Survey
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
* Your assessment is very important for improving the work of artificial intelligence, which forms the content of this project
Dietary Pattern and Lifestyle Factors Associated with Menopausal Symptoms Maggie Chung, Alyssa Claxton, Gretchen Gibbons, Stephanie LaPlant, Taylor Wang, Lauren Zuro Advisor: Bonnie Beezhold, PhD, MHS, CHES Introduction Research Question • Do women on a plant-based diet have fewer menopausal symptoms? Are there other lifestyle factors that also impact menopause? Hypothesis • Women who are vegetarians or vegans will report fewer symptoms compared to those who are omnivores. (Beezhold, Radnitz, Rinne, DiMatteo, 2015)1 Overview - Menopause • Menopause overview • Menopause symptoms • Hormone replacement therapy (Grant 20152, Opatrny 20083, Shumaker 20034) Overview-Research Studies • Fewer menopausal symptoms associated with higher intake of whole grains, F&V in Chinese postmenopausal women. 5 • Decreased menopausal symptoms associated with high fiber intake in women treated for breast cancer. 6 • Plant-based diets are associated with favorable metabolic profiles in pre- and post-menopausal women. 7 • Vegan diet was associated with reduced HDL-C level in preand post-menopausal women. 8 5. Liu, 2015; 6. Gold, 2006; 7. Karelis, 2010; 8. Yee-Wen, 2014 Study Objectives • To investigate whether dietary patterns and behaviors as well as specific foods were associated with symptoms that occur during menopause in aging women. • To investigate whether demographic and lifestyle factors were related to menopausal symptoms. Methods – Study Design • Cross sectional survey study • Online delivery through convenience sampling using SurveyMonkey • Eligibility requirements • Females, ages 45-80 years old • Willing to complete an online survey Methods – Participant Recruitment Methods – Survey • Survey completion • Survey components • • Demographics Lifestyle factors Methods – Survey • Severity of menopausal symptoms; Menopause-Specific Quality of Life questionnaire (MENQOL) • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Hot flashes Night sweats Sweating Being dissatisfied with personal life Feeling anxious or nervous Poor memory Accomplishing less Feeling depressed, down, or blue Being impatient with others Feelings of wanting to be alone Increased facial hair Changes in skin Feeling bloated Backaches • Frequent urination • Involuntary urination when laughing or coughing • Change in sexual desire • Flatulence or gas pains • Aching in muscles and joints • Feeling tired or worn out • Difficulty sleeping • Aches in back of neck or head • Decrease in physical strength • Decrease in stamina • Vaginal dryness during intercourse • Avoiding intimacy Methods – Survey • Which of the following foods do you include in your diet (at least monthly)? • Meat (beef, pork, lamb); chicken or turkey; fish or shellfish; eggs; dairy foods; none • Diet questions: foods, food groups, nutrients • Fruits, vegetables, beverages, omega-3 fatty acids Methods – Survey FRUITS AND VEGETABLES Apricots, plum, pear, apple Berries (any type) Citrus fruits (oranges, grapefruit, tangerines) Grapes Pineapple, papaya, mango (fresh) Broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower, kale, mustard greens, radish, turnips Orange vegetables (carrots, sweet potatoes, butternut