consider what such a hell says about the character. • How does it relate to the Don Giovanni they saw and heard at the Live in HD transmission? • How might this be a punishment for his deeds? For his personality? • Would Mozart and Da Ponte have agreed with George Bernard Shaw? December 24, 1994 Don Giovanni 34 Classroom Activity: A lot of “light” music Scene A 1–3 Donna Anna 4 Sharon Sweet 5–8 Don Ottavio 9 Patricia Schuman 10–12 Leporello 13 James Morris Stanford Olsen Donna Elvira Zerlina ACT I: Donna Anna and Don Giovanni Instrumental The Commendatore, Don Giovanni, and Leporello Tracks 1–8 continuously Scene B Herbert Perry Hei-Kyung Hong Depending on your class’s interests, you might want to follow up by having students read, or even perform, scenes from Don Juan in Hell. Another activity to provoke thinking about the ideas raised by Don Giovanni would be to consider other “hells” imagined by people who do not accept the Western concept of hell as a great inferno. For instance, Jean-Paul Sartre, the 20th-century French philosopher, stated, “Hell is other people.” His play No Exit depicts three characters trapped for eternity in one small room. Your students might be interested in choosing a fictional or historical character, learning about that person’s life and achievements, then imagining and writing or illustrating a depiction of that person’s “hell,” as Shaw did for Don Giovanni. How would it reflect, or correct, their character’s life experience? If your class did the Classroom Activity A Lot of “Light” Music they might be interested in comparing the positions of Enlightenment thinkers to the hells of Don Giovanni and Don Juan in Hell. Would either hell make sense to thinkers who believe that liberty is a natural right and that moral offenses are offenses against other people? If Rousseau or Locke believed in an afterlife, what might their hell look like? CD 1 of 2 Met Radio Recording ACT I: Masetto, Don Giovanni and Leporello Masetto Scene C 14–18 ACT I: Don Giovanni and Zerlina 19–22 Don Giovanni and Zerlina Duet: Là ci darem la mano Commendatore 23–24 Donna Elvira, Don Giovanni, and Zerlina Sergei Koptchak 25 Leopold Hager 26–28 Metropolitan Opera Orchestra and Chorus 29 Masetto Ildebrando D'Arcangelo Conductor Tracks 10–24 continuously Scene D ACT I: Quintet: Leporello, Don Giovanni, Donna Anna, Donna Elvira and Don Ottavio Tracks 26–28 continuously Scene E 30–32 33 ACT II: Don Giovanni and Leporello discuss women Tracks 30–32 continuously Scene F 34–38 39 ACT II: The Commendatore and Don Giovanni Tracks 34–38 continuously 35 The met: LIve in HD don giovanni classroom activity A Lot of “Light” Music: Enlightenment Statements CD 2 of 2 Musical Highlight: count the ways 1–8 ACT I: Leporello’s Catalog Aria 9 10–12 ACT II: Troppo mi spiace 13–17 Non mi dir 18 19–26 27 Tracks 1–8 continuously Musical Highlight: another view of love Tracks 10–17 continuously Musical Highlight: last words Donna Elvira, Zerlina, Don Ottavio, Masetto, Donna Anna, and Leporello 28 Don Ottavio and Donna Anna dance a minuet 29 Don Giovanni and Zerlina dance a quadrille 30 Waltz 31 Tracks 28–30 continuously 32–34 Overture 35–36 End of the opera, Don Giovanni descends into hell musical highlight: drama or comedy? FUN FACT 37–39 8. Liberty does not give a person the right to destroy himself or any other creature. (Do no harm/John Locke) 2. Everyone is born equal, neither good nor bad. Inequality is the result of people’s environments and experiences. (Equal at birth/John Locke) 9. Everyone has the right to punish a person who harms another person or obstructs another person’s rights. (Punish when needed/John Locke) 3. Humans are driven to protect their independence and equality. (The drive to be independent/John Locke) 10. Morality is an unspoken deal that every person makes with everyone else—an agreement to be part of society and follow its rules. (Agree to be moral/Rousseau) Tracks 19–26 continuously Musical Highlight: three different dances at the same time 1. When people act in their own interest, society benefits. (Self-interest/Adam Smith) Dinner scene, melodies from other composers 4. People are naturally free. No one need ask permission of anyone else before acting. (Natural liberty/John Locke) 5. Everyone wants to control others, to be rich, to be lazy and to enjoy pleasure. (The