squash, pumpkin) Spinach, Swiss chard, salad greens Never or less than 1X a mo (1) 1-3X Per Mo (2) Once A Wk (3) 2-4X Per Wk (4) 5-6X per Wk (5) Once 2-3X 4-5X 6+X a per per per Day day day day (6) (7) (8) (9) Survey Validity & Reliability Validity • Incorporated validated scales • • Exercise and social support Menopause-specific Quality of Life questionnaire (MENQOL) • Use of clear and appropriate language for survey questions • Pilot testing and feedback • Online delivery promoted large geographic sample. Reliability • Potentially unclear questions were eliminated • Validated scales showed strong internal consistency and test-retest reliability • MENQOL – Cronbach alpha coefficient = 0.93 (0.81 to 0.89) Methods - Statistical analysis • • • • • • Correlational, differential analysis Parametric statistics Descriptive statistics Pearson’s correlation coefficients and multiple linear regression; Chi square tests Independent t tests, ANOVA, ANCOVA Significance - p < .05; SPSS version 23 Results Menstrual Status Perimenopausal 22.2% n=109 Postmenopausal 77.8% n=383 Diet Pattern OMN 55.7% n=248 VG 27.6% n=123 VEG 16.6% n=74 Vegetarian Types •Semi-vegetarian •Pescatarian •Ovo-vegetarian •Ovo-lactovegetarian •Lactovegetarian Location by Country Canada 4.0% n=18 Other 4.3% n=19 United States 91.7% n=408 Ethnicity Asian 2.0% n=9 Black 1.3% n=6 Hispanic 3.1% n=14 Other 4.0% n=18 White 89.4% n=398 Body Mass Index (BMI) Overweight 23.0% n=88 Obese 33.2% n=127 Normal 43.9% n=168 Education Population Characteristics by Diet Type Variables Age Country (US/non-US) Ethnicity (white/other) Education (yrs beyond HS) BMI OMN n=248 VEG n=74 VG n=123 Test stat p value Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Mean ± SD 445 59.17 ± 7.85a 58.35 ± 7.57b 55.15 ± 6.29ab F=12.28 <0.001 445 243 / 5ab 5a 27b X2=57.9 4 <0.001 445 227 / 21 65 / 9 106 / 17 X2=2.73 0.255 445 7.46 ± 3.63 8.03 ± 3.77 6.96 ± 3.39 F=2.09 0.125 395 29.02 ± 7.12ab 25.89 ± 5.77b 26.54 ± 6.32a F=8.23 <0.001 n Same letters differ significantly 69 / 96 / Menopausal Symptoms Principle component analysis results: Component 1: Physical symptoms (17) Component 2: Mental symptoms (6) Associations of Diet Type with Symptoms Variables N Physical symptoms Mental symptoms r / p value r / p value Diet type (Omn/Vg) 371 -0.122 / 0.010 0.057 / 0.233 Total vegetables 432 -0.181 /<0.001 -0.142 / 0.003 Total fruits 431 -0.099 / 0.040 -0.100 / 0.039 Total flesh foods 431 0.173 /<0.001 -0.033 / 0.490 Beef 422 0.157 / 0.001 0.009 / 0.858 Total dairy foods 430 0.196 /<0.001 0.071 / 0.141 Total eggs 431 0.115 / 0.018 -0.043 / 0.378 Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant Multivariate Analysis – Predictors of Menopausal Symptoms PHYSICAL symptoms Variable β* MENTAL symptoms p value Variable β* p value Age -0.234 <0.001 Social support -0.246 <0.001 Vegan diet (N/Y) -0.181 0.002 Age -0.201 <0.001 BMI 0.157 0.004 -0.128 0.009 Sleep hrs/night -0.106 0.040 Sweets intake freq 0.117 0.015 0.057 Sleep hrs/night -0.096 0.046 0.107 Total exercise -0.086 0.090 0.083 0.097 Sweets intake freq Total exercise 0.103 -0.088 Berries intake freq BMI R2 0.158 R2 0.187 Correlates with p values < .025 included in models. *Betas are standardized. Comparison of Symptoms by Diet Groups Symptoms n OMN VEG VG n=248 n=74 n=123 F ratio Adj F ratio Mean ±SD Mean ±SD Mean ±SD Physical symptoms 445 40.46 ± 17.83a 41.12 ± 17.78b 33.26 ± 14.80ab Mental symptoms 445 13.64 ± 6.32 15.35 ± 7.97 13.87 ± 7.27 ** p<0.001, *p<0.05; ANOVA - same letters differ significantly. 