drive to control/Voltaire) 6. It is impossible for all people to be equal. Many people must have nothing so that some people can have a lot. (Necessary inequality/Voltaire) 7. No human can know anything perfectly, so no human has the right to judge another. (No judgment/David Hume) 36 11. Anyone who tries to break society’s rules must be forced to obey them. (Zero tolerance/Rousseau) 12. All humans experience exactly two impulses: the fear of death and the desire for power. (Death and Power/Thomas Hobbes) 13. Humans want two things: to increase pleasure and to avoid pain. (Pleasure and Pain/Thomas Hobbes) 14. People are basically selfish, so we give the authority to leaders in order to protect ourselves from one another. (Defense from selfishness/Thomas Hobbes) The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet classroom activity sheet A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene A A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene A (continued) CD 1 of 2 CD 1 of 2 Giovanni, fresh from an attempt to seduce Donna Anna, kills her father in a duel. Track 7 DON GIOVANNI: Track 1 Non sperar, se non m’uccidi, Ch’io ti lasci fuggir mai! DONNA ANNA: Don’t hope that if you don’t kill me, I will ever let you escape! Track 2 DON GIOVANNI: Donna folle! indarno gridi, Chi son io tu non saprai! Crazy woman! You cry out in vain! You’re not going to find out who I am! Gente! Servi! Al traditore! DON GIOVANNI: DONNA ANNA: Miserable man, wait, if you want to die! Track 8 IL COMMENDATORE: Ah, soccorso! son tradito! L’assassino m’ha ferito, e dal seno palpitante sento l’anima partir! Help! I am betrayed! The assassin has wounded me and I feel my soul departing from my beating breast! DON GIOVANNI: Ah, già cade il sciagurato, affannoso e agonizzante, già dal seno palpitante veggo l’anima partir. Ah, The wretch already falls gasping and dying. I can already see his soul departing from his beating breast. LEPORELLO: Qual misfatto! qual eccesso! Entro il sen dallo spavento palpitar il cor mi sento! Io non so che far, che dir. What a crime! What an outrage! My heart is trembling with fear in my breast! I don’t know what to say, what to do. Track 9: Tracks 1–8 continuously Track 3 DONNA ANNA: Misero, attendi, se vuoi morir! Taci e trema al mio furore! Scellerato! DON GIOVANNI: Sconsigliata! Somebody! Servants! Get this scoundrel! Be quiet and tremble at my anger! Villain! Mad woman! Track 4 Instrumental Track 5 THE COMMENDATORE: Lasciala, indegno! Battiti meco! Let her go, you worthless creep! Fight with me! Track 6 DON GIOVANNI: Va, non mi degno di pugnar teco. IL COMMENDATORE: LEPORELLO: Potessi almeno di qua partir! DON GIOVANNI: 38 Così pretendi da me fuggir? Misero! Go! It’s beneath my dignity to fight with you. That’s how you try to run away from me? At least I could get out of here! Wretch! 39 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet classroom activity sheet A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene B A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene C CD 1 of 2 CD 1 of 2 The wedding of Zerlina and Masetto. Giovanni tries to get Masetto out of the way in order to seduce his bride. The wedding of Zerlina and Masetto. Track 14 Track 10 MASETTO: Signore! DON GIOVANNI: MASETTO: Cosa c’è? La Zerlina senza me non può star. LEPORELLO: In vostro loco ci sarà Sua Eccellenza e saprà bene fare le vostre parti. DON GIOVANNI: Sir! DON GIOVANNI: Alfin siam liberati, Zerlinetta gentil, da quel scioccone. Che ne dite, mio ben, so far pulito? What is it? ZERLINA: Signore, è mio marito… We’re finally free of that fool, my lovely little Zerlina. Don’t I know how to clean things up, my dear? Sir, he’s my fiancé… Zerlina can’t be without me. His Excellency will take your place, and you can be sure that he will take care of your duties well. Oh, la Zerlina è in man d’un cavalier! Oh, Zerlina is in the hands of a gentleman! Va pur, fra poco ella meco verrà. Get going. In a little while, she’ll come with me. Track 15 DON GIOVANNI: Chi? Colui? Vi par che un onest’uomo, un nobil cavalier, com’io mi vanto, possa soffrir che quel visetto d’oro, quel viso inzuccherato da un bifolcaccio vil sia strapazzato? Who? Him? Do you think a virtuous man, a noble gentleman such as I pride myself in being, could allow this little golden face, this sweet face, be wasted on such a contemptible hick? Track 11 DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Va, non temere. Nelle mani son io d’un cavaliere. MASETTO: ZERLINA: E per questo? E per questo non c’è da dubitar MASETTO: Ed io, cospetto… DON GIOVANNI: Olà! Go, don’t be afraid. I am in the hands of a gentleman. Which is to say? Which is to say that there’s nothing to worry about. And me, right here… Track 16 ZERLINA: Ma, signore, io gli diedi parola di sposarlo. Tal parola non vale un zero. Voi non siete fatta per essere paesana; un altra sorte vi procuran quegli occhi bricconcelli, quei labbretti sì belli, quelle dituccie candide e odorose, parmi toccar giuncata e fiutar rose. DON GIOVANNI: But sir, I have given my word to marry him. Such a promise is worth nothing. You were not made to be a peasant. Another fate is in store for those roguish eyes, those beautiful little lips, those pale, fragrant fingers which seem to me as soft as snow and sweet as roses. Hey! Track 17 ZERLINA: Track 12 Finiam le dispute! Se subito senza altro replicar non te ne vai, Masetto, guarda ben, ti pentirai. DON GIOVANNI: Let’s end this argument! If you don’t leave right away without another word, Masetto, watch out. You will regret it. Ah!… Non vorrei… DON GIOVANNI: Che non vorreste? ZERLINA: Alfine ingannata restar. Io so che raro colle donne voi altri cavalieri siete onesti e sinceri. Ah! I don’t want to… You don’t want to what? To end up tricked. I know how rarely you noblemen are honest and sincere with women. Track 13 MASETTO: Ho capito, signor, sì! Chino il capo e me ne vo’, giàcché piace a voi così, altre repliche non fo. Cavalier voi siete già. Dubitar non posso affé; Me lo dice la bontà che volete aver per me. I understand, sir, yes! I should bow my head and go since that’s how you want it. I won’t say another word. You are after all a gentleman. I cannot doubt that. I have heard about the kind of goodness you want to show me. (to Zerlina) Bricconaccia, malandrina! Fosti ognor la mia ruina! You little fool, you minx! You always were my downfall! 40 41 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet classroom activity sheet A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene C (continued) A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene C (continued) CD 1 of 2 CD 1 of 2 Track 18 Track 21 È un impostura della gente plebea! La nobilità ha dipinta negli occhi l’onestà. Orsù, non perdiam tempo; In questo istante io ti voglio sposar. DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Voi! Certo, io. Quel casinetto è mio. Soli saremo e là, gioiello mio, ci sposeremo! DON GIOVANNI: …non son più forte. That’s just a rumor started by the peasants! Honesty shines in a nobleman’s eyes. Come now, let’s not waste time. I want to marry you right now. ZERLINA: You! DON GIOVANNI: Certainly me. That little cottage is mine. We’ll be alone there, my little jewel—we’ll marry there! ZERLINA: DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Track 19 Vorrei e non vorrei There we will take each other’s hands. There you will say yes to me. Look, it’s not far off. Let’s leave here, my precious. ZERLINA: (Vorrei e non vorrei, Mi trema un poco il cor. Felice, è ver, sarei, Ma può burlarmi ancor.) (I want to and I don’t want to. My heart is trembling a bit. I would be happy, it’s true, but he could still trick me.) ZERLINA: Vieni, mio bel diletto! (Mi fa pietà Masetto.) DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Partiam, ben mio, da qui. Ma può burlarmi ancor. DON GIOVANNI: DON GIOVANNI: Là ci darem la mano, Là mi dirai di sì. Vedi, non è lontano; Partiam, ben mio, da qui. Là mi dirai di sì. Mi trema un poco il cor. DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Vieni, vieni—là ci darem la mano, Io cangerò tua sorte. Presto… non son più forte. I don’t have the strength. Come, come—there we will take each other’s hands. I want to and I don’t want to. There you will say yes to me. My heart is trembling a bit. Let’s leave here, my precious. But he can still fool me. Come, my delightful beauty. (I pity Masetto.) I will change your fate. Quick… I don’t have the strength. Track 22 Andiam, andiam, mio bene A ristorar le pene d’un innocente amor. DON GIOVANNI AND ZERLINA: Let’s go, let’s go, my precious, to savor the pangs of an innocent love. Track 20 DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: (Mi fa pietà Masetto.) DON GIOVANNI: ZERLINA: Vieni, mio bel diletto! Io cangerò tua sorte. Presto… non son più forte. Come, my beautiful delight. Track 23 (I pity Masetto.) Fermati, scellerato! II ciel mi fece udir le tue perfidie. Io sono a tempo di salvar questa misera innocente dal tuo barbaro artiglio! I will change your fate. Quick… I don’t have the strength. DONNA ELVIRA: ZERLINA: Meschina! Cosa sento? Halt, villain! Heaven has enabled me to hear your lies. I am in time to save this poor innocent girl from your barbarian claws! You wretched woman! What am I hearing? Track 24 (Amor, consiglio!) (to Elvira) Idol mio, non vedete ch’io voglio divertirmi? dON GIOVANNI: DONNA ELVIRA: Divertirti, è vero? (Love, advise me!) My darling, don’t you see that I just want to amuse myself? Amuse yourself? Really? Track 25: Tracks 10–24 continuously 42 43 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet classroom activity sheet A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene D A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene E CD 1 of 2 CD 1 of 2 Near the end of Act I, this is the only point in the opera at which Mozart and Da Ponte refer to the subject of liberty. Near the beginning of Act II, Leporello and Giovanni discuss the latter’s attitude towards women. Track 26 Track 30 LEPORELLO: Venite pur avanti, vezzose mascherette! DON GIOVANNI: È aperto a tutti quanti, viva la libertà! Come in, come in, charming masqueraders! DON GIOVANNI: My home is open to all! Long live liberty! LEPORELLO: Track 27 Ti basta l’animo di far quel ch’io ti dico? Purchè lasciam le donne. Do you have the guts to do what I tell you to? Provided that we abandon the women. Track 31 DONNA ANNA, DONNA ELVIRA, and DON OTTAVIO: Siam grati a tanti We are grateful for all of this generosity. DON GIOVANNI: Lasciar le donne? Pazzo! Abandon the women? You’re crazy! segni di generosità. Track 32 Track 28 DON GIOVANNI: È aperto a tutti quanti, viva la libertà! DONNA ANNA, DONNA ELVIRA, and DON OTTAVIO: Siam grati a tanti segni di generosità. Track 29: Tracks 26–28 continuously My home is open to all! Long live liberty! We are grateful for all of this generosity. DON GIOVANNI: Lasciar le donne? Sai ch’elle per me son necessarie più del pan che mangio, più dell’aria che spiro! LEPORELLO: E avete core d’ingannarle poi tutte? DON GIOVANNI: È tutto amore! Chi a una sola è fedele, verso l’altre è crudele: io che in me sento sì esteso sentimento, vo’ bene a tutte quante. Le donne poiché calcolar non sanno, il mio buon natural chiamano inganno. LEPORELLO: Non ho veduto mai naturale più vasto, e più Abandon the women? You know that, for me, they are more necessary than the bread I eat, more than the air I breathe! And so you have the heart to trick them all? It’s all love! A man who is faithful to only one is cruel to all the rest; I, who feel within such deep emotions, want to be good to all of them. Since women don’t know how to appreciate my behavior, they call my natural goodness trickery. I’ve never seen a nature as great and as kind as yours. benigno. Track 33: Tracks 30–32 continuously 44 45 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet classroom activity sheet A Lot of “Light” Music: Scene F A Lot of “Light” Music Which Side Are They On? CD 1 of 2 At the end of the opera, Giovanni and the statue of the Commendatore argue before Don Giovanni’s descent into hell. Track 34 THE STATUE OF THE COMMENDATORE: Don Giovanni, a cenar teco Don Giovanni! You invited me to supper, and here I am. Scene A Mozart & DaPonte Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Evidence in Scene A: m’invitasti, e son venuto. Enlightenment statements that apply: Track 35 THE STATUE: Pentiti, cangia vita! È l’ultimo momento! Repent! Change your life! This is the final moment! Track 36 DON GIOVANNI: No, no, ch’io non mi pento, Vanne lontan da me! No, no—I will not repent. Get away from me! Pentiti, scellerato! DON GIOVANNI: Mozart & DaPonte Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Evidence in Scene B: Track 37 THE STATUE: Scene B No, vecchio infatuato! No! Repent, villain! No, you conceited old man! No! Yes! Enlightenment statements that apply: No! Scene c Mozart & DaPonte Ah! Your time is up! Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 DON GIOVANNI: Da qual tremore insolito sento assalir gli spiriti! Dond’escono quei vortici di foco pien d’orror? What strange trembling do I feel attacking my spirits! Where are these whirlpools of fire, filled with horror, coming from? Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 demons: Tutto a tue colpe è poco! Vieni! c’è un mal peggior! No doom can match your crimes! Come! Worse torments await you! Don Giovanni: Chi l’anima mi lacera? Chi m’agita le viscere? Che strazio ohimè! che smania! che inferno! che terror! Ah! I’m being torn apart! Something’s clawing at my vitals! What torture, what delirium! Hell and all its torments! Arrgh! Che ceffo disperato! Che gesti di dannato! Che gridi! che lamenti! Come mi fa terror! Ah! Despair contorts his face! He writhes as one damned! What shrieks! What groans! I’m terrified! Arrgh! THE STATUE: Sì! Track 38 DON GIOVANNI: THE STATUE: No! Ah! tempo più non v’è! Leporello: Evidence in Scene C: Enlightenment statements that apply: Track 39: Tracks 34–38 continuously 46 47 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni classroom activity sheet Resource Page for Musical Highlight A Lot of “Light” Music Which Side Are They On? Count the Ways: Leporello’s Catalog Aria CD 2 of 2 Track 1 Scene D Mozart & DaPonte Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 LEPORELLO: Madamina, il catalogo è questo Delle belle che amò il padron mio; Un catalogo egli è che ho fatt’io; Osservate, leggete con me. My little lady, this is the catalog of the beauties that my employer has loved, I have kept this catalog of his. Take a look, read along with me. Evidence in Scene D: Track 2 In Italia seicento e quaranta; In Almagna duecento e trentuna; Cento in Francia, in Turchia novantuna; Ma in Ispagna son già mille e tre. Enlightenment statements that apply: In Italy, 640. In Germany, 231. 100 in France, in Turkey 91, but in Spain, there are already 1,003. Track 3 Scene E Mozart & DaPonte Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Evidence in Scene E: V’han fra queste contadine, cameriere, cittadine, v’han contesse, baronesse, marchesine, principesse. E v’han donne d’ogni grado, D’ogni forma, d’ogni età. There are among these ladies, peasants, chambermaids, city women. There are countesses, baronesses, marquises, princesses. And are women of every rank, of every shape, of every age. Track 4: Tracks 2–3 continuously Enlightenment statements that apply: Track 5 scene F Mozart & DaPonte Individual Liberty score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Social Control score 0 1 2 3 4 5 Evidence in Scene F: Enlightenment statements that apply: 48 Nella bionda egli ha l’usanza di lodar la gentilezza, Nella bruna la costanza, nella bianca la dolcezza. Vuol d’inverno la grassotta, vuol d’estate la magrotta; È la grande maestosa, la piccina è ognor vezzosa. With blondes, he has the custom of praising their gentleness, with brunettes their devotion, with fair-haired women their sweetness. He likes a fat one in winter. He likes a skinny one in summer. The large one he finds stately; the tiny one charming. Track 6 Delle vecchie fa conquista pel piacer di porle in lista; Sua passion predominante è la giovin principiante. Non si picca—se sia ricca, se sia brutta, se sia bella; Purché porti la gonnella, He conquers old ones just for the pleasure of putting them on the list. His main passion is the inexperienced young one. It doesn’t bother him if she’s rich, if she’s ugly, if she’s beautiful, as long as she’s wearing a skirt. 49 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni Resource Page for Musical Highlight Resource Page for Musical Highlight Count the Ways: Leporello’s Catalog Aria (continued) Another View of Love: Donna Anna’s Aria CD 2 of 2 CD 2 of 2 Track 7 Track 10 Voi sapete quel che fa! You know what he does! DONNA ANNA: Troppo mi spiace allontanarti un ben che lungamente la nostr’alma desia… I am all too sorry to put off a happiness that our soul has wanted for so long. Track 8 In questa forma dunque mi tradì il scellerato? È questo il premio che quel barbaro rende all’amor mio? Ah! Vendicar vogl’io l’ingannato mio cor. Pria ch’ei mi fugga si ricorra… si vada… io sento in petto sol vendetta parlar, rabbia e dispetto. DONNA ELVIRA: So this is the way the villain betrayed me? And this is the reward that this barbarian