1 ANCOVA adj means: 41.62a, 40.63b, 31.83ab, ƞ2= 0.062. p 2 ANCOVA adj means: 14.12, 15.40b, 12.87b, ƞ2=0.016. p 8.33** 1.78 12.83**1 3.52*2 Discussion Vegan diet is associated with lower severity of physical menopausal symptoms; vegans reported lower symptom severity than those who ate animal foods. • Confirmed previously mentioned studies. 9,10 • Vegan diet had highest dietary fiber intake vs omnivorous diet. 11,12 9. Liu, 2015; 10. Gold, 2006; 11. Bani, 2013; 12. Park, 2011. Sweets intake • Excess sugar consumption is linked to cell aging, negative health ailments 13-15 • Excess sugar consumption13 is linked to deficiencies in memory, cognitive health, and affects biological aging 16,17 13. World Health Organization, 2015; 14. Melton, 2000; 15. Mikulikova et al 2008; 16. Crane et al 2013; 17. Cassidy et al 2010 Methods • NIH Dietary Questionnaire II We are interested in whether you consume any of the following specific foods or beverages and how frequently you do so. ON AVERAGE OVER THE PAST YEAR Never or less than 1-3 per once a month month (2) (1) Sweets (pastries, cakes, cookies, brownies, candy, etc.) Soft drinks (sugar-sweetened, non-diet) Once a week (3) 2-4 per week (4) 5-6 per week (5) Once a day (6) 2-3 per day (7) 4-5 per day (8) 6+ per day (9) Results – Intake of Sweets / Soda Variable n OMN VEG VG p value* Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Sweets 432 3.84 ± 1.81a 3.44 ± 1.87b 2.64 ± 1.52ab < .0011 Soda 424 1.61 ± 1.28a 1.25 ± 0.89b 1.13 ± 0.55ab < .0012 * ANOVA; groups with same letters differed significantly. 1 F = 18.8, ƞ2 = .08. 2 F = 8.8, ƞ2 = .04. p p Results – Associations Variables n Physical symptoms Mental symptoms (r/p) (r/p) Sweets intake 432 .167 / .001 .130 / .007 Soda intake 424 .118 / .015 .102 / .035 Total sweets intake frequency 423 .179 / .001 .139 / .004 Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant. Results – Group Comparison Total sweets variable n Never or Less rarely frequently eat sweets eat sweets More frequently eat sweets F ratio Adj F ratio M ± SD M ± SD M ± SD Physical 377 Symptoms 37.77 ± 17.55a 35.53 ± 13.98b 45.46 ± 20.47ab 11.33* 8.82*1 Mental 423 Symptoms 13.73 ± 7.11a 13.06 ± 5.99b 16.38 ± 7.63ab 8.07* 7.21*2 * p < .01; same letters differ significantly. 1 Adj means: 36.37, 35.64, 44.51, pƞ2 = 0.045. 2Adj means: 13.63, 13.26, 16.17, ƞ2 = 0.033 p Discussion Eating sweets was related to increased severity of menopausal symptoms; females eating sweets more frequently had higher symptom severity than those who never or rarely ate sweets. • Intake of sweets was positively associated with the risk of onset of menopausal symptoms18,19 • Frequency of sweets intake was associated with chills20 18. Sabia et al 2008; 19. Herber-Gast & Mishra, 2013; 20. Ishizuka, 2008 Background – Berry Intake • Foods that contain phytoestrogens act as antioxidants which may relieve menopausal symptoms 21 • Higher intake of flavonoids at midlife is associated with greater wellbeing in the elderly 22 21. Moreira et al, 2014; 22. Samieri et al, 2014 Methods We are interested in whether you consume any of the following specific foods or beverages and how frequently you do so. ON AVERAGE OVER THE PAST YEAR Never or 1-3 