has for my love? Ah! I want to avenge my heart broken from lies. Before he escapes me, I’ll make him… I’ll go… in my breast, I only feel revenge, anger, and hate. Track 11 DONNA ANNA: Ma il mondo, o Dio! Non sedur la costanza del sensibil mio core. But the world, o God! Do not tempt the steadfastness of my sensitive heart. Track 12 Track 9: Tracks 1–8 continuously DONNA ANNA: Abbastanza per te mi parla amore. Enough of you talking to me of love. Non mi dir, bell’idol mio, che son io crudel con te. Don’t tell me, my beautiful darling, that I am cruel to you. Tu ben sai quant’io t’amai, tu conosci la mia fé’. You know well how much I loved you. You are familiar with my fidelity. Track 13 DONNA ANNA: Track 14 DONNA ANNA: Track 15 DONNA ANNA: Calma, calma il tuo tormento, se di duol non vuoi ch’io mora. Calm, calm your anger if you don’t want me to die of grief. Track 16: Tracks 13 and 15 repeated Track 17 DONNA ANNA: Forse un giorno il cielo ancora sentirà pietà di Perhaps one day, heaven will again have pity on me. me. Track 18: Tracks 10–17 continuously 50 51 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni Resource Page for Musical Highlight Resource Page for Musical Highlight Last Words: The Final Sextet Last Words: The Final Sextet CD 2 of 2 CD 2 of 2 Track 19 Track 24 DONNA ELVIRA, ZERLINA, DON OTTAVIO and MASETTO: Ah, dov’è il perfido? Dov’è l’indegno? Tutto il mio sdegno sfogar io vo’! DONNA ANNA: Solo mirandolo stretto in catene alle mie pene calma darò. Ah, where is the evil one? Where is that worthless man? I want to vent all my anger! DON OTTAVIO: Al desio di chi m’adora ceder deve un fido amor. To the wish of the one who adores me, I must grant trust and love. Only when I see him bound in chains will all my suffering give way to calm. DONNA ANNA: Al desio di chi t’adora ceder deve un fido amor. To the wish of the one who adores you, you must grant trust and love. Track 20 Track 25 LEPORELLO: Più non sperate di ritrovarlo, più non cercate. lontano andò. all: Cos’è? Favella! Via presto, sbrigati! LEPORELLO: Don’t hope to see him again. Don’t look for him. He went far away. What? Tell us! Quickly, quickly! Venne un colosso… Ma se non posso… There was a huge statue…but I can’t…. Presto! Favella! Sbrigati! Quick! Tell! Hurry Up! THE OTHERS: DONNA ELVIRA: ZERLINA: Io men vado in un ritiro a finir la vita mia! Noi, Masetto, a casa andiamo! A cenar in compagnia! MASETTO: Noi, Zerlina, a casa andiamo! A cenar in compagnia! LEPORELLO: Ed io vado all’osteria a trovar padron miglior. I will go into seclusion for the rest of my life! Masetto, let’s go home to have dinner with our friends! Zerlina, let’s go home to have dinner with our friends! And I’m going to the inn to find a better master. Track 26 Track 21 Tra fumo e fuoco… Badate un poco… L’uomo di sasso… Fermate il passo… Giusto là sotto… Diede il gran botto… Giusto là il diavol—Se’l trangugiò. LEPORELLO: TUTTI: Stelle, che sento! LEPORELLO: There was smoke and fire… Wait a moment… The man of stone… stop running around…just there, below… there was a big bang…just there, the devil…swallowed him up. ZERLINA, MASETTO, and LEPORELLO: Resti dunque quel birbon con Proserpina e Pluton. E noi tutti, o buona gente, ripetiam allegramente l’antichissima canzon: Thus that rascal rests with Proserpine and Pluto, and all of us, good people, happily sing the ancient song again: Questo è il fin di chi fa mal; E de’ perfidi la morte alla vita è sempre ugual. This is the end of someone who acts wickedly. And the death of evildoers is always equal to their lives. ALL: My stars, what am I hearing! Vero è l’evento! It’s true. Track 27: Tracks 19–26 continuously Track 22 DONNA ELVIRA: Ah, certo è l’ombra che m’incontrò! DONNA ANNA, ZERLINA, DON OTTAVIO and MASETTO: Ah, certo è Ah, that must have been the ghost I encountered! Ah, that must have been the ghost she encountered! l’ombra che l’incontrò! Track 23 DON OTTAVIO: Or che tutti, o mio tesoro, vendicati siam dal cielo, porgi, porgi a me un ristoro, non mi far languire ancor. DONNA ANNA: Lascia, o caro, un anno ancora allo sfogo del Now that we have be avenged for everything by heaven, o my treasure, give me some relief—don’t make me languish longer. Leave me one more year, dear, to clear my heart. mio cor. 52 53 The met: LIve in HD The met: LIve in HD don giovanni don giovanni