per less than month once a (2) month (1) Berries (any) Once a week (3) 2-4 per week (4) 5-6 per week (5) Once a day (6) 2-3 per day (7) 4-5 per day (8) 6+ per day (9) Results – Intake of Berries Variable n OMN VEG VG Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Berry intake 419 3.72 + 1.65a frequency 3.86 + 1.66b p value 4.54 + 1.87ab <.001* * ANOVA, F ratio = 9.036, pƞ2= 0.042; groups with same letters differed significantly. Results – Associations Variables Berry intake frequency n Physical Symptoms (r/p) Mental Symptoms (r/p) 119 - .208 / .000 - .188 / .000 Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant. Results – Comparison of Groups Never or Eat berries rarely weekly eat berries n Eat berries daily F ratio Adj F ratio M ± SD M ± SD M ± SD Physical 373 Symptoms 44.84 ± 21.26a 38.38 ± 15.83 35.14 ± 15.56a 7.39* 3.78*1 Mental 420 Symptoms 16.15 ± 7.85a 13.80 ± 6.73 12.64 ± 5.97a 6.72* 4.93*2 * p < .05; groups with same letters differ significantly. 1 ANCOVA adj means: 43.41, 38.41, 36.61, ƞ2 = 0.02 p 2 ANCOVA adj means: 15.76, 13.88, 12.87, ƞ2 = 0.02 p Discussion Eating berries was related to decreased menopausal symptoms; females eating berries daily had lower symptoms than those never or rarely eating berries. • Decrease in estrogen during menopause increases oxidative stress 23,24 • Berry supplementation resulted in significant improvement in symptoms 25 23. Manach et al, 2004; 24. Doshi et al, 2013; 25. Schrager et al, 2015 Background – Omega-3 Fats • Omega-3 fat26 supplementation decreased depression symptoms and hot flash frequency 27 Animal Based Plant Based 26. Mozaffarian et. al, 2011; 27. Freeman et. al, 2011 Methods • NIH Dietary Questionnaire II format; Omega-3 questionnaire (Sublette et al, 2011) We are interested in whether you consume any of the following specific foods or beverages and how frequently you do so. ON AVERAGE OVER THE PAST YEAR Never or less than 1-3 per once a month month (2) (1) Walnuts or walnut oil, canola oil Flaxseeds (ground) or flaxseed oil Once a week (3) 2-4 per week (4) 5-6 per week (5) Once a day (6) 2-3 per day (7) 4-5 per day (8) 6+ per day (9) Results: Comparison of Groups Variable p value OMN VEG VG M ± SD M ± SD M ± SD Walnuts, canola oil 2.53 ± 1.55 (n=238) 3.04 ± 1.78 (n=71) 3.11 ± 1.86 (n=116) .0031 Flaxseed, flaxseed oil 1.92 ± 1.58 (n=239) 2.51 ± 1.80 (n=73) 3.44 ± 2.01 (n=117) <.0012 1ANOVA, F ratio = 5.86, ƞ2= 0.027; 2ANOVA, F ratio = 29.56, ƞ2= 0.122 Results: Associations with Symptoms n Physical Symptoms (r/p) Mental Symptoms (r/p) Walnuts 426 - .066 / .172 - .096 / .048 Flaxseeds 430 - .127 / .008 - .088 / .068 Total major ALA sources 424 - .132 / .007 - .120 / .014 Frequency of major ALA sources Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant. Results: Comparisons of Groups n Never or Less freq More freq rare freq of of major of major F ratio major ALA ALA ALA Adj F ratio M ± SD M ± SD M ± SD Physical 424 Symptoms 40.37 ± 18.16a 39.57 ± 17.46 35.40 ± 15.87a 3.21* 1.56 Mental 424 Symptoms 14.95 ± 7.25a 14.13 ± 7.08 12.63 ± 6.18a 3.96* 3.47*1 * p < .05; groups with same letters differ significantly. 1 ANCOVA adj means: 14.94, 13.94, 12.86:, ƞ2= .016. p Discussion Eating major ALA sources was associated with decreased menopausal symptoms; those who ate them more frequently vs never or rarely reported less mental symptom severity. • • Vegetarians reported better mood and higher PUFA than omnivores 28 High ALA intake in vegetarians lowers the LA/ALA ratio 29 28. Beezhold et. al 2010; 29. Sanders 2009 Background • Diets rich in monounsaturated fatty acids improved the quality of life for postmenopausal women.30 • Fast food consumption, starting in adolescents, among those following a Western diet have a stronger association with overweight/obesity, and poor dietary outcomes.31 30. Anderson-Vasquez et. al, 2015; 31. Poti et. al, 2014 Methods Which of the following best describes the type of meals you most frequently eat? . ON AVERAGE OVER THE PAST YEAR Never or rarely Convenience/Frozen Food Home Cooked Meals Eat out (fast food) Eat at a full service restaurant 2-4 times per month 2-3 times per week 4-6 times per week Once per day 2-3 times per day Results – Comparison of Groups Eating habits Eat home-cook meals Eat convenience foods Eat fast foods Eat at full service restaurants OMN VEG VG 241 71 121 (n=243) (n=71) (n=122) 105 23 46 (n=240) (n=72) (n=115) 139 29 27 (n=240) (n=72) (n=117) 213 58 82 (n=245) (n=72) (n=121) p value* .745 .199 .0001 .0022 *Chi-square; p<.05 is significant. 1X2(10, N= 429)= 44.06. 2X2(8, N= 438)= 24.41. Results – Associations of Eating Patterns Physical symptoms (r/p) Mental symptoms (r/p) Eat home-cooked food 437 -.041 / .387 - .017 / .729 Eat convenience/ frozen food 428 .127 / .009 .102 / .035 Eat fast food 430 .179 / .000 .132 / .006 Eat at full-service restaurants 439 -.004 / .932 - .120 / .012 Eating behavior patterns n Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant. Fast Foods Conv Foods Results – Comparison of Groups n Never engaging in eating pattern M ± SD Engaging in eating pattern M ± SD t statistic F ratio ANCOVA Physical Symptoms 379 37.03 ± 16.44 41.77 ± 18.57 -2.95* 2.92 Mental Symptoms 428 13.44 ± 6.92 14.87 ± 6.78 -2.29* 2.14 Physical Symptoms 383 35.85 ± 16.49 43.31 ± 18.11 -4.11* 8.15**1 Mental Symptoms 430 13.24 ± 6.53 15.08 ± 7.32 -2.91* 7.35**2 Independent t test; p < .05; ** p < .01; groups with same letters differ significantly. 1 ANCOVA adj means: 36.95, 41.97, pƞ2=0.045. 2ANCOVA adj means: 13.30, 15.01, ƞ2=0.017. p Discussion Eating convenience or fast food is related to an increased severity of menopausal symptoms, and those who consumed fast foods reported more severe symptoms than those who did not. • Those who ate fast food had less healthy dietary intake overall32 • Older women who did not eat fast foods reported fewer and less severe symptoms33 • Fast food frequency by women were lower in vitamin A, carotenes and vitamin C density34 32. Wilcox et al, 2013; 33. Moore et al, 2009; 34. Bowman, 2004 Background- Physical Activity • Regular aerobic exercise is associated with improved menopause symptoms, including anxiety and depression 35 • Physically inactive menopausal women have more depressed mood, memory/ concentration problems, vasomotor symptoms than physically active women 36 35. Luoto et. al, 2012; 36. Mansikkamaki et. al, 2015 Methods • “Considering a 7-day period, how many times on average do you do the following kinds of EXERCISE for more than 15 minutes during your free time?” (Responses 0-20x/week) Strenuous (heart beats rapidly) • jogging, hockey, soccer, basketball, cross-country skiing, judo, roller blading, vigorous swimming, vigorous long distance cycling • Moderate (not