Resource Page for Musical Highlight Resource Page for Musical Highlight Three Different Dances at the Same Time Drama or Comedy? It’s All in the Overture CD 2 of 2 CD 2 of 2 TRACK 28 Tracks 32–34: Orchestral Overture Minuet Track 35 The statue: Don Giovanni, a cenar teco m’invitasti, e son venuto. Don Giovanni! You invited me to supper, and here I am. Quadrille Don Giovanni: Non l’avrei giammai creduto. Ma farò quel che potrò! Leporello, un’altra cena fa che subito si porti! I never thought you would. But I shall do what I can. Leporello, ask for more food to be served immediately! Track 30 Leporello: Track 29 Waltz (from beneath the table) Ah, pardon, siam tutti morti! Don Giovanni: Vanne, dico… Ferma un pò. Non si pasce di cibo mortale chi si pasce di cibo celeste. Altre cure più gravi di queste, altra brama quaggiù mi guidò! The statue: Track 31: Tracks 28–30 continuously Ah, master, we’re all as good as dead Go along, I tell you… Wait a moment. Those who have tasted the food of heaven do not eat moral viands. Other, weightier concerns, another need has brought me here! Track 36 demons: Tutto a tue colpe è poco! Vieni! c’è un mal peggior! No doom can match your crimes! Come! Worse torments await you! Don Giovanni: Chi l’anima mi lacera? Chi m’agita le viscere? Che strazio ohimè! che smania! che inferno! che terror! Ah! I’m being torn apart! Something’s clawing at my vitals! What torture, what delirium! Hell and all its torments! Arrgh! Leporello: Che ceffo disperato! Che gesti di dannato! Che gridi! che lamenti! Come mi fa terror! Ah! Despair contorts his face! He writhes as one damned! What shrieks! What groans! I’m terrified! Arrgh! TRACK 37–39 See Fun Fact, p. 13. 54 55 55 The met: LIve in HD October 29, 2011 don giovanni Don Giovanni: My Highs & Lows Conducted by fabio luisi October 29, 2011 Reviewed by Performance Activity: Little Boxes Name Class the stars Teacher For this production of Don Giovanni, the set designer, Christopher Oram, and the director, Michael Grandage, envisioned the opera’s setting as a complex of open cubes—“buildings that can have balconies, and balconies that can have interiors, and all the interior life of that and the exterior life of it.” On this worksheet, you can sketch the set as it first appears, then keep track of its changes and uses as the opera—like the set itself—unfolds. Act _, Scene _ Star PowerMy Comments Mariusz Kwiecien as Don Giovanni * * * * * Marina Rebeka as Donna Anna * * * * * Barbara Frittoli as Donna Elvira * * * * * Ramón Vargas as Don Ottavio * * * * * Luca Pisaroni as Leporello * * * * * Mojca Erdmann as Zerlina * * * * * John Relyea as Masetto * * * * * Act _, Scene _ THE SHOW, SCENE BY SCENE action Act _, Scene _ Act _, Scene _ 56 Act _, Scene _ Act _, Scene _ musicset design/staging Leporello talks about his boss 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Donna Anna tries to hold Don Giovanni 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 The duel 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Don Giovanni meets Donna Elvira 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Leporello sings about the Catalog 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Don Giovanni meets Zerlina and Masetto 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Don Giovanni sweet-talks Zerlina 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Donna Elvira appears 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 57 October 29, 2011 Don Giovanni: My Highs & Lows Conducted by fabio luisi THE SHOW, SCENE BY SCENE action musicset design/staging Donna Anna realizes who the masked man was 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 The party in the ballroom 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Leporello and Don Giovanni trade identities 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Leporello and Donna Elvira 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 Don Giovanni and Masetto 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 The graveyard My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 Don Ottavio and Donna Anna My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 Don Giovanni’s dinner guest My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 The big finish My opinion 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 1-2-3-4-5 58