exhausting) Mild (minimal effort) • fast walking, baseball, tennis, easy bicycling, volleyball, easy swimming, alpine skiing, dancing • such as golf, bowling, easy walking Total exercise: (Mild X 3) + (Mod X 5) + (Stren X 9) Results – Comparison of Groups OMN n=248 VEG n=151 VG n=123 Means ± SD Means ± SD Means ± SD Mild 4.88 ± 3.13 5.22 ± 3.30 5.41 ± 3.54 0.314 Moderate 3.10 ± 2.36 3.35 ± 2.42 3.67 ± 2.86 0.127 Strenuous 1.61 ± 1.31a 2.28 ± 1.84 1.92 ± 1.71a 0.0031 Total 45.11 ± 22.98a 55.04 ± 28.36 49.68 ± 25.51a ANOVA test; groups with same letters differ significantly. 1 F ratio= 6.3, ƞ2= 0.18. 2 F ratio= 6.5, ƞ2= 0.28 p value 0.0022 Results - Associations with Symptoms Physical Symptoms r/p value Mental Symptoms r/p value Variable N Mild Moderate Strenuous 459 459 459 -.086 / .066 -.166 / .000 -.109 / .020 -.032 / .490 -.175 / .000 -.073 / .116 Total 459 -.177 / .000 -.140 / .003 Pearson’s correlation coefficients; p<.05 is significant. Results- Comparison of Groups Total Ex Moderate Ex n Low activity Medium activity High activity F ratio Adj F ratio Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Mean ± SD Physical Symptoms 268 41.18 ± 17.41 39.95 ± 18.19 34.64 ± 15.93 8.33 2.11 Mental Symptoms 268 15.10 ± 7.13a 14.64 ± 6.87 b 11.81 ± 6.01ab 8.97* 4.62*1 Physical Symptoms 409 14.75 ± 6.75a 14.66 ± 7.13 12.79 ± 6.59a 3.96* 5.07*2 Mental Symptoms 409 42.40 ± 18.33abc 39.78 ± 17.04abc 34.95 ± 16.52abc 7.43* 3.26*3 ANOVA, p<.05; groups with same letters differ significantly. 1ANCOVA adj means: 14.88 , 14.77, 11.92, ƞ2= 0.038; 2ANCOVA adj means: 14.82 , 14.67, 12.71, p 2 3 2 pƞ = 0.022. ANCOVA adj means: 41.12, 40.03, 35.91, pƞ = 0.016. Discussion Moderate exercise (and total) was associated with lower severity of menopausal symptoms, and those who reported not engaging in moderate exercise had more mental symptoms. • Those who reported less total exercise had more menopausal symptom severity than those who reported more total exercise. • Association of aerobic exercise and fewer physical and mental symptoms in menopause studies 37,38 37. Kim, 2014; 38. Gutierrez, 2012 Key Findings • Vegans report lower severity of physical menopausal symptoms than omnivores • Multiple factors were associated with lower severity of menopausal symptoms Decreased Symptom Severity Increased Symptom Severity Vegan Diet Age BMI Sleep Hours Social Support Physical Activity Education Sweets, Fast & Convenience Foods, Grapes, Coffee, Milk, Orange/Grape Juices, Soda, Green/Black Tea, Dark Chocolate, Beef Berries, Tree fruit, Spinach, Pomegranate Juice, Plant Omega-3 Strengths and Limitations • Strengths • • • Large sample size Exploration of a topic with limited previous research Included many data points • Limitations • • • • • • Length and personal nature of questions Self-reported data Retrospective Food frequency only Low generalizability Correlational study Conclusion • A plant-based diet may ease the menopausal transition • Being physically active and healthier eating habits (“slow” food) may also be beneficial Images courtesy of sirrichards.com and tattly.com Future Research • Experimental study with vegan vs omnivore diet in menopausal women • Duration of adherence to a vegan diet in menopausal women • Investigation of premenstrual symptoms and plant-based diet Questions? Thank you for listening! Image courtesy of publicdomainpictures.net